Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

March 5 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew


New on NRO . . .
Close
Vargas’s Sob Story
Ten years after 9/11, the privacy of illegal aliens still trumps national security.

By Michelle Malkin


Archive Latest RSS Send

With great fanfare and elite-media sympathy, José Antonio Vargas publicly declared himself an “undocumented immigrant” this week. “Undocumented” my you-know-what. In the felony-friendly pages of the New York Crimes — er, Times — the Pulitzer Prize–winning journalist turned illegal-alien activist spilled the beans on all the illegal IDs he had amassed over the years. He had documents coming out of his ears.

The Times featured full-color photos of Vargas’s fake-document trove — including a fake passport with a fake name, a fake green card, and a Social Security card his grandfather doctored for him at Kinko’s. He committed perjury repeatedly on federal I-9 employment-eligibility forms. In 2002, while pursuing his journalistic career goals, he was told by an immigration lawyer that he needed to accept the consequences of his law-breaking and return to his native Philippines.

Advertisement
Following the rules would have meant a ten-year bar to reentry into America. Making false claims of citizenship is a felony offense. Document fraud is a felony offense.

Vargas, who frames himself as a helpless victim, freely chose instead to secure yet more dummy documents. He used a friend’s address to obtain an Oregon driver’s license under false pretenses. That gave him an eight-year golden ticket to travel by car, board trains and airplanes, work at prestigious newspapers, and even gain access to the White House — where crack Secret Service agents allowed him to attend a state dinner using his bogus Social Security number.

At least Vargas tells the truth when he says he’s not alone. Go visit a 7-Eleven in the D.C. suburbs. Or the countless vendors in MacArthur Park in Los Angeles. Or any of the 19 cities in 11 states from Massachusetts to Ohio to Kentucky where a massive, Mexico-based “highly sophisticated and violent” fraudulent-document ring operated until February of this year. “Undocumented workers” and “undocumented immigrants” have plenty of documents.

The persistent use of these open-borders euphemisms to describe Vargas and countless millions like him is a perfect illumination of the agenda-driven dominant progressive media.

They’re as activist inside their newsrooms as Vargas is out in the open now. Bleeding-heart editors were hoaxed by a prominent colleague, exposed to liability, and yet still champion his serial subversion of the law. San Francisco Chronicle editor Phil Bronstein bragged that he was “duped” by Vargas, but endorses his “subterfuge” because Vargas’s lobbying campaign for the illegal-alien student bailout known as the DREAM Act “just might lubricate the politically tarred-up wheels of government and help craft sane immigration policy.”

Who’s insane? The Vargas deceit is not an object lesson about America’s failure to show compassion. It’s another stark reminder of America’s dangerous failure to learn from 9/11.

Time and again, security experts have warned about how jihadists have exploited lax immigration and ID enforcement. Driver’s licenses are gateways into the American mainstream. They allow illegal aliens to establish an identity and gain a foothold in a community. They help them open bank accounts, enter secure facilities, board planes, and do things like drive tractor-trailers carrying hazardous materials.

It has been nearly ten years since several of the 19 9/11 hijackers operated in this country using hundreds of illicitly obtained fake driver’s licenses and IDs. Most states tightened licensing rules, and yet Vargas easily obtained a driver’s license not only in Oregon, but more recently in Washington state. He again used a friend’s residence to pass muster. Washington state’s licensing bureaucracy still does not check citizenship. The man sitting in the Oval Office campaigned to keep driver’s-license laws as loose as possible to appeal to the open-borders lobby. He appointed lobbyists for illegal aliens to top federal immigration positions. His head of Immigration and Customs Enforcement just signed a memo pushing the DREAM Act through by administrative fiat. And the privacy of illegal aliens still trumps national security.

I ask again: Who’s insane?

Vargas believes his sob story is an argument for giving up on immigration enforcement and passing a mass amnesty. It’s a sob story, all right. Homeland Security officials across the country should be weeping at the open mockery Vargas and his enablers have made of the law.

Michelle Malkin is the author of Culture of Corruption: Obama and His Team of Tax Cheats, Crooks & Cronies (Regnery 2010). Her e-mail address is malkinblog@gmail.com. © 2011 Creators Syndicate, Inc.

You Might Also Like...

Nordlinger: One Mo’ Time

Symposium: The Mesa Debate

Trinko: Santorum in Arizona



COMMENTS   26

EXPAND  

   06/24/11 07:37

Honestly, the consequences of this travesty go well beyond a post 9/11 threat; they go to the very heart of the rule of law--which is much more pernicious.

Once the rule of law becomes something that we selectively enforce without amending, we may as well declare that the bone-marrow of our country is rotting away. It's the first step towards anarchy.

And nothing symbolizes our attitude towards the rule of law better than the issue of illegal immigration.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/24/11 08:27

Where are all the left wing women to help this poor guy out? All he needs is for one of them to marry him and he's good to go!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/24/11 09:39

Good catch.

And has anyone checked the voter rolls for this guy? I've never lived in a state that actually checked citizenship; they assume you're being honest when you check the "I am a citizen" box on the form (and Iowa will give you a ballot if you leave the box blank). Add his vote for Obama to the top of the list of felonies he'd be charged with if he was a citizen.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/24/11 08:53

When I returned to the U.S. in 2004 after a 13 year absence, I came ahead of my (Polish) wife to settle affairs while she got her visa/green card in order.

I was separated from her and our baby for four months while the ladies at the embassy visa desk took their own sweet time - and were none too polite about it either.

On one of the numerous appointments my wife told the clerk, "My husband is an American citizen."

"Well that won't help you," the clerk replied.

"My son is an American citizen."

"Well that won't help you."

That's what you get for following the rules.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Fil-TX
   06/24/11 16:08

Steve B: Your story is the other side of the law-breaking that goes with our immigration policy. Folks like you who spend the money and time to go to the process are greatly dishonored by the liberals, activists and law-breaking illegals.
Thank you for doing it legally. I would bet that you and your family appreciate your citizenship because you had to earn it by being rudely handled by our bureaucrats at Immigration.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Zazabeth
   06/24/11 09:47

Emigrants are needed to cultivate and fleece by selling them the "American Dream" mantra. There have never been any seriousness in immigration laws. The people wanted protection from jetsam and good old politicians-- for votes --give them scarcely enforced border laws.

Who will buy all these under water mortgages, overpriced cars, overpriced higher education, poorly designed technologies, and outfit their lives with frivolous gadgets? It is the emigrants, who have come to believe in the "American Dream". Those who are stuck holding the "American Dream" debt needs someone to buy it from them. This is the history of American and its false vision of arrival and middle-class status. There is no such thing as middle-class or upper-middle class because this status is a status where the people are heaviest in debt and pays the bulk of the taxes to feed and house the rest of the country's flotsam.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Boca Condo King
   06/24/11 10:17

No one has brought up the following:

1. The Philippines is a democratic free country.
2. The NYTs, or any news service can still employ this man as a overseas correspondent.
3. What do you think, $100k in taxpayer cost for 15 years of k - 12 education?
4. What J school grad did not get a job?
5. US military service is a path to citizenship, does not seem to have been thought about for a second.
6. Meg Whitman was scolded by the same press for not responding to a notice that informed her not to respond, but the newspapers get a pass for taking this guys ids?

Our system is broken, it hurts our poor people, it drains our economy, and it seems to be run with the idea that the US is bad and should be punished.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
pdevlin
   06/24/11 11:08

As he has admitted to committing felony offences, should he not be arrested and charged? Oh no, I forgot, that can't happen to a poor illegal alien...

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/24/11 12:20

As an illegal immigrant, Vargas is just doing the Pulitzer prize-winning job that Americans won't do.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/24/11 14:37

He came here when he was 12-years old. If he'd killed someone he'd be free by now, but you folks still want to punish him for being an illegal immigrant?

He got good jobs, paid taxes, didn't break any laws other than those required to allow him to get documents required to navigate daily life.

I recommend amnesty and focusing our law enforcement on real criminals and terrorists. Anyone who can hold down a job should automatically get a visa. Period.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/24/11 17:36

He didn't just break a law in 1982 and stopped. He continues at this very minute to still be breaking the law. Escort him to the airport and let him get back in line in the Phillipines.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/24/11 19:23

There is no "line." There's a lottery, a rush to fill quotas, and laws preventing people from hiring whom they want.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/24/11 19:53

Then, work to change the law to allow more legal immigration. But don't give amnesty to those who have already broken the law.

A simple solution is to pass immigration reform that applies only to those not in the country illegally when it takes effect.

If it is true that the millions of law-abiding illegals really want to be here legally, we should see a significant number self-deporting to be eligible.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/28/11 09:42

The US brings in 1 million LEGAL immigrants annually...we do NOT need to change the law to allow MORE legal immigration.

And we do NOT need any kind of immigration reform. We have laws, we have a process, we have a system. Unfortunately, our government ignores it. Simply to ENFORCE the immigration laws already on the books is the simple solution to this outrageous law breaking!

I'm so sick and tired of listening to the BS coming out of DC that we need immigration reform. What our government needs is a wake up call to uphold the law and our Constitution and end their games with vote-getting by exploiting this illegal situation!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/24/11 17:42

....I see that the lawless open boarders Nazis are posting here again....

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Isle Oracle
   06/24/11 19:20

Nordickus - You obviously don't live in a city where crimes by illegals takes the lives, and livelihood of US citizens.

You obviously aren't looking for a good job or any job.

And, you obviously don't value your U.S. citizenship.

How about taking a hike and leave us to do the dirty work of undoing the mess of people deserting their country and taking advantage of ours.

I have no sympathy for people that don't have the courage to make their country a better place to live.

If we accepted your ideas then, there would be no job for Mr. Vargas because we would be in the same or worse state as Mexico, Phillipenes, etc.

How about showing some respect for the laws we ALL have to obey.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/25/11 07:52

He didn't break any laws. Are you freaking kidding me! How many documents did he obtain through fraud. Answer, every dang one of them. If you or I do that we get arrested. But because he is an illegal alien, he gets a pass.

You are kidding right?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
ReneeM
   06/24/11 16:12

Excellent points, BocaCondoKing. Of course, the Left will never address them -- it's so much easier to call people like you and Steve B racists and xenophobes simply for pointing them out.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
MN J
   06/24/11 21:27

Most people emigrate to the USA for a better life - legally or illegally. When we ignore or give a pass to those who land here illegally, we are telling them the law doesn't matter. They left their homelands b/c the rule of law was, for the most part, nonexistent. They come here only to find out that the same problem exists.

We've GOT to tighten our borders and immigration procedures.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   06/25/11 03:20

This whole issue was supposed to have been solved back in 1986. Amnesty was granted to all those already here illegally, and we started all over with a clean slate. Supposedly, it was made illegal to hire an illegal -- but nowhere was the law enforced.
Every politician immediately looked the other way, and forgot all about promised immigration reforms, or any effort to enforce the still inadequate laws on the books. Democrats especially noticed that they could pad the voter rolls by weakening immigration enforcement and required ID to vote, or to get absentee ballots.
Now after 25 years of cynical manipulations and compounding unlawful entry with forged documents, we are treated to tearful bleating about chronic lawbreaking as if it were the new standard of patriotism.

If they could see what we have become, our Founding Fathers would not be crying -- they'd be vomiting.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Load More Comments

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact