Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

May 28 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew


New on NRO . . .
Close
Ambitious Turkey
Reasons and tips for showing our displeasure with Ankara’s neo-Ottomanism

By Daniel Pipes


Archive Latest RSS Send
Text  

A few days ago, Turkey’s foreign minister, Ahmet Davutoğlu, grandiloquently proclaimed that “if the world is on fire, Turkey is the firefighter. Turkey is assuming the leading role for stability in the Middle East.”

Such ambition is new for Ankara. In the 1990s, it contentedly fulfilled its NATO obligations and followed Washington’s lead. Starting about 1996, relations with Israel blossomed. In all, Turkish policy offered an attractive exception to the tyrannical, Islamist, and conspiracist mentality generally dominating Muslim peoples. That the country’s political leaders were corrupt and fumbling seemed of little consequence.

Advertisement

Those faults, however, proved extremely consequential, leading to the repudiation of long-established political parties and the victory of an Islamist party, Adalet ve Kalkınma Partisi (AKP), in the elections of November 2002. By March 2003, in advance of the coming war in Iraq, the new government signaled that a new era had begun by refusing to permit American troops to traverse Turkish territory.

Over the next eight years, Turkish foreign policy became increasingly hostile to the West in general, and to the United States, France, and Israel in particular, as it warmed to governments in Syria, Iran, and Libya. This shift became particularly evident in May 2010, when Ankara both helped Tehran avoid sanctions for its nuclear program and injured Israel’s reputation with the Mavi Marmara–led flotilla.

But the full extent of Ankara’s Middle East ambitions emerged in early 2011, concurrent with the region’s far-reaching upheavals. Suddenly, Turks were ubiquitous. Their recent activities include:

Providing a model: Gül holds that Turkey can have a “great and unbelievable positive effect” on the Middle East — and he has some takers. For example, Rached Ghannouchi, leader of Tunisia’s newly legalized Ennahda movement, has stated: “We are learning from the experience of Turkey, especially the peace that has been reached in the country between Islam and modernity.”

Offering an economic lifeline to Iran: The Turkish president, Abdullah Gül, paid a state visit to Tehran in February, accompanied by a large group of businessmen, capping an evolution whereby, according to the Jamestown Foundation, “Turkey is becoming a major [economic] lifeline for Iran.” In addition, Gül praised the Iranian political system.

Obstructing foreign efforts in Libya: Starting on March 2, the Turkish government objected to any military intervention against Moammar Qaddafi’s regime. “Foreign interventions, especially military interventions, only deepen the problem,” Davutoğlu put it on March 14, perhaps worrying about a similar intervention to protect Kurds in eastern Turkey. When military operations began on March 19, Turkish forces did not take part. Turkish opposition delayed NATO’s engagement in Libya until March 31 and then freighted it with conditions.

Supporting Qaddafi: Turkey’s prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, helped Qaddafi by issuing both demagogic proclamations (“Turkey will never be a party that points a gun at the Libyan people”) and practical proposals (e.g., that Qaddafi salvage his rule by appointing a president). Ankara also offered, according to the Istanbul-based Hürriyet newspaper “to be involved in the distribution of humanitarian aid in Libya, to manage the Benghazi airport and to deploy naval forces to control the area between Benghazi and the Greek island of Crete.” In gratitude, Qaddafi replied, “We are all Ottomans.” In contrast, Libyan rebels fumed at and marched against the Turkish government.

Helping Damascus: In January, Ankara agreed to train Syrian troops. In March, Erdoğan publicly advised Syria’s president, Bashar al-Assad, on how to maintain power, perhaps fearful that Syria’s 1.4 million Kurds might win more autonomy and cause unrest among Turkey’s approximately 15 million Kurds.

Anti-Zionism: Ankara has emerged as the leader in delegitimizing Israel. Davutoğlu tries to unify its enemies while predicting Israel’s disappearance; a government-affiliated organization plans a new Gaza “freedom” flotilla with at least 15 ships taking part; and the deputy prime minister calls for a Libya-style bombing of Israel.

Ankara’s ambitions must be checked. Less provocatively and more intelligently than the Iranian regime, it aspires to reshape Muslim countries in its Islamist image. The opening salvos of this effort have gone well, being both effective and largely unnoticed.

Possible methods to block AKP influence include: expressing displeasure with Ankara’s “neo-Ottomanist” policies; publicly questioning whether Turkish actions are compatible with NATO membership; quietly encouraging opposition parties in the country’s June 2011 elections; and, at this moment of AKP hostility and of Kurdish uprisings in eastern Turkey, reconsidering the delicate question of Kurdish civil rights.

Daniel Pipes is director of the Middle East Forum and Taube distinguished visiting fellow at the Hoover Institution of Stanford University.

Text  

You Might Also Like...

Malkin: Obama’s Land of the LOST

Lowry: Unleash Biden!

Keune: 'Clean Coal' Means No Coal



COMMENTS   12

EXPAND  

Paul Occonail
   04/12/11 04:22

This article is full of biases and discriminative way of the view point to Turkey. I think that the author does not feel comfortable with rising power of Turkey. Why?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/12/11 08:28

Actually, I believe he is lamenting the rapid morphing of a modern, secular Turkey into another theocratic, terror-state like Iran and Syria.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
TROY
   04/12/11 09:27

I guess author really does not know Turkey's History and its huge effects to region.Turkey is fair playmaker in the world..Turkey is no longer "private ryan" since 2003 rejecting iraq missive in Turkish Capitol.Author and his lords must have seen that.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/12/11 14:16

Turkey, the vestige of a vast medieval empire, is attempting, like Russia, to reassert its former glory. Unlike Russia, Turkey is animated by a resurgent Islam, so must be considered the bigger threat to the West.

However, because of Islam, Turkey will likely never become more than a thorn in the side of the West. The religion's inherent backwardness will prevent it from moving forward in the modern world, and within a decade or two it's currently modern infrastructure and western-based technology will look like matchbox toys as they are swept aside by some future Atomic-powered Robot Killing Machine of a future West.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Devin
   04/12/11 17:50

I am totally appalled by this article. It is so clear that the author is oblivious about Turkey and its role in the region. Turkey has a moderately Islamic government but secular and mostly embraced western values and life style. Its economy is booming and it could really be good example in the region that moderate Islam and secular system can coexist while while the country prosper. Why is this bothering some people?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Can Demir
   04/12/11 18:29

A perfect example of google-journalism to be exemplified representing the genre for college journalism students.

Nice way to pack as much against the country in such a short article.

Turkey IS the model, at least the direction. It is 99% Moslem still yet secular. Prosperous but NON-OIL based. Industrial economy able to compete head to head with the best in Europe and Asia.

Iran & Syria are Turkey's 2 largest neighbors. It is only comical to assume that increasing trade and decreasing friction with them is bad. Switch roles, would you be able to shun Canada and Mexico?

Libya - Please read a little bit of the loooong history of Libya and its tribes. Obama was smart to get out of something that will be no different then Afghanistan. France ran into grab contracts from others like Turkey, China, Italy, US.

Anti-Zionism - Whats left to defend of Israel and its Dogs of War who prefer the current bloody status to a solution? And for how many decades now ?

Ohh its only Turks by the way you say? However polls show most European populations are on the same page! Why the big love for the status-quo in America? Could it be the Israeli & Jewish private interest groups and lobbies ?

If US only abstained (stopped vetoing everything thats not pro-Israel regardless how correct it was) from votes in the UN, the United Nations would direct NATO to do in Israel, the same it is doing in Libya...

Israel actions in Palestine are only damaging itself as well as world view against Jews in general. As a people who has suffered so much they should be the first to rise against such treatment but as long as lobbies are there to provide blank checks covering politicians failure-to-learn everyone suffers.

But you already know that...

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/12/11 21:43

Pointing out that Turkey is 99% Muslim is really just an oblique way of referencing their thousand years of atrocities in Anatolia, Armenia, and Thrace.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/13/11 03:43

"By March 2003, in advance of the coming war in Iraq, the new government [refused] to permit American troops to traverse Turkish territory."

This is often stated, but it is not true. Prime Minister Erdogan supported transit, and the great majority of AKP members in the National Assembly voted to authorize transit.

The vote narrowly failed because the opposition parties overwhelmingly voted NO at the behest of French lobbyists.

I have no dispute with the rest of this article, but that error should be put to rest.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/13/11 05:06

Turkey is reverting to its' genocidal, imperialist tradition .The next flotilla they send to provoke Israel will end up on the bottom of the Mediterranean. Supporters of the Turkey talk tough but don't seem to understand , "Zionists" are not the Armenians and can totally obliterate Turkey.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
i2eye
   04/13/11 06:56

This is a really bad article in so many ways. Just the very first sentence under the title show the bias and lack any intent on being fair or correct.

Why is it that Turkey is good when it unconditionally follows the lead of US as the author writes but bad when they follow their own interest such as refusing the troop passage. This is a really silly argument since everyone who knows the situation in Iraq today would have agreed with Turkey. This also goes for all other of your arguments, Turkey has much better position to lead/influence/model for a democratic ME than USA, France or Israel as history has shown over and over agian.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
truth
   06/20/11 03:26

Just like most of the other commentors of this article, I do as well feel that the author is totally bias & anti-Turkish. Turkey & its people will only be stronger and stronger from now on in each and every passing year. Thanks to Erdogan, Turks have waken up and relized their importance & power. This nation was once the biggest super power of the world, and it will inevitably a big player again. You, the Turkish haters, nothing you can do to stop it , but just face to the reality. As Atarurk said " peace at home, peace in the world".

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Musa Can
   03/26/12 19:46

Mr. Pipes, such an article should be well below a man of your stature. This article has so many holes a college student would be able to drive a truck through it.

Have you truly become so delusional that you'd come out with a hit piece this flawed?

I would have expected more from you. You have an axe to grind with Turkey? Great, grind away nice and slow without making yourself look so ridiculous.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact