RNC’s Data Push Greeted with Skepticism
The GOP is trying to become more data-savvy, but the path is not always smooth.

Para Bellum Labs YouTube video


Eliana Johnson

‘The future’s already here, it’s just not evenly distributed yet,” Chuck DeFeo, the Republican National Committee’s chief digital officer, tells me. He’s talking about the Democratic party’s advantage in the realm of data analytics, which in the 2012 presidential election helped propel President Obama to victory over Mitt Romney.

With the midterm elections in sight, the RNC last week unveiled Para Bellum Labs — para bellum is Latin for “prepare for war” — an initiative designed to help the party and its candidates bridge the technology gap. DeFeo describes Para Bellum as a startup company housed within the RNC.

Within the broader conservative movement, the effort is being greeted with a mixture of hope and skepticism. While digital startups have proliferated on the left, some wonder whether a party committee is capable of fostering the sort of culture that breeds technological innovation. Others say the party’s decision to prohibit insurgent candidates from accessing its data will inhibit progress.

Regardless, the RNC is now focused on staffing its in-house innovation hub, and it is recruiting hard. In a highly produced YouTube video, the RNC showcases cheery Para Bellum employees — 14 of them, to date — singing the company’s praises from behind sleek Apple computers. “We are here to push the envelope when it comes to how you manage, analyze, and take advantage of data,” says Azarias Reda, the RNC’s newly hired chief data officer. “The cool thing about this is that I am literally trying to work to elect the next president,” another employee says.

Nearly a thousand résumés have poured in since Para Bellum’s February 4 launch. At the same time, talent scouts are scouring the West Coast for digital gurus willing to forsake jobs at traditional Silicon Valley startups to help revive the fortunes of the GOP.

The RNC began, at the behest of donors, to turn its attention to data analytics in the wake of the 2012 election. It brought in Facebook’s Andy Barkett as chief technology officer in June of last year; DeFeo as chief data officer in July; and Reda, a Ph.D. in computer science and a LinkedIn alumnus, just last month.

DeFeo talks about effecting a cultural shift within the RNC, of fostering an environment where there is an “imperative to innovate” and to “propel yourself forward faster.” “We’re a startup in every sense of the word, except we didn’t form an LLC,” he says. Para Bellum also differs in another important regard: It is part of the national committee and, while it is funded to the tune of about $17 million, the risk-reward calculus of a typical venture-capital-backed start-up is absent.

On the data front, much of the day-to-day drudge work is being performed by Data Trust, the for-profit venture established by a handful of former GOP heavyweights including former RNC chairmen Mike Duncan, Jim Nicholson, and Ed Gillespie. Its links to the RNC run deep: Barkett, the RNC’s chief technology officer, serves simultaneously as CTO of Data Trust.

The company was created in 2011 to shoulder the cost of maintaining and improving the party’s voter file, a list of registered voters knit together from local election rolls. As a part of the RNC’s new focus on data analytics, Data Trust is now building a data-management tool known as VRM — voter relationship management — the primary user interface to the RNC’s data, which will allow campaign volunteers and others to map neighborhoods, create walk lists, and feed the data they gather back into the system.

Setting up Data Trust, party officials grappled with how much influence and access to afford outside forces, like a rival Koch data initiative known as i360 (previously called Themis) and tea-party groups that often back candidates trying to buck sitting Republicans. Though the RNC’s interests initially prevailed, personnel moves indicate that the party’s grip on Data Trust may be loosening. Executive director and former RNC chief of staff Anne Hathaway is reportedly no longer with the company, and Mike Duncan, who was serving as chairman of Data Trust’s board of directors, no longer holds that position. Data Trust president Johnny DeStefano did not respond to a request for comment.

Para Bellum isn’t the first GOP attempt to step up its tech game; it’s only the latest. It’s in part because previous attempts to centralize the party’s voter file — initiatives like Voter Vault and Data Center — didn’t meet with much success that many are casting a skeptical eye on Para Bellum’s dramatic rollout.

One senior Republican digital strategist tells me that in all his years working in GOP politics, he has yet to tap Data Trust or its predecessors, “mostly because I can get better information elsewhere.” He’s doubtful the party’s latest undertaking will meet with much success, he says, because “I’ve been flirted with by this girl enough that, at this point, I don’t think I’m going to get her phone number.” The strategist, a male in his 30s, tells me, “I’m probably a 67-year-old woman in GOP data.”

Critics of the RNC’s effort also level more substantive challenges. They question whether a political party, subject to limitations on soft-money contributions and the crushing demands of electoral politics, is capable of incubating a startup culture that will breed technological innovation. They also oppose the party’s decision to limit access to its voter file.


Sign up for free NRO e-mails today:

NRO Polls on LockerDome

Subscribe to National Review