Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew


New on NRO . . .
Close
Reagan at Notre Dame
A call to transcendence and duty

By Paul Kengor


Archive Latest E-Mail RSS Send
Text  

For those of us fascinated by Cold War history, the last few months have been a treat, with recognition of two 20th-century giants who played a huge role in peacefully taking down an Evil Empire and ending the longest-running conflict of a bloody century. In February, Americans marked the centennial of the birth of Pres. Ronald Reagan. This May, Catholics marked the beatification of Pope John Paul II.

Advertisement

Even then, that’s just the tip of the historical iceberg. We’re at the 30-year mark of a bunch of events that conservatives in particular should reflect on, instead of just hopping from news cycle to news cycle. The founders of our movement, with the founding editor of National Review among them, would want us to stand athwart history yelling “Stop”; that is, to pause and pay recognition.

In January 1981, Ronald Reagan was inaugurated president. Mere weeks later, on March 30, he was shot. On May 13, John Paul II likewise was shot. Both men, we learned only later, came perilously close to bleeding to death during emergency surgery. Those events would convince the president and the pope that God had spared them for a special — indeed, historical — purpose.

Some of this has been acknowledged in retrospectives in recent weeks. What will not get its due, however, was a special speech given by President Reagan on May 17, 1981, at Notre Dame. And here, I encourage conservatives to listen up and take notes.

The occasion was Notre Dame’s commencement, and Reagan gave the assembled undergrads a lesson to remember, including one of his first presidential predictions on the demise of Communism:

The years ahead are great ones for this country, for the cause of freedom and the spread of civilization. The West won’t contain Communism, it will transcend Communism. . . . It will dismiss it as some bizarre chapter in human history whose last pages are even now being written.

The visionary quality of Reagan’s words is evident only in retrospect. Though no one else was making such audacious predictions, and though many scoffed at Reagan, those last pages were indeed being written. Unbeknownst to the world, Communism’s grip on Eastern Europe would not survive the decade. Even the USSR would disintegrate peacefully. On Dec. 25, 1991, a helpless Mikhail Gorbachev resigned as leader of the USSR, formally turning out the lights.

For Reagan, that process was aided by an indispensable ally, John Paul II, who had been shot only four days before the Notre Dame speech. Reagan asked the Notre Dame faithful to pray for John Paul, and commended him for his recent encyclical attacking Communism.

The speech was crafted by chief speechwriter Tony Dolan. The draft on file at the Reagan Presidential Library (“Presidential Speeches,” Box 1, Folder 7) shows few edits by Reagan. This was a surprise, given that Reagan heavily rewrote many of these major foreign-policy speeches (especially Dolan’s Evil Empire draft). When I pointed this out in the original version of this article, posted on May 16, Dolan quickly corrected me (through the Comments section below, and in a personal e-mail). He told me I was “too generous” about his role in this speech. “Though the archives don’t show it,” clarified Dolan, “the Gipper did a complete rewrite of my draft on this one. And then called me to apologize. Geez.” Dolan summed up: “RR did a complete rewrite.”

That makes sense, given that this talk is so uniquely and personally Reagan. It began with lengthy extemporaneous remarks, and then wove together quotes and anecdotes, impromptu and prewritten, establishing Reagan’s theme of a larger cause and challenge — a challenge for all of America. It was a complex, enigmatic speech that can only be fully understood today, long after Reagan’s presidency and with current knowledge of what Reagan was secretly pursuing behind the scenes. Reagan telegraphed its unorthodox nature in these opening lines:

The temptation is great to use this forum as an address on a great international or national issue. . . . Indeed, this is somewhat traditional. So, I wasn’t surprised when I read in several reputable journals that I was going to deliver an address on foreign policy and the economy. I’m not going to talk about either.

This wasn’t quite true. Or maybe it was. Reagan’s objective was much larger — yes, untraditional — as if transcending the economy and foreign policy. Reagan drew upon dramatic remarks by Winston Churchill: “When great causes are on the move in the world, we learn we are spirits, not animals, and that something is going on in space and time, and beyond space and time, which, whether we like it or not, spells duty.”

1   2   3   Next >
Text  

You Might Also Like...

Malkin: Obama’s Land of the LOST

Lowry: Unleash Biden!

Keune: 'Clean Coal' Means No Coal



COMMENTS   16

EXPAND  

   05/16/11 09:20

Mr. Reagans speech at Notre Dame was one of the best(Commencement) Presidential speeches I've heard in my lifetime. It was an address given by a MAN, so I don't expect the powers that be at NRO to accept it for it's importance.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 RobL
   05/16/11 09:46

Such a contrast...

Thinking in football metaphors, President Reagan truly was the Gipper, he had full command and control of his game and willed his nation to victory.

President Obama on the other hand does not. He could have transformed his presidency following the gutsy and successful call to kill Bin Laden. Within a day though he wavered on the photo release while charging forward with operation detail releases (likely breaking some OPSEC rules along way). He trumpeted about not spiking the football exactly as he attempted to spike the football but couldn’t as his team changed the details hourly.

Instead of an overtime game winning touchdown to highlight his presidency, President Obama has fumbled the football with these blatant self serving shenanigans and likely his presidency as well.

Ronald Reagan will be remembered as a legendary president, no Hall of Fame awaits President Obama.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/16/11 11:38

This shows why its hard to apply Reagan today. It is difficult to apply a vision of man with God to inspire a cause greater than ourselves against tyranny that bases itself on Islam to defend a belief in a secular order. We cannot easily stand athwart against history with a medieval opponent until we can give an account one fits with the other.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Larmeau
   05/16/11 13:18
   05/16/11 13:28

Make no mistake, Gnu, about the perceived lack of "religion" of the Soviet Union. Their god was the State, and they worshipped it just as fanatically as Islamic terrorists worship Allah. The key word, in my opinion, is "totalitarian." That word makes it not just easy, but necessary to apply Reagan today. His principles are just as true and applicable today as ever, whether facing the Soviets, or some power-hungry mullah.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
ddot
   05/16/11 14:12

What a contrast between a President Reagan and a President Obama. One a visionary American, the other a visionary Utopian. One a stalwart leader of the West, keenly aware of the indispensable value of our unique ideas and institutions, the other a devoted follower of an undefined something else, which must be better.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/16/11 15:07

Thank you Mr. Kengor for the post and the reminder. A service to us all.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/16/11 16:00

Paul Kengor is fast establishing himself as the "go to" historian of the Reagan Era.
But here I must rush into print and say he is too generous about my role in this speech. Though the archives don't show it (they can be deceiving ) the Gipper did a complete rewrite of my draft on this one. (And then called me to apologize. Geez.)
His familiar voice is there in phrases like "Now it's only a game..."
The students loved him that day.
So did I. As I guess almost everybody does now.
This text speaks to why.
Incidentally, a while back when Obama went to Notre Dame, Vince Haley hauled this out storage and gave it the You Tube title "Source of All Strength."
Still there for the viewing

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
bobo
   05/16/11 17:17

While Reagan was in office people made such degrading comments about him. Many liberals still do. They just cannot accept the fact that he was right about nearly everything. He had incredible vision for America.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Ken Ashby
   05/17/11 03:27

Certainly, Reagan's support of the Afghan mujahideen subsequently panned out well.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/17/11 11:08

"Certainly, Reagan's support of the Afghan mujahideen subsequently panned out well."

I suppose FDR was wrong to ship all those airplanes, jeeps, trucks, spam, and electrical wire to the Soviets so they could destroy most of the Wehrmacht?

Trust me, between the Mujahideen and the Soviets, the Soviets were the uncomparable terrorists.

Are comments like yours what passes for reasoned, thoughtful commentary in your circles?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/18/11 10:54

CitizenC, agreed. The problematic Mujahideen are not our friends by any measure, but there is simply no comparison to the Soviets if we're comparing evil wrought. The number of deaths caused by the Mujahideen in totality would be an off week for the Soviets.

I find it interesting to note that this same year our current president was attending Democratic Socialist Alliance-sponsored rallies while at Occidental. And BHO wrote later in "Dreams" that he would organize for, "Change in the White House, where Reagan and his minions were carrying on their dirty deeds."

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/18/11 15:34

Will you plz. stop living in the past. Reagan was well known in CA as Gov. and he is most certainly not the end all, be all, of quotable persons. He had good writers. Remember he was an actor and could do justice to lines put before him. Besides the man is dead and today's youth have no memory of him - We must live in the present in order to secure the future. Try moving into the present for all our sakes.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/18/11 16:31

4truth, because nobody in the past can serve as a good example or role model or inspiration, eh?

As far as Reagan's ability to write, you may want to listen to to his radio commentaries from 1975-1979. They were all written out by him on yellow legal paper. I'm pretty sure he wrote all his own stuff as GE's spokesman all those years too.

In 1980, Mondale credited those commentaries as a big part of Reagan's victory over other GOP contenders and Carter. He considered doing similar radio spots too, until Mike Deavers pointed out to him that Reagan hand-wrote every spot.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/18/11 17:30

4truth,

Those of us who hold Reagan in high regard and remember his leadership are not “living in the past”, we're conserving it.

It is, after all, a core principle of being a “conservative”. (at least in my account).

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/19/11 03:26

During my early teens living in Santa Barbara County between 1977 - 1980, where President Reagan also lived, I listened to Reagan's five minute broadcasts over the radio and look forward to them weekly. From Rancho Del Cielo, his plain-spoken messages resonated with this teenager. When I attended high school and the university, encountering the freaks of the 60s then teaching in droves, I found it very easy to deconstruct their pathetic positions and rebut whatever they posited. President Reagan was an eternal optimist and he was and still is my role model.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact