Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew


New on NRO . . .
Close
Europe’s Humiliation
From colonial powers to mendicants.

By Rich Lowry


About Author Archive Latest E-Mail RSS Send Follow•   followers
Text  

One hundred and fifty years ago, no one could mistake the relative power of Europe and China. When the British defeated the Chinese in the First Opium War, they imposed an indemnity, took Hong Kong, and forced open more Chinese ports to British merchants. They demanded extraterritoriality for British citizens, exempting them from Chinese law. Other Western powers extracted similar privileges.

When this wasn’t enough, the British launched the Second Opium War after the Chinese seized a ship flying the British flag and refused to apologize. The French joined in, and the two together captured Beijing, and burned the emperor’s summer palaces for good measure.

Advertisement

This nasty episode is worth recalling against the backdrop of the Europeans’ begging the Chinese to help bail them out from their debt crisis. What would Lt. Gen. Charles Cousin-Montauban, the commander of the French forces who marched on Beijing, make of Klaus Regling, the commander of the European bailout fund who traveled to Beijing hoping for a helping hand? What would Lord Palmerston, who justified war against China as a matter of honor, think of Nicolas Sarkozy’s supplicating his Chinese counterpart for funds?

The Chinese refer to the period from the middle of the 19th century to the middle of the 20th as “the century of shame.” Now, the shame is all on their former tormentors. The Chinese suffered foreign rule and the breakdown of calcified institutions inadequate to the modern world. No one will conquer the Europeans, but they are laboring under a broken model of governance that has exposed them to the humiliation of asking for Chinese backing for their bailout, and, inevitably, more embarrassments to come.

The Europeans share a misbegotten single currency that is amplifying the inherent problems attendant to the practice of spending money that you don’t have. Perhaps the Greek crisis can be contained, but what if Spain and Italy spin out of control? Europe is trying to fund a “bazooka” big enough to fend off doubtful markets but doesn’t want to — and perhaps can’t — fund it all by itself. Germany is Europe’s economic powerhouse, yet its public debt–to–GDP ratio is already larger than ours.

This is where China and its $3.2 trillion in foreign reserves come in. If China were to contribute to a bailout fund that Europe wants to build up to $1.4 trillion, it would surely ask for concessions in return, such as the Europeans’ dropping their criticism of China’s undervalued currency. China also might wonder why it should come to the rescue of a European Union that still has it under an arms embargo. History comes full circle, with the ascendant Chinese in a position to extract concessions from erstwhile colonial powers.

So far, though, Beijing is not showing any eagerness to jump in to the European-bailout business. For all that it wants a robust European export market, China might be doing the math and realizing that Europe has a problem too big for serial bailouts. The official Xinhua News Agency ran a piece explaining, “Amid such an unprecedented crisis in Europe, China can neither take up the role as a savior to the Europeans, nor provide a ‘cure’ for the European malaise.”

This reversal in fortunes was a long time in coming. Nothing could have stopped the Chinese from adopting more rational, market-friendly policies a few decades ago, and China has proven immune to appeals to allow its currency to appreciate so its exports don’t have such an advantage. What Europe could control was its own destiny. It chose a comfortable, if bankrupting, social democracy and a vast experiment with a single currency. The euro was supposed to be the vehicle and symbol of Europe as a world power, and instead is laying bare its debt-addled decay.

For the United States, listing in a similar direction, the turnabout in Europe’s global position should be of the utmost interest — as a cautionary tale.

— Rich Lowry is the editor of National Review. He can be reached via e-mail: comments.lowry@nationalreview.com.

Text  

You Might Also Like...

Trinko: Will Fear Decide Texas Senate Race?

Symposium: Polling Life

Malkin: Obama’s Land of the LOST



COMMENTS   20

EXPAND  

   11/01/11 08:36

Well, Rich, here's a "cautionary tale": countries don't listen to cautionary tales. Especially ours.

Countries don't have ears, eyes and a brain. Only the people inhabiting them do--and only to the extent that they pay attention. And even if countries did have a mind of their own, what would you say about the mind of a country that has elected Barack Obama?

That is, Barack Obama the racialistic, pro-Islam, anti-business, thuggish, ultra-Liberal mega-spender at a time when an America divided by race was threatened by Islam, had near two-digit unemployment, was in desperate need of a more civil debate in Washington and was in debt by trillions?

Barack Obama the rabidly anti-energy shill at a time when oil and gas prices were steeply rising? Barack Obama the friend of the despicable Barney Frank and Chris Dodd at a time when the market crash they oversaw and profited from was erasing the wealth of families by the billions of dollars?

Only an America with its head buried in the sand--or a civically-immature, irresponsible electorate--would do such a thing.

And that nearly 50% of the electorate are eager to make the same mistake again--amidst more calls for taxes, more demands for special favors, more idiotic drones like the OWS zombies, and more hyperbole about children being torn by wolves unless we spend yet another trillion here and there--tells you to which extent our civic maturity has atrophied.

History will repeat itself (sadly, in the form of the West's decline and fall), because this defective gene is in-built in us humans.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 09:17

I fear America's head is buried in a far darker place than just sand ... God help us if, indeed, the doomsday scenario plays out and he gets reelected.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 11:41

Back away from the crack pipe and loosen up the tinfoil buddy

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 12:10

Ok, I will bite.

Let's hear a non-tinfoil prediction of where our current policies will take us.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 12:08

History does repeat itself....

So, after the West collapses, then the International Caliphate will collapse and the China will collapse too!

That's good news!

What?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/03/11 01:19

"sadly, in the form of the West's decline and fall"

Sad for you, perhaps. Remember that several ***billion*** people have been looking forward to this for quite some time.

Our Weltanschauung is changing, and only the Germans have had the literary self-awareness to corner and name our unquiet feelings.

Please quit living in your WWII bubble and admit that German competence and hard work have kept the slovenly EU afloat longer than it has deserved.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/03/11 17:34

In a global economy, MoH, the collapse of the West would be a catastrophe for China. With dramatically decreased demand for its products and no real internal market to make up the difference, China's export-driven economy would be devastated.

Incidentally, if you didn't like the West's racialist nonsense, it's a good idea not to peddle your own.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 08:57

The sad part, Voltaire, is that the Republican electorate doesn't seem much smarter - although it doesn't really have much of a choice with this rotten field. But still, Mitt is just an absolutely disaster. Maybe the Tea Party can keep him slightly on task. Slightly. He can't even decide what his stance on ethanol policy is.

Gary Johnson 2012! (But no one cares.)

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 09:08
   11/02/11 01:11

I'm sick of hearing that Mitt is a done deal.

The election is more than a year away.

If the mass media has so much persuasive power as to convince voters that other Libertarian and Republican hopefuls haven't a chance, then the Western World really does deserve to drink some Jonestown Kool-Aid.

If Mitt actually wins the Republican nomination, I'm voting for Obama. Let's accelerate this process!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
PaulR
   11/01/11 10:02

"No one will conquer the Europeans...."

Don't bet on it. We are still in the early acts of this play.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 15:02

If anyone is going to conquer the Europeans they better hurry while there are still some left. (A Mark Steyn demographic death spiral reference.)

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 11:21

Fifty years ago, France was a colonizer. Now, the former colonizer has been colonized.

The wheel of furtune lifts some even as it casts others down. France's former colonies won their independence, but colonized France may never be as fortunate.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 16:01

The question I don't hear anyone asking is, "Why would China have any interest in bailing out Europe?" What's going to happen to enable Europe to ever pay the money back? Sure they buy a lot of Chinese products, but loaning deadbeats money to buy your products is functionally equivalent to just giving your products away. My impression is the Chinese are better businessmen than that.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Bart
   11/01/11 16:35

Mr. Lowry:

You skipped over the part in-between the Opium Wars and the current travails, during which Europeans, during a 77-year period of almost unparalleled barbarity, stupidity, bigotry, ignorance, savagery and greed, carefully and deliberately chose to cripple themselves by engaging in two major internal wars and then meekly acquiescing in the subordination of almost half of Europe under the thuggish and ignorant thumb of one European power for another 40 years. (European contributors to NR/NRO ought to keep this 1914-91 period in mind when they write scornfully of Northern Africans and Southwest Asians for being so messed-up.)

Unsustainable social democracy and a single currency may be hurting Europe, but putting too much of an emphasis on these factors is a bit like criticizing a man for smoking while he's sitting in a wheelchair to which he was fated after he tried to commit suicide by setting himself on fire and then jumping off a freeway overpass.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/01/11 17:32

Before anyone gets all whoopy on the European economic crisis, they should remember that we have a far worse situation here than they have in Greece, Ireland, Spain, and Italy combined.

It has a bigger economy than any 2 nations there and yet is more socialist than all of Europe, even more insanely committed to never successful climate-mitigation policies, welfare-state entitlements, over-run by undocumented and hostile immigrants, intensely anti-business, completely dominated by one political party, and dotted with potential natural disaster.

California is a death-knell in the making for OUR economy far beyond what the Europeans are facing and no one here is even paying attention.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
KevinJ
   11/01/11 18:38

While I agree that the Euro has been a unmitigated disaster I am not sure what is the relevance of British actions in China 150 years ago. The UK is not part of the Euro and is not going to China with cap in hand.

France and Germany are borrowing on behalf of the failing economies in Greece, Ireland and maybe Portugal. I also don't see the relevance of French actions in China in the 1800's. to the collapse of those economies.

It is unfortunate that the repulsive regime in China through it's adoption of State Capitalism and currency manipulation has gained so much financial clout but it is a fact of life, for now.

The Europeans should move away from leftist ideas about a Federal Europe and return to the free trade concepts within the original European Common Market and we should avoid taking too much pleasure in the misery of others.. I wish there was a German word for such practice.

The Greek referendum is a good step forward.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/02/11 14:59

There's nothing wrong with the euro, other than that it's a (relatively) hard currency. If you borrow more than you can repay in a hard currency it's hard to hide the fact that you are bankrupt.

If you can borrow in your own currency you can repay your debts by printing money, but it's just a different version of default, just as destructive and more regressive than letting some big banks collapse. Ours is coming soon enough and the Germans will be taking joy in our misfortune, even if they don't have a very apt word for that.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/02/11 01:01

Thank you, Mr. Lowry, for FINALLY voicing what every Westerner should already know by heart.

It is time for the BIG PAYBACK, and about 5,000 years too soon for Westerners to think they can best one of the oldest, and certainly one of the greatest civilizations in the history of the solar system.

David Rockefeller and his One World Government will have to take a back seat, because China will never again kowtow to foreigners.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/03/11 17:27

China was bested, MandateOfHeaven. Whether it will return the favor still remains to be seen.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact