by Jonathan H. Adler

Kathryn, I agree with you that Reid’s treatment of Saad was particularly shameful (which is saying something given how some of the nominees have been treated). My only point is that he was certain to be on the list because of the e-mail incident. (I also suspect that some Dems wanted him on the list so Bush couldn’t claim credit for nominating the first Arab-American appellate judge.)

Bench Memos

NRO’s home for judicial news and analysis.