Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

May 28 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew


New on NRO . . .
Close
The Other Libertarian
Want a small-government Republican? Try Gary Johnson.

By Michael Tanner


Archive Latest RSS Send
Text  

It says something about our political culture that while the mainstream media were obsessed last week with the latest bizarre pronouncements by Donald Trump, another businessman-turned-politician was becoming the first declared Republican presidential candidate, with far less fanfare.

In many ways, former New Mexico governor Gary Johnson is the anti-Trump. While Trump is bombastic and self-aggrandizing, Johnson is self-effacing, often coming across as more wonk than politician. You’re not likely to see him in his own reality show any time soon.

Trump harrumphs about budget deficits and the national debt but in the past has supported single-payer health care and higher taxes. He still opposes the Ryan budget and any substantial entitlement reform. Trump has not put forward a single serious idea for deficit reduction. Johnson too has issues with Ryan’s plan — because it doesn’t go far enough.

Advertisement

Johnson criticizes Republicans for having demagogued Obamacare’s Medicare cuts, because those charges made it harder for Republicans to propose their own needed cuts. And Johnson would cut: He proposes repealing George W. Bush’s Medicare prescription-drug benefit and including current seniors in changes to Medicare.

Johnson would reduce future Social Security benefits by changing the payment formula, indexing it to prices rather than to wages, and he is open to personal accounts. Overall, he calls for cutting government spending by $1.6 trillion this year to bring the budget into balance. That may not be entirely realistic, but it sets a high bar that other candidates will have to respond to.

And, unlike other Republican candidates, Johnson would not exempt defense from the budget knife.

No one can accuse Johnson of being a Johnny-come-lately to government cutting. During his two terms as governor, Johnson vetoed more than 750 pieces of legislation, more than the other 49 governors combined over that period. He left the state with a $1 billion surplus despite cutting taxes more than a dozen times.

On other issues: Johnson is also a strong supporter of school choice and wants to get the federal government out of education. He would repeal Obamacare and advocates the general Republican program of market-based health-care reforms. He opposed TARP and vigorously opposes corporate welfare, including farm subsidies.

Johnson is an economic conservative, not a culture warrior. If social conservatives were upset over Mitch Daniels’s call for a truce on social issues, they are not going to be happy with Johnson: He is pro-choice, though he opposes Medicaid or other taxpayer funding of abortion and his gubernatorial campaigns were endorsed by pro-life groups. He is comfortable with gay marriage. And his support for legalizing marijuana — borne out of being governor of a border state suffering from Mexico’s drug war — will get more than a little play from his opponents.

Still, if he can get through the primaries, that sort of social moderation combined with fiscal conservatism may play well with the sort of suburban swing voters that will be crucial to the GOP’s 2012 prospects.

It also remains to be seen how Johnson’s anti-war stance (he opposed the Iraq war and calls for pulling out of Afghanistan) will play with Republican primary voters. It is worth noting, however, that even among Republicans, polls show support for the war below 60 percent. Independents increasingly favor a pullout.

Still, Johnson has an appealing résumé that can go head-to-head with Trump’s. A triathlete who once climbed Mt. Everest, he built a one-man company into a multi-million-dollar corporation that employed more than 1,000 people.

Johnson remains a very long shot for the Republican nomination. He lacks money and organization. His name recognition is nearly nonexistent. That shot was made smaller still by Ron Paul’s announcement yesterday that he is setting up an exploratory committee for another run, thereby splitting the already modest libertarian vote.

On the other hand, Johnson, unlike Trump, is proposing serious ideas that are likely to influence the debate as it goes forward. In a flawed field, he will force the better-known candidates to defend their positions on spending, health care, and military adventurism. One might think that would be worth almost as much media attention as Trump’s latest birther buffoonery.

Maybe if Governor Johnson went on Dancing with the Stars.

— Michael Tanner is a senior fellow at the Cato Institute and author of Leviathan on the Right: How Big-Government Conservatism Brought Down the Republican Revolution.

Text  

You Might Also Like...

Malkin: Obama’s Land of the LOST

Lowry: Unleash Biden!

Keune: 'Clean Coal' Means No Coal



COMMENTS   11

EXPAND  

SmallGov
   04/27/11 07:53

Excellent guy...sadly, he'd never win the nomination because we're still on this Quixotic chase to ban abortion and the Sisyphus attempts at keeping drugs illegal.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 08:16

All sounds good except the libertarian aspect on foreign policy.
We must live in the real world not the world of John Lennon's Imagine.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 10:51

So far, that's the best list of beliefs I've seen from any potential candidate thus far. Too bad the American public are probably too stupid to adopt this guy's WFB take on marijuana.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 11:05

I'm looking forward to seeing Gov. Johnson st the debates. It is too bad that Ron Paul is probably going to run again, but it will be nice to make the other candidates respond to two libertarian voices at the debates.

Gary Johnson is the real thing and has actually governed successfully as a small government conservative - far more than Pawlenty, Romney or Daniels.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Hugo Schwyzer
   04/27/11 12:27

Gary Johnson is exactly the kind of candidate the GOP desperately needs: fiscally conservative, socially moderate, globally cautious. He'll have my vote.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Jeff Moe
   04/27/11 16:07

Governor Gary Johnson is the real deal, has the talents to tackle the enormity of the budget problem, and won't just "fake" addressing the issue by punting it 10 years down the road like politicians are currently advocating. We don't have another 10 years to ignore this problem. GJ in 2012!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Josh
   04/27/11 18:19

Paul/Johnson ... let's buckle down, keep the vote, and pull the swing with sensible policies.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Roger Nicols
   04/27/11 21:36

Encourage your Democrat friends to vote for Paul or Johnson in the primary. Tell them it will force Obama to me more liberal on the following issues: War, Drugs, Gay Rights.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/29/11 23:45

I wish he had a chance of winning. Sadly, he doesn't. Out of the people running, Johnson would far and away be my choice. Without exaggeration, he has the potential to be the best president since Abraham Lincoln.
That said, unless he actually has a shot at winning the nomination, my vote is probably going to Mitch Daniels, who's the next best thing.
It should be noted that out of the people running, only Johnson and Daniels have an impressive record of actually getting things done.
Sarah Palin wouldn't be able to run a gas station. We need to get serious. We already had a not too bright and not too principled Republican President, this time we need to elect someone with some policy knowledge and success in advancing liberty.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
more of the same
   04/30/11 00:15

I guess he's a libertarian that neo-cons can live with. I distrust him because of his contempt for social conservatism and his foreign policy soft interventionism.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/01/11 15:05

How did he get elected in New Mexico, a state almost as left wing as Maine?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact