The Columbia Spectator is the student newspaper at Columbia University, the school I was once proud to call my alma mater. A report in that newspaper raises the following question: Are leading American universities producing moral illiterates?
Advertisement
According to the Spectator, a group of students who are members of a group called CIRCA, the Columbia International Relations Council and Association, has been invited to attend a private dinner with Mahmoud Ahmadinejad when he travels to New York for the United Nations General Assembly meeting next week. A student spokesman for the group, asked if the invitation provoked controversy within CIRCA, seemed surprised by the question. “Everyone was really enthusiastic,” said Tim Chan. “They’re thrilled to have this opportunity.”
Ahmadinejad represents everything that campus liberals profess to hate. In order of importance, those things would be: (1) persecuting homosexuals; (2) cruel and abusive treatment of women; (3) brutal treatment of minorities; (4) shooting opponents of the regime in the streets; (5) restricting free speech; (6) building nuclear weapons; and (7) sponsoring terror worldwide. Tehran provides material and moral support for Bashar Assad’s murderous regime in Syria, which has mowed down protesters by the thousands in the past few months. The Iranian regime is also guilty of fetid anti-Semitism, and has the blood of many American soldiers who served in Iraq on its hands — though it isn’t clear that the latter two offenses rate very highly with Columbia students.
Even as members of CIRCA were eagerly anticipating dining with one of the world’s true fiends, the Iranian government was refusing to release American hikers Shane Bauer and Joshua Fattal, who were recently convicted of espionage after a secret trial and sentenced to eight years in prison. Both Bauer and Fattal are graduates of Berkeley, and believers — if you can extrapolate from their backgrounds in “sustainable development” and freelance photography for leftist outlets like Democracy Now! — in liberal causes. Even if members of CIRCA feel no particular solidarity with the hikers as fellow Americans, they might at least feel something for fellow members of the liberal clerisy. But apparently not.
College students are old enough to be responsible for their own moral decision-making, but the faculty and administration of Columbia University certainly provided an appalling example in 2007 when they invited Ahmadinejad to speak. Oh, university president Lee Bollinger tried to quash some of the controversy the invitation sparked by calling Ahmadinejad a “cruel dictator” to his face. But those insults only made Bollinger seem an ungracious host, and did little to mitigate the damage that issuing the invitation in the first place had done to Columbia’s reputation. The invitation, Bollinger insisted, arose out of Columbia’s “almost single-minded commitment to pursue the truth.” Simple-minded might be closer to the mark. As for truth, how exactly does offering the prestigious forum of a famed university to a Holocaust denier advance the search for truth?
There is a world of difference between tolerating and respecting differences of opinion within a university (notably absent when it comes to conservative ideas by the way), and tolerating actual despots with the blood of innocents on their hands. Ahmadinejad’s regime has presided over executions of young homosexuals. Two were hanged in a public square just 24 months before Ahmadinejad stepped to a podium at Columbia. Here is how Human Rights Watch describes the current situation:
Since Iran’s crackdown against anti-government protests following the 2009 presidential election, the human rights crisis in the country has only deepened. Human Rights Watch is particularly concerned about the broad-based targeting of civil society activists, including lawyers, students, women’s rights activists, and journalists, and a sharp increase in the use of the death penalty. Yet the government’s record of cooperation with international institutions, particularly with UN mechanisms, remains extremely poor.
Something is inoculating Ahmadinejad from the total contempt members of the university community would ordinarily feel toward someone with his views and his behavior. It is impossible, for example, to imagine the university inviting fellow Holocaust denier and racist David Duke to speak to the students and faculty. And it’s equally impossible to imagine that students would be “thrilled” by a dinner invitation from Rev. Fred Phelps of the Westboro Baptist Church.
My suspicion is that the harshly adversarial pose of the university toward American society and culture leads to a misplaced benefit of the doubt toward enemies of this country. It is Ahmadinejad’s very hatred of the U.S. that makes him intriguing to Columbia.
Ahmadinejad's hatred of America is only part of the attraction for Columbia, they also love dictators that the U.S. government condemns and embargoes. Castro, Chavez, et al. After all, if U.S. foreign policy against it, liberal college professors and their sheep must be for it. I am sure the students of CIRCA will listen to Ahmadinejad's tales of woe brought on by the "Great Satan" with rapt attention, never once questioning any of the issues listed. Callow youth + progressive liberal education = CIRCA members.
"Ahmadinejad represents everything that campus liberals profess to hate."
And therein lies the hypocrisy that is usually associated with the "elites"...who's next on the Columbia speaking circuit...Chavez? Assad? Mugabe?
Since these students are so enamored of people that hold anti-American views and seem to wet their pants when awarded a sit-down, I wonder how many of them are having their education subsidized by my tax dollars in the form of student loans?
You have to wonder if they are envious of the power that Ahmadinejad has over his country. The liberal youth would love to be able to get us all to do what they think we should (Save the Earth, Save the Children, Save the Animals, etc) but get frustrated with us when we don't listen. Here's a man that with the flick of a finger could get us all to recycle (or risk death). I really don't think they care to know about the horrors that he inflicts, the media sure doesn't spend much time on it.
Colleges used to be for shaping the young minds, now they just let them follow their own course. Nothing is wrong or immoral.
I sure hope you're not contributing to your alma mater.
Leftwing college campuses have been bastions of support for Communist/Socialist dictator worship for 40 years. Just look at all of the NVA flags on display during the Viet Nam protests, the “Mao” hats and “Che Guevara” t-shirts that many students wear, and the unwavering belief by many collegians that Marx was really on to something. As you so ably note, these “kids” support the most appalling regimes, pursuing the most vile policies of murder, repression, and bigotry; all the while, doing so in the name of the false ideologies of “understanding, social justice, and multiculturalism.”
Sad, but true. However, looking on the bright side, it does appear that the American education system is good at something; producing simple-minded, guilt-ridden useful idiots.
Exactly so. The enemy of my enemy is my friend, goes the adage. What is most detestable, more than homophobia, nuclear weapons, racism, antisemitism, etc., to these students, is patriotism.
My guess: This group from Colombia is packed full of idealistic International Institutionalists.
One could understand how an IR group would be interested to hear the leader of an enemy state speak as an educational exercise, but to be "thrilled" to have a private dinner with Ahmadinejad exposes some kind tacit approval of his brutal policies.
One recalls the late Allan Bloom, whose “Closing of the American Mind,” published more than 20 years ago, captured almost perfectly the conditions that have produced the mind-set now on view at Columbia. A corrosive relativism has mugged reason to the point where no society or culture—or the practices that define it—can ever be considered superior—or inferior—to others. Good and evil have been found wanting as “moral” categories and thus banished from respectable intellectual discourse. Hence the invitation to Ahmadinejad, whose presence on campus allows us to warmly congratulate ourselves on our openness, our tolerance, and our courageous stand for diversity in all its forms.
I think that Ahmadinejad's attraction to those at Columbia is as much about his hatred of Israel as it is about his hatred of the US. The students willingness to sit down with him just reflects the growth of anti-semiticism, generally expressed as anti-zionism though I fail to make much distinction, on college campuses.
Ah, the please spank me culture. The Marquis de Sade would understand how 'thrilled at the opportunity' the CIRCA members feel at meeting their most recent 'enthusiasm'
University organizations, departments and programs concerned with international relations are nearly all riddled with:
- Leftism – and its language of Buzzwords and PC Jargon
- Bias from scholars of foreign areas who identify with the area/culture/people they study over and above the US
- Anti-Americanism – and blaming the US and/or West for all evil
- Obsession with Israel
- Apologetics for any person, group, government or movement hostile to the US
Students and scholars in these organizations see themselves not as patriotic Americans studying the world to better advance US values and interests, but rather as advocates of the foreign to an ignorant and benighted America.
How is the conduct of a group of students who are some of the members of a club and who are currently attending something called "Columbia University" supposed to be indicative of whether "leading American universities" are "producing moral illiterates"?
Sorry if some yahoos attend the college that you used to attend, Ms. Charen, but their conduct says no more about the product of "leading American universities" than does the depredations of a group of any other Americans about a larger group (sailors, priests, Jews, lawyers, Mormons, citizens of Omaha, mailmen) with which those persons can be associated.
College students aren't children. Hold them, by name if possible, responsible for their conduct. If an institution does something, hold the institution accountable. But don't group people or institutions who didn't do what you're complaining about with those who did what you're complaining about.
Bart,
Maybe. I see your point. But, if this is truly indicative on the thought process of a large percentage of those attending leading universities, and Columbia certainly qualifies, then there is a problem with those universities. When a few people of any group are yahoos you can chalk it up to the statistical certainty of yahooness when many people are yahoos you wonder what is going on in that group.