Google+
Close
A Tired and Poor Speech
Obama plays election-year politics on immigration.


Text  


Michael Barone

‘Years before the statue was built,” Barack Obama began the peroration of his July 1 speech on immigration, Emma Lazarus “imagined what it could mean.”

Actually, the French sculptor Bartholdi was at work on the Statue of Liberty before Lazarus published her famous “give me your tired” poem in 1883. (The statue was assembled in New York Harbor two years later and dedicated in 1886.)

The speech itself was similarly misleading. Obama, as he so often does, told us we must start “being honest about the problem and getting past the false debates that divide the country rather than bring it together.” But even as presenting a fair description of some immigration issues, Obama got in some false debating of his own.

Advertisement
He criticized the “ill conceived” Arizona law authorizing state and local law-enforcement officers to ascertain the legal status of those stopped for other reasons, just as federal officials already can, and presented two serious arguments against it — that it discourages cooperation with local police and subjects Hispanic-appearing Americans to questions others would not be asked.

But he also said it would put pressure on state and local budgets without stating how (isn’t that Arizona’s problem?) and seeks to “enforce rules that ultimately are unenforceable.” But federal law has required legal immigrants to carry proof of status for decades, and if that law is unenforceable, we might as well throw up our hands.

Obama went back in history to take shots at the Alien and Sedition Acts, repealed in 1802, and the Chinese Exclusion Act, repealed in 1943. He was apparently trying to depict America as unwelcoming to immigrants, even though the nation has welcomed more immigrants than any other.

But the most misleading thing about the speech was Obama’s attempt to put the onus of non-action on the party currently in the minority in both the Senate and House.

“The majority of Democrats are ready to move forward,” he said, though this is far from apparent. House speaker Nancy Pelosi has refused to bring the issue up until the Senate acts, out of unwillingness to ask her Democrats to cast tough votes, though she was willing to do that a year ago on the cap-and-trade bill — evidently, a higher priority for her — and this year asked them to cast tough votes for the Senate-passed health-care bill.



Text  


Sign up for free NRO e-mails today:

NRO Polls on LockerDome

Subscribe to National Review