It was after the firefight was over, when American troops were tending to the wounded, that Khadr threw the grenade that killed Speer. In response, another U.S. Special Forces soldier shot Khadr. Levant recounts that, “his first words to the U.S. forces who shot and captured him were in English, cursing the soldiers and calling on them to shoot him again — and thus make him a martyr.” Instead, however, U.S. medics treated him, and then turned him over to American surgeons — saving his life. Later, an ophthalmologist was flown to Afghanistan to save the vision in one of his eyes which had been hit by shrapnel.
The last chapter in this murder mystery has yet to be written. Should Khadr be set free next year, will he return to the battlefield as more than 160 of the detainees released from Guantanamo have done (including the top al-Qaeda-affiliated leader in Libya)? Dr. Michael Welner, an American forensic psychiatrist who studied and interviewed Khadr, concluded that he remains a committed jihadist and may see himself stepping into the shoes of his father who was killed in a shootout with Pakistani soldiers in 2003.
Khadr’s more moderate supporters believe he can be rehabilitated. I would ask how they propose that be done: What therapy can change the mind and soul of a 26-year-old man who subscribes to al-Qaeda’s ideology?
Less moderate Khadr supporters believe that no rehabilitation is necessary because he did nothing wrong by fighting Americans who had invaded Afghanistan. Khadr’s mother and older sister, who are back in Canada, reportedly take this view. The facts they conspicuously ignore: Afghanistan is not Khadr’s homeland. He was himself a foreign invader, fighting with al-Qaeda to reestablish a Taliban dictatorship over the people of Afghanistan.
Here’s my best guess about where the story goes from here: Khadr will be paroled but he won’t return to making IEDs, toting AK-47s, and throwing grenades. Nor, however, will he apply to medical school or open a restaurant. Instead, he will become a professional propagandist, telling audiences he was tortured in Afghanistan and Gitmo (claims not supported by any evidence as the military judge presiding over the case ruled), while promoting anti-Americanism and furthering the Islamist cause.
Yes, Khadr has led a tragic life. But the blame for that rests with his parents who decided to make him a teenage terrorist, not with America or Gitmo. And, unlike SFC Speer, Khadr still has a life. Before long, he is likely to be both free and celebrated by people who call themselves human-rights activists. In the real world, murder mysteries don’t always have satisfying endings.
— Clifford D. May is president of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, a policy institute focusing on national security.