Google+
Close

The Corner

The one and only.

Clemency For Cory Maye



Text  



Radley Balko has been all over the story of Cory Maye, who is on death row in Mississippi for shooting a cop. His summary post is here, though there is much more on his site. Under normal circumstances, I would have no sympathy for a cop killer, but these circumstances were anything but normal. In the process of executing a warranted no-knock search on Maye’s neighbor in the middle of the night, cops burst into Maye’s home, unannounced. Maye woke up and, fearing for his life (that of his 18-month-old child), fired on one of the police, who later died from the wound. The cop’s death is a horrible tragedy, but the cause was the cops’ mistake — breaking down the door of the wrong home — not Cory Maye’s. If Maye reasonably believed his life was in danger, the shooting was self-defense. Even if he didn’t, it is hard to see how the death penalty could be warranted. (Note to the conspiracy-minded reader: The dead cop was the police chief’s son.) Tookie Williams may not have deserved clemency, but Cory Maye certainly does. Indeed, from Balko’s reporting, I don’t believe Maye should even be in jail. More here and here.



Text  


Sign up for free NRO e-mails today:

Subscribe to National Review