Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

May 28 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew


New on NRO . . .
Close
Canada Stands Up to Iran
The theocrats do not succeed in intimidating our neighbor to the north.

By Clifford D. May


Archive Latest RSS Send
Text  

Last week, Canada’s Free Thinking Film Society — love that name — was scheduled to screen Iranium, a new documentary about the regime that has ruled Iran since 1979, its drive to acquire nuclear weapons, and the dangers that poses to the West. But then the Iranian embassy complained and — coincidently — threats and “suspicious letters” were received at the National Archives in Ottawa, where the event was to take place. The Archives cancelled the screening and shut the building. Archives spokeswoman Pauline Portelance explained: “We deemed the risk associated with the event was a little too high.”

Apparently, however, officials above her pay grade recognized that allowing Iranian theocrats to set the limits of free speech in Canada’s capital would run an even higher risk. It was given to Minister of Heritage James Moore to deliver a Churchillian response.“This movie will be shown, the agreement will be kept,” he said. “We will not be moving it to a different facility, we’re not bending to any pressure. People need to be kept safe, but we don’t back down to people who try to censor people by threats of violence. Canada does not accept attempts from the Iranian Embassy to dictate what films will and will not be shown in Canada.”

Advertisement

The Canadian screening of Iranium has now been rescheduled for early February. Will Iran’s rulers and supporters accept that decision? Or will they escalate the conflict? While we’re waiting for the answer, it’s worth recalling that the Islamic Republic has a long history of attempting to enforce its will extraterritorially. As early as 1989, the Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, who had led Iran’s revolution ten years earlier, issued a fatwa against a British subject, Salman Rushdie, because Khomeini considered Rushie’s novel, The Satanic Verses, blasphemous. The fatwa called for Rushdie to be executed by any Muslim who could manage the task.

That might have been expected: As Iranium makes clear, Khomeini’s revolution was not just against the Shah of Iran. It was intended for export — and not only to countries in which Muslims are in the majority.

Khomeini’s ambitious goal then, and his successors’ goal now, is “world revolution,” the creation of a universal and “holy” government and the downfall of all others. “Islam is good for you,” Khomeini said. “It is good for the world.” He said this even as — in Stalinist fashion — he was executing at home and assassinating abroad not just those who opposed him but also those who might one day oppose him.

I am among those interviewed in Iranium, along with several other Foundation for Defense of Democracies experts. Also providing analysis and insight: scholar Bernard Lewis, former CIA director Jim Woolsey, Sen. Jon Kyl, and former ambassador John Bolton. But it is really Iran’s despots who tell the story.

For example, in 1980, war broke out between Iran and Iraq. Khomeini sent Iranian children on foot to clear minefields so that regular troops and tanks could pass after. How could a man of faith justify that? He was guaranteeing their entry into Paradise. Iran’s current president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, finds poetry in such carnage. “No art is more beautiful,” he is seen in the film telling a group of his acolytes, “more divine and more everlasting” than “the art of martyrdom.”

Khomeini’s successor, the Supreme Leader — an audacious title — Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, is candid: America is not just Iran’s enemy; America is the “enemy of Allah” and “the Great Satan.”

It is difficult for us, for Westerners, children of the Enlightenment, to believe that there are rulers of great nations who take such ideas seriously. But if you watch and listen to them — not least in this documentary — it becomes clear that they do. What does that mean for policy? It means that diplomacy, outreach, engagement, and carefully crafted speeches showing respect and apologizing for “grievances” will have limited utility.

Truth be told, Americans have been reaching out to Iran’s theocrats for more than 30 years. Khomeini came to power on Jimmy Carter’s watch. Carter was by no means hostile to him and his revolution. On the contrary, Carter’s U.N. ambassador, Andrew Young, called Khomeini “some kind of saint.” William Sullivan, the U.S. ambassador in Tehran, compared Khomeini to Gandhi. A State Department spokesman at that time worried about the possibility of a military coup against Khomeini, saying that would be “most dangerous for U.S. interests. It would blow away the moderates and invite the majority to unite behind a radical faction.”

In response, Khomeini and his followers, as seen in the film, chanted not only “Death to America!” but also “Death to Carter!” And, of course, less than a year after Khomeini came to power, his followers took over the U.S. embassy, which Khomeini called a “center for corruption,” holding its occupants hostage for 444 days — not exactly the kind of action Gandhi would have endorsed.

Seizing an embassy is an act of war.  Carter’s response was, as Bernard Lewis characterized it, “feeble.” Khomeini was gratified to discover that “Americans cannot do a damn thing.”

1   2   Next >
Text  

You Might Also Like...

Malkin: Obama’s Land of the LOST

Lowry: Unleash Biden!

Charen: Obama’s Education Hypocrisy -- Again



COMMENTS   23

EXPAND  

   01/27/11 09:19
   01/27/11 10:04

It's about time that someone (anyone) would stand up to the consummate evil of the Iranian regime. Let's hope this film will receive wide distribution in Western countries.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/27/11 10:11

What continues to astound me is, while Iran pursues nuclear weapons with the announced intention of using them on Israel (the "one-bomb state" in Ahmedinejad's words) nobody: not the Palestinians, not their Islamic brothers, and not the useful idiots in the West, seem to have considered that when Israel is consumed in nuclear fire - the Palestinians go too.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/27/11 10:38

Call me a tad paranoid, but if I order the DVD, is Julian Assange going to find out and publish my name and address to The Boys of Terror in Tehran?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
mbas
   01/27/11 11:26

Hey U.S.- shall we stand with our brothers in Canada, or are we weak in the knees? Did history (Nationalist Party in Germany in the 1930's for instance) not teach us anything about allowing ruthless idealogues to run over freedoms, laws, and liberties? Why are we in the U.S. so afraid to label the activities and goals of the current Iranian leaders (political, and Muslim) as DANGEROUS and NOT-TO-BE-TOLERATED? We really must pressure this administration to put down the rhetoric, and pick up the weapons at our disposal. Clearly, an nuclear-bomb wielding Iran cannot be tolerated under its current government. It simply cannot be allowed to even continue as it is. We must act.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Thomas_L.....
   01/27/11 12:37

"virgins sentenced to capital punishment are routinely raped prior to execution. This practice also is based on theology: Virgins go to Paradise, a reward enemies of the regime do not deserve."

I can barely imagine a more evil deed
based on a more evil concept. If Islam condones this with Allah's approval, then he is indeed the moongod and Islam is nothing more than mono-paganism.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Mary Blatt
   01/27/11 12:44

Everyone shy's away from ANYTHING that might offend a muslim. The media slams Christianity but is silent about islam and terrorism. Why is that? Because the muslims are barbarians that are raised to react to any criticism about their so called "sacred" Allah with violence and murder. Simple enough for you??? These people do not assimilate into foreign societies. They should not be allowed to immigrate since their sole purpose is to over run, then conquer where ever they go. And keep your "racism" comments to yourself... this is just the truth.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
robins111
   01/27/11 15:18

Our Prime Minster on 'I'm a dinner Jacket', Iran

External Link 

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Barbie
   01/27/11 16:30

Math Question *
10 + 1 = ???

Math is hard!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Edmund Onward James
   01/27/11 17:27

Indeed, I am proud of Minister of Heritage James Moore.

However, what concerns me is that the Islamists have infiltrated and utilize the stealth approach or the soft-sell of Islam, a religion of peace.

There are problems in many of our Canadian universities. The Muslim protesters were more than rude with Jewish students.

Ottawa University forced Ann Coulter not to speak there, because the president said there were rules.

Nonetheless, our Prime Minister and ministers do not fear the belicose Arab and Muslim dictators. They even faced up to the United Arab Emerates and there demand for more airline flights to Canada.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Riss
   01/27/11 20:30

This is what happens due to most of the world being as ignorant of the true religion, Christianity, as it is of the many counterfeits, e.g. Islam, secularism being one of many others, what the Founding Fathers knew were and rejected as lies. Of course today's tools are absolutely sure there's nothing absolutely sure! and say this self-refuting nonsense with a straight face. Some things are so ridiculous and absurd only an intellectual is dumb/brainwashed enough to believe it!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/27/11 20:48

Is this the same Canada that recently banned an old Dire Straits song because it used an unkind word for gays? That ran Mark Steyn up against a hate speech tribunal for deviating from the requisite multicultural orthodoxy?

Not that I should be knocking our friends north of the border, we've got plenty of our own inanity down here in the USA.

On another note, how bizarre is it that the Iranian regime needs to threaten people with death and violence to conceal the truth of its odious agenda? If their brand of Islam is so good for the world, why aren't they actually owning up to it, singing its virtues, supporting films like "Iranium?"

I suppose it's because, like thugs and cowards smart enough to know theirs is an odious agenda, they must resort to less forthright means to further it.

So three cheers for the Canadians, for this small token of support for a better agenda and, hopefully, some new found testicular fortitude.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
pconnb
   10/09/11 10:44

Yes, this is the same Canada. Oh, don't forget:
1) Gay people in the US military are bleeding and dying so you and I can talk with civility and without fear.
2) This is the same Canada who is your largest trading partner in the world - and shares the longest undefended border in the world.
3) This is the same Canada who has always had a spine - standing with you in two world wars, Korea, and now in Afghanastan, where we are also bleeding and dying...with you.
4)And yes, this is the same Canada who gave shelter to your doplomats after the Iranian Revolution in 1979 - smuggled them out of that country - bringing them home to safety at the risk of our own safety and our lives. We've always had a "spine" and continue to be your friends and allies.
Just because we don't think exactly like the USA in certain situations and in regards to certain issues - doesn't mean we are wrong...it just means that sometimes we are different.....My Friend. :)

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
pconnb
   10/09/11 10:55

A lot of difference between a Dire Straits song and the Iranians building a nuclear bomb. And by the way - there are gay soldiers in the US military who are in Afghanastan, bleeding and dying right beside everybody else.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/28/11 10:09

I am pleased to see some Canadian politicians still have a spine and are willing to stand up for free speech (unlike their counterparts in Eurabia). The bottom line is that Islam today (and maybe at all times) is not a religion. It is a political ideology masquerading as a religion; it is a wolf in sheep's clothing.

What I find surprising is that Leftists (who call themselves, liberal) seem to loves it, even though it is misogynistic, homophobic, pediophiliac, and murderous. These are things for which the Left takes Western Civilization to task, yet for Islam, not a peep of criticism.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/28/11 11:25

Is Canada the new America?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 MAFV
   01/28/11 12:04

Mr. May, thank you for the work. Good for Canada!!! The clash with Islam is coming regardless of what we say or do...their will to war with the West is not about politics; it is about religion...whether we "nation build" or pull out, they're coming and will continue to do so until the infadels are defeated...the West must war or surrender!!!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/28/11 13:39

There's certainly no talking to the folks in charge, that's for sure. But I still hold out hope that we can reach and support more moderate secular voices like those seen in the last Iranian revolt and the one going on in Egypt as we speak.

Unfortunately, I am not hopeful they will ever get enough of a foothold to cause any real change....and even the moderate voice are a bit to theocratic for my taste. But what else can we do? Blow them all up?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Pack Fancher
   01/28/11 18:28

Where can "Iranium" be viewed in the US?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
TomMikePat
   01/28/11 20:19

So where can we see this movie if we can't drop what we're doing and hoof it to Ottawa in February?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Load More Comments

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact