Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

May 28 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew


New on NRO . . .
Close
Unequal Protection You Can Believe In
Obamacare waivers violate the Constitution’s guarantee of equal protection.

By Deroy Murdock


About Author Archive Latest RSS Send
Text  

Twenty-eight of these United States — encompassing 164 million people, 53 percent of America’s population, and 285 Electoral College votes — are suing the federal government to stop Obamacare. This litigation challenges the constitutionality of Obamacare’s mandate that individuals purchase health insurance. The U.S. Supreme Court is likely to decide, once and for all, whether the Constitution’s Commerce Clause empowers Congress to force Americans to conduct commerce.

Shattering the Obamacare Death Star, however, may require slamming it from multiple directions. Hence, an additional legal strategy should address this law’s apparent violation of the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause — which explicitly applies to the states, but which the Supreme Court has more or less hitched onto the federal government as well.

Advertisement

Obamacare is not being enforced equally at all. As of February 9, the Obama administration had granted 915 waivers, mainly to influential organizations, major companies, and pro-Democratic labor unions. Those less lucky or less well connected have a different option: Obey Obamacare.

According to the Health and Human Services Department, these waiver recipients claim that complying with new “annual dollar-limit requirements” would cost their group health plans “either a large increase in premiums or a significant decrease in access to coverage.” But unlike the objective income brackets that trigger diverse tax rates, “large” and “significant” are subjective criteria. This gives HHS bureaucrats ample opportunity to treat the insured unequally.

Major waiver recipients and their enrollees include the Carpenters Health and Welfare Fund (20,500), Service Employees International Union Local 25 (31,000), Darden Restaurants (34,000), Aetna (209,423), CIGNA (265,000), and the United Federation of Teachers (351,000). Union members represent 43.1 percent of the 2,443,047 enrollees included in these waivers.

“Obamacare was sold as all benefit — no downside,” Rep. Cliff Stearns (R., Fla.) said Wednesday at a waiver-focused House oversight hearing. And now, “2.5 million people literally need to be protected from the devastating effects of Obamacare.”

“The selective dispensations to Obamacare’s mandates that Obama so far has given to various special interests — especially his union friends — fly in the face of the Constitution’s Equal Protection Clause,” says Roger Pilon, the libertarian Cato Institute’s vice president for legal affairs. “But they’re just the other side of the ‘Cornhusker Kickback,’ the ‘Louisiana Purchase,’ and other last-minute shenanigans that Obama and congressional Democrats employed to get this travesty passed in the first place.”

“The very interests who supported this law and helped ram it through Congress are now applying for waivers,” Betsy McCaughey, president of Defend Your Healthcare (defendyourhealthcare.us), told the Conservative Political Action Conference in Washington on February 12. “If government has the power to grant waivers, it has the power to deny them and destroy any business. Americans never should have to slink and slither to the White House for exemptions, like supplicants.” McCaughey will ask President Obama to give waivers to everyone who requests them via her website.

1   2   Next >
Text  

You Might Also Like...

Editors: Pressuring the Chief

Lopez: Women of Barnard -- Cheerleading Squad

Malkin: Obamacare’s Patient-Dumping, Privacy-Meddling Scheme

Capretta: Obamacare Hurts Seniors

Franck: The Founders Loved Mandates?

Holtz-Eakin& Nussle: Medicare’s Dirty Little Secret



COMMENTS   10

EXPAND  

Generii
   02/18/11 21:15

Has anyone noticed all the NEW hatred and discontent in America since 2008?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/19/11 10:53

Thanks for your article. I agree that we should pursue the equal protection angle. The issue I see is that there were no provisions for waivers in the law, so granting them is arbitrary which gives far too much power to HHS specifically and the Executive branch generally. This article also touches on the issue of waivers and granting too much power to the government, External Link 

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/19/11 11:31

I agree that the equal protection aspect needs to be looked at. There is no provision for waivers in the law, so granting waivers is done arbitrarily. This gives too much power to HHS and the Executive branch to award these waivers for political reasons. This article External Link  touches on this subject as well.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/19/11 14:00

Obama is the most divisive president of our time.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 MAFV
   02/20/11 00:24

Mr.Murdock, thanks for the work.

"Unequal Protection You Can Believe In"...and the surprise is?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
kendralucas
   02/20/11 06:36

Correspondence The authors avouch they compel ought to no Buy cheap co-Diovan competing monetary Order prandin interests. Morton Lippmann Kazuhiko Ito Polina Maciejczyk Lung Chi Chen New York University School Buy cheap zithromax of Buy cheap otibact Medicine Nelson Buy cheap human Growth Hormone Institute of Environmental Purchase amoxicillin Medicine Tuxedo, New York E mail: lippmann@env. Med. Nyu. Edu Jing Shiang Hwang Institute of Discount levitra Jelly online Statistical Science Academia Sinica Order nizoral online Taipei, Taiwan REFERENCES Lippmann M, Ito K, Hwang JS, Discount cheap amoxicillin Maciejczyk P, Chen LC. (2006). Cardiovascular effects of Purchase kamagra nickel in ambient alike. Environ Health Perspect Buy actonel 114:1662–1669. NTP. . Toxicology and Carcinogenesis Studies of Buy cheap strattera online Nickel Sulfate Hexahydrate (CAS No. 10101 0) in Discount kamagra F344 Rats and B6C3F1 Mice (Inhalation Studies). TR . Research Triangle Park, NC:National Toxicology Program. Prows DR, McDowell SA, Aronow BJ, Buy cheap amoxicillin online Leikauf GD. . Genetic susceptibility to Buy viagra Plus nickel induced pointed lung harm. Chemosphere 5:1139–1148. ERRATUM In Figure 4 of Lippmann et al. [Environ Health Perspect 114:1662–1669 (2006)], the latchkey was repair in the Purchase periactin archetype manuscript published online but was faulty in the final understanding. The dashed Order kamagra lines should intimate filtered disclose, and the concentrated lines should signify CAPS. The corrected trust in appears deeper. A Filtered freshen CAPs 650 Buy classic ED Pack (Viagra+Cialis+Levitra) online HR (beats/min) 600 550 500 7/14 8/11 9/8 10/6 11/3 12/1 Discount diflucan online Discount cheap zyprexa 12/29 Date B logSDNN (msec) –4. 0 –4. 5 –5. 7/14 8/11 9/8 10/6 11/3 Order cheap xalatan 12/1 12/29 Date Figure Order zithromax 4. Daily Discount geodon faction averaged HR ( A ) and Purchase brahmi online Order cheap albenza online Purchase cialis Jelly online HRV (logSDNN) (B) in mice Buy celexa online exposed to CAPs or filtered mood. EHP regrets the indiscretion. A 294 VOLUME 115 Order cheap singulair online | NUMBER 6 | June 2007 Purchase zetia • Environmental Order geodon online Health Perspectives .

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/20/11 08:51

I went to the link for the list of the 915 waivers granted by the administration. I was stunned to see that the Union plans that have received waivers meant that over one million enrolled Union members have been granted a waiver. By listing 915 employers, you are understating the problem. A million card carrying Union members are not subject to Obama Care. Go to the link and check it out!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/20/11 14:59

It stinks!
That legislators don't personally take part in social security or this health care deal is no small matter. It's taxation without representation .. it's why there was a tea party.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
amdriven2live
   02/20/11 15:32

What needs to happen is someone with "standing" who has been denied a wavier needs to sue to show the inequality. “If government has the power to grant waivers, it has the power to deny them and destroy any business."
Very well said~great article

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Sherry
   02/23/11 16:14

I think this is one of the most compelling cases against it. Who would have thought that the very people screaming to pass it would be the ones lining up to opt out?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact