It’s impossible to read Ying Ma’s fascinating memoir, Chinese Girl in the Ghetto, without wincing. She was born in Guangzhou, China’s third-largest city. Throughout her mostly carefree early childhood years, she kept her family’s secret: that her parents repeatedly sought permission to emigrate to the United States.
Her family was not poor, at least not by Chinese standards of the late 1970s and early 1980s. Yet her daily life would be considered squalid by First World standards. Her family lived in a two-bedroom apartment. She, her brother, and her parents shared one bedroom (and two plank beds). Her paternal grandparents and an uncle shared the other. At times, another uncle slept in the living room. They shared the kitchen and bathroom (such as it was) with the family next door. There was no running hot water, and the toilet was a hole in the floor. The elderly had a particularly hard time crouching.
Advertisement
Ying Ma’s childhood was nonetheless relatively carefree. She longed for more possessions, and eagerly consumed whatever Western products — like nail polish and candy — her relatives brought from nearby Hong Kong. But she excelled in school, was surrounded by friends, was doted upon by her grandfather, and looked forward (here’s the wince) to a fantastic new life in America.
As a child, Ying could not comprehend the more menacing aspects of totalitarian rule. Her third-grade teacher, for example, announced one day that instead of doing math, “You are all going to spend the hour confessing.” When the pupils expressed confusion, Teacher Fu explained, “The school knows that each of you, or someone you know, has behaved wrongly. . . . Now start writing.” Ying recalls, “I always believed my teachers. Now I was genuinely worried. Did the school already know I had relatives from Hong Kong who brought me toys and clothing from the world of the capitalist running dogs? Did it know I really, really liked American movies . . . ?” Panicky, she wrote about her brother’s choice to hang out with some bad elements in the seventh grade. “For days after my confession, I lived in abject horror.” She thought the police might come for her brother. She wanted to warn him, but didn’t dare, because to do so would reveal her betrayal. Such are the torments communism imposes on eight-year-olds.
In a better world, the Ying family would emigrate to the sunny uplands of the United States and bask in prosperity and freedom. Emigrate they did — but without money and speaking no English, they settled in a poor neighborhood of a poor city, Oakland, Calif. And there, Ying Ma was forced to confront some of the shameful aspects of life in this country.
Though far less poor than her classmates in China, the Oakland kids felt entitled to steal. On one of her first days in an American classroom, Ying Ma was shocked by the brazen theft of a shiny mechanical pencil one of her Chinese classmates had given her as a farewell present. Her outrage was pure: “Every one of my former [Chinese] classmates understood stealing to be shameful. . . . Our parents and instructors repeatedly condemned it. Those who disobeyed were severely punished with public reprimands in class followed by potential corporal punishment at home. . . . In the ghetto, however, I could not count on my classmates to know right from wrong, nor could I count on the adults to ferret out fault and dispense punishment.” In a way that counted very much to a young teenager — safety and security — Oakland was less civilized and less just than Guangzhou.
Ying Ma was also a victim of racism — though not in the way Americans are comfortable dissecting and condemning. Her mostly black and Hispanic classmates and neighbors engaged in daily racist taunts and sometimes violence. They victimized Asians of every stripe, calling Chinese, Koreans, Vietnamese, and Filipinos “Chinaman,” “ching chong,” or “chow mein.” Black high school students screamed abuse at a middle-aged Cantonese cafeteria worker, calling her a “stupid Chinaman.” Though Ying burned with fury, she could do little to respond. “Physically, we were usually no match for those who discriminated against us. Culturally, we were predisposed to be less confrontational than our non-Asian peers.”
A black teacher, who took an interest in Ying Ma and helped to place her in the “gifted” program despite her limited English, is remembered gratefully, along with the black friend who stood by her when she was physically attacked by a racist (Hispanic) bully.
As with many other immigrants, the Ying family was able to escape poverty by fierce hard work, planning, and mutual support. Ying Ma herself was able to go to Cornell and then Stanford Law School. Despite her difficult path, she loves America. Her journey has made her the very best kind of conservative — one whose love of liberty, order, and self-reliance has been forged through gritty experience.
Liberals definition of racism – any white person action that does not fully support the needs of a non white person (Asians excluded). For example, criticizing the President (thus not fully supporting him) is racism.
I can only imagine the silent racism Ms. Ma experienced getting into college and graduate school.
In many public schools Asian race is not considered a minority, only black and Hispanics are. I inquired why at my school district – answer was that Asians, while admittedly ‘a minority’ do remarkably well academically and do not qualify for academic assistance programs other minorities do. Thus the State Department of Education does not consider them a minority from an academic perspective.
At the University level...many elite school subtract admission points from Asian applicants academic records to make them more competitive with non Asians (blacks and Hispanics get bonus points added, whites are neutral).
If the left keeps this up, it not unreasonable to wonder if at some point Americans will be dreaming of immigrating to other nations.
It is not surprising her inner-city experiences made her conservative.
What is shocking is that the inner-cities do not produce legions of conservatives.
I do not imagine I could live in Detroit or Oakland, observe reality, and then conclude, "Whatever policies and politicians created this...I want more of it!"
Ms Ma's journey to conservatism is not uncommon for many first generation Asian-american immigrants who came 20-30 years ago. Whether Chinese, Vietnamese, Cambodian, or Laosian, many of us grew up with stories of family members killed or tormented by Communists. Some of us even had parents that reminded us that it was Democrats that betrayed them.
We grew up in strong nuclear families that emphasized that discipline, frugality, and hard work are the paths to success. Our parents taught us that the United States is the land of opportunity and freedom; that we should be proud to be Americans. Sadly, only one party seems to share in these ideals anymore.
Thanks to our public school system, much of these ideals has been lost on the current generation of Asian kids who have been "educated" about the history of their country. My kids are in the California school system which seems more interested in "sensitizing" them than educating them. In elementary school, they spend more time on American-Indian culture than they do on the American Revolution. In middle school, they'll learn more about the slave trade than the Civil War.
I'm sure it will get worst as they get older since our media culture only slants left. Older kids are exposed only to the "good Democrat" vs "evil-rich-homophobe-nazi Republican" images on TV, radio, and even their teachers. Several years ago, I saw my neighbor's high school age son with a Che poster in his room.
The only recourse left to conservative parents seems to be to supplement the education of our kids on our own.
This is in fact an inspirational story. It is wonderful that people with above-average intelligence and discipline can go so far in America, despite coming from a disadvantaged position as a non-affluent immigrant.
My only question is this. Why does Mona Charen choose to ruin the story by politicizing it? There is something really sad when the story of an individual has to be twisted to fit into a skewed political narrative.
Congratulations to Ying Ma! Whether she CHOOSES to be a conservative or a liberal or a little bit of both or even *gasp* an INDIVIDUAL that doesn't fit into the neat little boxes that ideologues would want to put her into.