1972—In a Brennanesque opinion in People v. Anderson, the California supreme court, by a 6-1 vote, misconstrues the state constitution’s prohibition on cruel or unusual punishment to reflect “contemporary standards of decency” and rules that the death penalty violates what it imagines contemporary standards to be. All pending death sentences, including those of Charles Manson and Sirhan Sirhan, are voided. Nine months later, the people of California, expressing actual contemporary standards, override the ruling by voting overwhelmingly to amend the state constitution to authorize the death penalty.
Most Commented on NRO
The Editors: Pressuring the Chief
Comments (108)
Noah Glyn: Breaking: Gay D.C. Superhero Revealed
Comments (92)
Robert VerBruggen: Changing Stories in theMartin . . .
Comments (74)
Noah Glyn: Ashley Judd: Obama ‘HasAn . . .
Comments (64)
Montford & Ambler: Climategate Continues
Comments (60)
Robert Costa: How Hatch Wooed Palin,and . . .
Comments (59)
Katrina Trinko: Romney Behind Obama inThree . . .
Comments (51)
Michael Walsh: Kaffee Klatsch
Comments (50)