During Attorney General Eric Holder’s confirmation hearings, General Holder decried the politicization of the Department of Justice, declaring, “I will work to restore the credibility of a department badly shaken by allegations of improper political interference . . . Under my stewardship, the Department of Justice will serve justice, not the fleeting interests of any political party.” This echoed a similar theme that then-senator Barack Obama sounded on the 2008 campaign trail; he would not overly politicize the Department of Justice, and “was a constitutional law professor, which means that unlike the current president I actually respect the Constitution.”
The Supreme Court’s oral arguments last week in Arizona v. United States highlight one more instance of how much the Obama administration has failed at keeping these promises. As Byron York asked on Twitter last week, is DOJ’s Solicitor General “Donald Verrilli bad at his job or just burdened by having to defend the indefensible?” Evidence suggests the latter.
As John Hinderaker pointed out on Wednesday, even Justice Sotomayor was openly skeptical of the DOJ’s argument, telling Solicitor General Verrilli to put aside an argument that was “not selling well,” and “try to come up with something else.” Later on, Justice Kennedy wondered if Verrilli was arguing that the “government has a legitimate interest in not enforcing its laws.” Justice Scalia followed up Verrilli’s largely incoherent response by asking if “we have to enforce our laws in a manner that will please Mexico.”
The DOJ’s politicization is becoming a noticeable pattern. Their greatest hits include:
Some DOJ defeats come with the job — they have to defend statutes to the best of their ability, which can be difficult. This is different. Instead, the Eric Holder DOJ is getting walloped for much stronger and farther-out-of-the-“mainstream” legal positions that are often times not necessary to fulfill their legal duty, or even competently advance their agenda within the contours of acceptable policy discretion. Hopefully President Obama and the Eric Holder DOJ will stop trying to defend the indefensible, and focus instead on competently enforcing our nation’s laws.