Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Campaign Spot

Election-driven news and views . . . by Jim Geraghty.


Print   |  Text
 

Obi-Wan’s Friday Afternoon Assessment

Jim: So what are you seeing right now?

Obi-Wan: This wasn’t the week the Democrats needed. Not a whole lot more could have gone wrong.

No sooner did you and I start talking about how Obama was helping the Republicans by campaigning in his shirtsleeves and tossing away his best campaign asset — the imagery of the presidency — than he further demeans the office by talking about “punishing enemies,” and the next day provides us with the ultimate counter-image, that of the president with the comedian who calls him “dude.” That will bother Americans. Big-time.

And then the week finishes up with bad economic numbers and a wonderful exhibit of something else we talked about, that the GOP message should be Obama as a symptom of the real problem, the problem of the elite that has been running the Democratic party since 1972. Cometh now the rich imagery of Bill Clinton — McGovern’s Texas ’72 campaign operative — working with the Obamaites to do a smarmy deal in Florida to save the Democratic Senate that brought back the memories of the smarmy deal he tried to pull off in the Pennsylvania Senate race, not to mention all the smarmy deals the administration did for the health-care bill. This will play through the weekend. And the GOP should talk about all the Obama-Clinton imagery has done to help them this week, because this could affect other Senate races beyond Florida.

Jim: So what’s your sense of the Senate races at this point?

Obi-Wan: Well, the impossible is at least within view. In a year when Republicans had to defend 18 of the 33 seats that were up and at the same time gain 11 Democrat-held seats — 10 after Scott Brown — the thing is actually conceivable, if hardly predictable. Arkansas, North Dakota, Indiana seem won, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania look good, so do Illinois and Nevada, meanwhile GOP candidates are tied or slightly ahead in Colorado and Washington and close in West Virginia — a wave could help them enough.

That is ten, but some of them are a little shaky. I know smart people who think California is this year’s lagging indicator and that Carly Fiorina will pull it off, because Boxer still can’t break 50. And, just for fun, has anyone noticed that a poll or two in Connecticut and Delaware show a slackening in the Dems’ lead there?

Jim: See, now you’re going to drive people crazy. When you say that, people start jumping to the idea that either Connecticut or (COUGH) Delaware is in play.

Obi-Wan: Okay, whoa, now, Geraghty-ites. I will give you something nice to chew on this weekend, but only if you promise to keep this caveat in mind. You have to understand that Jimmy boy and I remember how proud we were of ourselves when, as people laughed uproariously, we said McCain had a good last debate and he would tie up the race and four days later or so, the AP poll had McCain storming back, credited to the debate performance. But, see, the problem with this election analysis stuff (as illustrated by that poor soul who wrote in recently saying we predicted a McCain win in ‘08) is that some people remember not what they read but only their emotions when they read it.

So, if everyone will be very adult about all this, and everyone will understand that on Monday the size of the Gallup generic lead will matter and the Senate polls and that even if the GOP runs the table on the contested races they still can’t afford an unexpected loss somewhere else, here is the something nice to munch on . . .

This thought comes from my memories of other wave years. One came while working on the 1964 campaign — the immensely popular candidates Chuck Percy in Illinois and Bud Wilkinson in Oklahoma going down to defeat. And 1980 and the awe on Howard Baker’s face when he found out he was Senate majority leader as the GOP picked up 12 Senate seats. And in 1994, one of the network guys was giving me the early exit polls about 11:30 a.m. One indicator was going to be Fred Thompson in Tennessee, who had a rocky start to his campaign. I remember Thompson was up by something astonishing, like 12 or 18 points. That night Pataki easily took the New York governorship and the speaker of the House, Tom Foley, lost in Washington.

The point here? Crazy stuff happens in wave elections. And right now the “happy times” wave seems close. But if the Superwave shows up — and the Gallup low turnout number is probably indicative (at 14 this week, which is unheard of) — anything could happen. Here is the fun thought for the weekend. (Though, remember now, this is all but pure recreation.) Will certain Senate islands get washed over? Oregon and Wyden? One of the New York seats? Maryland and Mikulski? Though, as I say, if Leahy loses in Vermont you can get me at one of the local homes. Old guys can handle just so much cognitive dissonance.

Jim: . . . “Jimmy Boy”?

Tags: Obi-Wan Kenobi

New on The Campaign Spot. . .


COMMENTS   12

EXPAND  

   10/29/10 14:27

C'mon Obi - give us a prediction. How many house and senate seats?!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/29/10 15:20

C'mon Super-Wave! Delaware needs a female Senator and the nation needs a new Senate. I want those committees run by the most conservative Republicans available. We'll deal with the filibusters and vetoes as they arise but the flow of legislation is set by the leadership and the committee chairs.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/29/10 15:34

What Southpaw said. "Change It Back!"

I lived near Seattle in 1994 & got to hear the wave sweep across America. Now I'm in Kentucky and an election worker to boot, so I'll be up at 0400 Eastern, and I fear I'll be too tired to party like it's 1773 after the polls close.

Lammergeier

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/29/10 16:15

"...that of the president with the comedian who calls him “dude.” That will bother Americans. Big-time."

As a proud conservative (and Republican) in my mid-30'a it really pains me that the Republican party is so out of touch with my generation and those younger that they cannot understand this. (Ugh, I sound like Meghan McCain.)

Oh well, at least the midterms results look good.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/29/10 16:21

While I think that we will "only" get 11 Senate seats myself, I don't think that Deleware and Connecticut are out of reach.

I remember the painful slipping away of the Talent seat a few years ago and figure that many Dem partisans will watch that same trend moving in our direction over the last few days in WA, CA, WV, and maybe, just maybe, Deleware and Connecticut.

My prediction for the house is +92.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/29/10 16:22

I know the current numbers don't really bear it out, but I can't shake this feeling that the Senate ends up 50/50. I think in addition to Arkansas, ND, Indiana, and Wisonsin, the GOP picks up PA and Nevada. I feel good about IL and CO, and I think they split WV and WA.

I'm not getting my hopes up about CA, CT, or DE, but if the wave is big enough to sweep the others, it won't matter.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/29/10 16:40

As an ex-Delawarean, I can only offer this: Chris Coons is an awful candidate, at the wrong time, and the insider Dems there know this. In a year when there is nothing on the state ballot to excite the Dem base (their statewide House candidate is another dullard), they have to be hedging at least a little bit. The polls say CO'D is gonna lose big, but I'm not so sure. Coons is no Biden, who could command 62 percent in a bad year. Prediction: CO'D will carry to the two lower counties and run even in the New Castle County exurbs (Middletown & Odessa). The election hinges on Wilmington -- if the Dems stay home in big numbers this could be interesting.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/29/10 22:20

I think he did... it was the "Happy Time" wave. 50+ in the house and up to 8 in the Senate.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/30/10 09:53

One thing I haven't heard commentary on is how the dynamics in the Senate will change even if Republicans fall short of a majority. In 2006, the Democrats won some pretty conservative states ... North Carolina, Virginia, Montana, Ohio, North Dakota, Nebraska and Missouri ... with some pretty liberal candidates. All of these senators are up for election in 2012, are they going to throw in their lot with Chuck Schumer and Obama if 2010 is a bloodbath? Or will they be more cooperative with Republicans? How nervous is Herb Kohl (WI) right now after the pasting Russ Feingold is getting?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 Huey
   10/30/10 11:04

I'm really hoping for a 50/50 split, with Biden having to cast tie-breaking votes and put the administration's stamp on Congress. That will help in 2012, which in my view is the real prize. Won't repeal without a win that year.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/30/10 16:02

I think we do get 10 in the Senate maybe eleven and 70+ house seats. Play smart enough, I am sure we won't, and we gain even more strength and a Republican president in '12. I am very excited...Tuesday can't come fast enough.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   10/31/10 09:12

I would just love a huge wave to wash over the Left. But we can't be disappointed if we get 8 Senate and 45 House seats. It will mean that we just need to work harder.

I am seeing in my kids and their friends who are in their 20's profoundly shocked at the lack of jobs and how the Left is going after their own Freedom. When my son in law that supported Kucinich in 2008 admits he is listening to Michael Medved and tells me I should check out Rand Paul there is a sea change

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact