Google+
Close
Fraud at Obamaphone, Inc.
A provider of government-subsidized cell phones cuts plenty of corners in its applications.


Text  


Strode says he has since quit TerraCom, and he’s taking college classes to become a pastor or social worker. But he says the company never fully paid him the commission he earned. A current Lifeline user himself, Strode says some users really do need help paying for a phone.

But he says he also noticed that “there were many people who already had cell phones, like their own personal cell phones, but that didn’t matter. It was [our job] to get the phones out.”

Advertisement
Strode’s story may help explain why, when Scripps National Investigative Team obtained TerraCom Lifeline applications and interviewed 51 people listed on them in person, all but one said their signatures were forged. Most of the people had never heard of TerraCom. Some had owned Lifeline phones from other vendors, but others said they had never applied for a subsidized cell phone.

The Scripps National Investigative Team also discovered that several Lifeline phones were registered under addresses of vacant homes in Indiana. Six TerraCom applications were under the names of men in a Milwaukee homeless shelter, who also claim their applications were forged.

But earlier this summer, TerraCom’s chief operating officer, Dale Schmick, told Indiana officials that TerraCom followed a verification protocol to ensure that phones were not approved for applications that listed addresses of abandoned buildings or homeless shelters. (According to the Lifeline rules, applicants who live in homeless shelters must fill out a worksheet verifying that they are economically separate from any other residents there.)

This is not the first time TerraCom has come under scrutiny for its practices. Earlier this year, the Scripps Investigative Team discovered that confidential data regarding more than 170,000 TerraCom Lifeline subscribers was put online, including Social Security numbers and financial information.

In April, Indiana’s Utility Regulatory Commission launched an investigation about how TerraCom “has been able to accomplish such rapid growth in the State of Indiana and whether the practices involved are compliant with the Commission’s Order and goal of minimizing waste, fraud, and abuse.”

Oklahoma and Texas are also making inquiries about the company. In February, TerraCom and its affiliate, YourTel, agreed to pay a settlement of more than $1 million after an FCC investigation found some of the company’s customers had received more than one phone, which is against the Lifeline program rules.

In July, TerraCom said they had laid off 700 people in 21 states, their “entire sales staff.” But National Review Online spoke with a salesman this week who claimed he was still working at TerraCom, and had been there for more than a year. Strode says many of the commissioned TerraCom employees he had worked with went to SafeLink and other Lifeline vendors after being laid off.

TerraCom is not the biggest Lifeline provider by a long stretch, but anecdotes, audits, and reports continue to reveal widespread fraud and abuse throughout the program. And Lifeline’s costs have increased by 166 percent in the past five years.

What began as a program for the poor has quickly devolved into corporate welfare, but like many federal initiatives, this deeply flawed program is almost impossible to shut down. A simple start would be to bar repeat abusers like TerraCom.

— Jillian Kay Melchior is a Thomas L. Rhodes Fellow for the Franklin Center for Government and Public Integrity.



Text  


Sign up for free NRO e-mails today:

NRO Polls on LockerDome

Subscribe to National Review