Making Enemies
A clever political ploy backfires.

By Arnold Steinberg, a political strategist.
January 28, 2002 12:55 p.m.

 

n the still-developing California governor's race, Richard Riordan is still way out in front in the race for the Republican nomination. (The primary is scheduled for March 5, the winner to face Democrat governor Gray Davis.) Riordan's two opponents are (moderate conservative) secretary of state Bill Jones and (more conservative) businessman Bill Simon. Some will remember that right after New Hampshire, Jones defected from George W. Bush's campaign in order to endorse John McCain. Nor has the White House warmed up to the candidacy of newcomer Simon, the issues-and-ideas candidate who is waging an unexpectedly low-key campaign.

Yet, an extraordinary front-page story in Sunday's Los Angeles Times has serious implications for the suddenly awakening primary that national political analyst Charles Cook had called "an entertaining intra-party soap opera." With five weeks to go, it's hard to see how Riordan can lose. But the consequences of primary misconduct are generally ominous for November. And if Riordan — as seems likely — becomes the party's nominee, he could find that forces he set in motion for March will return to haunt him in November.

"Washington Put Riordan Out Front on Health Issue" is the headline on the front page of Sunday's Times. The story is that when the Bush administration decided to grant Gov. Gray Davis's request to expand health-insurance benefits to the poor, it tipped off Riordan's campaign first. If true, the news of this conspicuous violation of protocol could potentially embarrass the Bush administration.

Background: In December 2000, Davis asked the federal government for a waiver to allow expansion of the Healthy Families program to cover adults, not just children. This week, Health and Human Services Secretary Tommy Thompson granted the waiver. But the Times article reports that Christopher McCabe, Thompson's state government liaison for HHS, alerted the Riordan campaign first, before notifying Davis. According to a Riordan adviser, McCabe suggested to the Riordan campaign: "If we felt we wanted to rip off a letter indicating that we wanted to encourage the government to cause the waiver to occur, that would be fine."

On January 18, Riordan wrote Thompson that the waiver was "particularly important to California as the state currently faces a serious and troublesome budget deficit. I look forward to what I hope will be your prompt and favorable response to our appeal." The Riordan campaign then e-mailed the letter to reporters. Davis learned of Thompson's decision days later from a reporter, to whom Riordan had wondered whether Thompson had given him credit for the waiver. Meanwhile, Thompson staffer McCabe, when asked why the Bush administration gave advance notice to the Riordan campaign, responded, "I'm not at liberty to say." Thompson, who held a friendly news conference with Davis, said he was unaware of McCabe's call and told reporters, "If he did, he did it on his own."

Thus, a clever political ploy backfires. Gray Davis, not Dick Riordan, is helped, and George W. looks bad. Is this any way to run a campaign?

 
 

BACK TO NRO


 
 
shim
shim