D.C. Circuit Victory for Challengers of HHS Mandate

by Ed Whelan

In an important procedural ruling yesterday, the D.C. Circuit reversed two lower-court orders that dismissed lawsuits against the HHS mandate brought by Wheaton College and Belmont Abbey College. The D.C. Circuit took “as a binding commitment” a Department of Justice lawyer’s statements that the HHS mandate would never be enforced “in its current form” against either plaintiff and that HHS would publish its proposed new rule for religious nonprofits by the end of March 2013 and would issue a new final rule before August 1, 2013. Based on those commitments, the court held the cases in abeyance and ordered the government to provide status reports on the new rule every 60 days.

In this Corner interview, Mark Rienzi, one of the Becket Fund lawyers representing the two colleges, explains more about the significance of the ruling and the broader battle against the HHS mandate.

Bench Memos

NRO’s home for judicial news and analysis.