The Problem with the European Press
Europe is a worry.

Mr. Novak is the George F. Jewett scholar at the American Enterprise Institute
June 20, 2001 8:35 a.m.

 

Printer-Friendly

Novak Archive

he surprise is not that he came, he saw, he conquered, but that the European press, abetted by the leftward hang of American political reporters, had thoroughly misled European elites about the essential guts, vision, and brains of President Bush.

Intelligent European reporters in Washington and New York have told their readers for years that Bush is a hick from Texas, unworthy of the attention of true elites, ignorant, invincibly misinformed, a rough rider over the views of others. Evidence: Bush unilaterally rejected the intelligent environmentalist's Kyoto Creed, they said.

Yet, after his wise, eloquent, and far-sighted Warsaw University Address, however, the tone in Europe visibly changed regarding President Bush. Even Ms. Amanpour, though it choked her to say it, commented on Bush's classic balanced cadences and large-minded vision, concluding that Europeans would have to revise theirs reviews of President Bush upwards and quite suddenly.

Corriere della Sera in Milan ran a front-page cartoon of Bush voicing that deft image of a "House of Liberty" from Ireland to the Urals, while at his knee newly elected Prime Minister Berlusconi tugs at his coat, whispering about his own copyright upon that symbol for his own coalition. A nice touch, Mr. Bush.

Vladimir Putin is being reported as warmed and gladdened by the American's ability to listen closely and to speak plainly and directly, and his willingness to explore the tacit presuppositions behind earlier (and newer) viewpoints and positions.

Suddenly, European elites are grudgingly admitting that Bush's thinking is ahead of theirs. They have some catching up to do intellectually, even if they end up disagreeing with him.

When, standing with European Commissioner Prodi, for instance, Bush replied gently to a reporter, "I would like to hear your [nodding to Signor Prodi] answer to that." The question was, Why are Europeans blaming Bush for his position on Kyoto, when not a single government in Europe has yet moved to ratify the Treaty, and the U.S. Senate under Clinton voted 95-0 against it.

Commissioner Prodi hemmed and hawed, saying it was the announced aim of all European governments and in the future steps would be taken…but the hypocrisy was now out in plain sight.

European elites have an infinite capacity for cynicism, stating fine words that reassure their allegiance of radical utopians, while having little or no intention of actually providing any action further than lovely words. Plain-speaking President Bush violated their code by matching his words exactly to the U. S. Senate's action. (Few have noticed the resemblance between Harry Truman of Missouri and George W. Bush of Texas.)

The problem of European foreign reporting in the United States has deepened to disastrous dimensions; a chasm yawns between its reporting and American reality. A minor cause of this incomprehension is the incorrigibly social democratic limitations of the European mind. European journalists just don't understand such elementary American realities as the building of communities where five generations ago virtually empty plains and valleys blew in the solitary wind. They do not understand that such communities were built through a love for risk, enterprise, cooperative labors, and religious faith. They don't understand that, without capitalist enterprise, such communities would have perished long ago, and that is why among us capitalism remains a good work. Our survival hinged upon it.

But the major cause of the problem of the European press is the irreligiousness and modernistic, amoral sophistication of the tone of voice favored by the European press. In such a tone, sympathy for the piety of students in Oklahoma, who insist on praying to Jesus at football games, is not an option. The writer's superiority to such benighted behavior in Oklahoma must be indicated, in order to preserve the complacence of his readers back home.

For European elites, American conservatives are a species worthy of amused mockery, not intellectual deference. Outside the U.K., no ideas but social democratic ideas get a thorough hearing in the European press.

Social democratic illusions about the world are suffocating Europe at its roots. An immense social crisis is descending rapidly on Europe, while its elites pride themselves on their superior culture. A chain of demographic time bombs has already begun to go off. Europe's population base is melting away like ice in July. The premises of welfare benefits for the elderly and other non-workers made so greedily by social democratic governments depended on a growing population, not a shrinking one. These promises will never be honored. In social democratic Europe, illusions rule. Where illusions rule, realities erupt with suddenness and force. For the future, unless there is an awakening, Europe is a worry.

 
 

BACK TO NRO


 
 
shim
shim