HELP
Send to a Friend
<% dim printurl printurl = Request.ServerVariables("URL")%> Print Version

April 2, 2002, 11:50 a.m.
Vieques Vogue
Training protests are still cool.

By Jim Boulet Jr.

hree Soldiers Killed in Military Training Accident" was the headline of a tiny wire-service story which ran over Easter weekend. Those lives were lost during a live-fire training exercise. This wasn't the first time this happened and, predictably, it won't be the last.



  

Training deaths at Fort Drum, New York, were the first topic at a hearing by the Subcommittee on Readiness of the Senate Armed Services Committee on March 21st. "We need to train the way we will fight," said Dr. Paul Mayberry, the deputy undersecretary of defense and representatives of the armed services agreed, despite risks demonstrated just the previous day.

At that same hearing, senators were reminded that potential uses of U.S. troops were inherently unpredictable. Secretary Mayberry mentioned that America was using "soldiers on horseback" in Afghanistan.

The issue of continued military training on the island of Vieques, Puerto Rico, can only be understood in this context.

The U.S. Marine Corps must be certified for 23 different missions, including storming a beach against a hostile enemy. This sort of assault has been practiced on Vieques since World War II until three years ago this month, when a Puerto Rican security guard, David Sanes, was accidentally killed by an errant munition.

Since April, 1999, the island's three major political parties (Statehood, Commonwealth, and Independence) have agreed that the U.S. training must be removed from Puerto Rico. This rare unanimity, along with the concentration of Puerto Rican votes in places like New York, Chicago, and Florida, has gained the "U.S. Out of Vieques" crusade support in unlikely places.

Rep. Rod Blagojevich (D., Ill.), now running for governor of Illinois, wrote President Bush a letter last month urging an executive order ending the training. As a Republican, New York's governor, George Pataki, was able to do much more. According to the American Prospect:

In mid-June [2001], as the Navy exercises began in Vieques, the Bush administration was poised to announce an immediate closing of the Vieques range. This would follow a recommendation made by Republican New York Governor George Pataki (who had just visited Vieques), who gained the endorsement of top Bush political advisor Karl Rove.

While practicing politics is part of any politician's job description, one would hope that the international impact of the expulsion of the American Navy from American-owned soil could be taken into account as well.

Sen. James Inhofe (R., Okla.) warned at the hearing that, "if we should allow a bunch of lawbreaking terrorists to shut down a range we own — that's going to have a domino effect." Inhofe directed his comment toward people like anti-Navy activist Lolita Lebron, who stormed the House of Representatives in 1954.

Inhofe might well have also been referring to the efforts of Cuba to get the United Nations "to order the halt of [United States] armed forces' military drills and maneuvers on Vieques Island." To no one's surprise, Cuba's resolution was supported by Iraq.

A new spate of protests have begun as Navy bombing runs resumed earlier this week on the island. Nobel-Prize winnerRigoberta Menchu is going to be protesting Navy training in Vieques later this month. She'll likely be joined by the usual assortment of Hollywood types and liberal leading lights.

These protests continue even though the Navy is using inert ammunition, per an earlier Clinton deal with Puerto Rico. (Military experts agree that this it is not as effective as live-fire training.) Unfortunately, the protests appear to be succeeding.

The governor of Puerto Rico, Sila Calderon, said on Monday that President Bush has personally promised her that the Navy would leave by 2003 and "I believe in President Bush's word." A law passed by Congress, though, after Sept. 11, says the Navy can use Vieques until it finds an "equal or superior" alternative. And Calderon did urge "the people of Puerto Rico [to] remember the war-like situation that the U.S. is in."

Of course, few of the "boot the U.S." crowd thought the United States would be in a worldwide war prior to Sept. 11. But some people did. They planned and trained and sometimes died in order to be ready when America needed them. Politicians of both parties should keep those brave people in mind as they decide the future of military training on Vieques.

Jim Boulet Jr. is executive director of English First.

Miles Gone By

William F. Buckley Jr.'s literary autobiography

Buy it through NR

 
Looking
for a story?
Click here