Bench Memos

NRO’s home for judicial news and analysis.

Error by Consensus


From our editorial on SCOTUS up today:

The Court has helped bring into being a significant degree of polarization about itself — so much that it is not at all clear that any candidate could generate a consensus. What the president should instead seek is a candidate who is committed to the rule of law. The rule of law entails predictable, because rule-bound, judicial decisions. It entails respect for the intentions of the sovereign people who ratified the Constitution and who ratified the amendments to it: If what they ratified needs to be changed, change should occur through a lawful process of amendment rather than judicial revision. It entails some respect for precedent, but does not confuse the stability of Court-made “constitutional law” with fidelity to the Constitution.


Subscribe to National Review