HELP
Send to a Friend
<% dim printurl printurl = Request.ServerVariables("URL")%> Print Version

June 12, 2002, 9:00 a.m.
Reading Between the Lies During Campus Visits
A Guide for Innocent Parents and Perplexed Students

By Winfield Myers

oon colleges will host legions of rising high-school juniors and their parents for the annual ritual of the college visitation. Picking a suitable school requires developing a critical eye, asking the right questions, and reading between the lines. Because few college officials will divulge controversial or negative information, parents and students must question professors, administrators, and students about the true nature of their school.



  

Before you embark, examine the school's website carefully. Remember that the goal of a college's web designers is to present the school as administrators want it to be seen, not necessarily as it is. Look at course descriptions and syllabi in the History and English departments, two bellwethers of curricular trends. Take note of the treatment of these subjects (chic professors make a living at unintended self-parody) or descriptions that employ the words race, class, and gender along with other trendy terms; these indicate a high degree of politicization — the substitution of politics for genuine learning.

Browse the pages of student groups to learn how far the administration will go in accommodating students' every whim. If you find groups devoted to paganism, various brands of sexuality, and every imaginable ethnicity, you'll know the administration is afraid to risk being "judgmental" and will do just about anything to cater to the demands or desires of the odd and the misled.

Academic Life: Key Questions
Assessing a school's academic life requires that you look beyond reputation. Ask what percentage of classes is taught by teaching assistants (TAs) during a student's first two years. Institutions frequently prefer to use the cheaper talents of graduate students for introductory courses so that big-name professors may devote their time to research. Inquire about the awarding of tenure to learn if teaching plays a significant role in such decisions (it should). Also ask about advising, a professorial duty often assigned to graduate students or professional counselors.

Does this school have a core curriculum? The customary affirmative answer is misleading at best. How many classes are in your core? Often, the answer is hundreds. If this is the best a college can do, there is no core curriculum worthy of the name, but only distribution requirements masquerading as a core. Ask whether all students must study Western history and literature as well as American history. Many schools have made these courses optional so that students graduate with little or no exposure to the events, personalities, or ideas of Western civilization.

Finally, ask how many years, on average, it takes for a student to graduate, and what the graduation rate is. Recent statistics compiled by the American Council on Education show that only 47 percent of college students remain enrolled in the school at which they began their studies and graduate within five years. Schools with low graduation rates accept too many students ill-prepared for college-level academics.

Student Life: Information to Gather
Dorm residents shouldn't be guinea pigs in social experiments designed to create a morals-free society. Find out if students can secure rooms in single-sex or substance-free dorms if desired. Often only coed dorms are offered, though some have single-sex floors. Others, however, are single-sex by room, and a few even offer coed rooms. Residents of substance-free dorms agree to abstain from drugs, alcohol, and tobacco.

Inquire about the nature of freshman orientation, which radical administrators see as an opportunity to divest their young charges of the family values with which they were reared. Films that most parents would consider pornographic are often shown during orientation, and practices that violate widely accepted moral standards may be presented in positive terms or even advocated. Students who speak up against such practices are sometimes singled out for ridicule and ostracized.

Crime rates in and around campus are a final problem you should ask about. Some schools engage in statistical high jinks in order to hide the true crime rate from parents, students, and donors. They may ignore crimes committed in areas immediately adjacent to campus in order to lower the apparent crime rate.

Political Atmosphere: Problems to Consider
Numerous political problems beset academia today. Speech codes (or harassment codes, as they're often called) control debate and protect selected groups from intellectual or social challenges. Students and professors are sometimes ostracized or punished for disagreeing with received academic opinion, whether the subject in question is feminist scholarship, the morality of affirmative action, or sexual proprieties. Defending your beliefs in the face of criticism is part of the college experience; facing official condemnation for voicing them is unacceptable.

Curricular politics are uglier today than ever before. Politicized courses serve to indoctrinate rather than educate, and professors who grind political axes rather than pursue the truth are, unfortunately, the norm. It's the inevitable outcome of the intellectual homogenization of the faculty: Hire only radicals and only radicals will be heard. It's the easiest way to quell dissent. Great professors are still around, but it's up to students to root them out.

Learn More
For a free copy of my pamphlet, "Asking the Right Questions in Choosing a College: A Guide for Students and Their Parents," contact the Intercollegiate Studies Institute by e-mailing freeguide@isi.org, download a printer-friendly version on ISI's website, or call (800) 526-7022.

— Winfield Myers is director of communications at the Intercollegiate Studies Institute.

Miles Gone By

William F. Buckley Jr.'s literary autobiography

Buy it through NR

 
Looking
for a story?
Click here