The Corner

The one and only.

lou dobbs democrats


Well, Derb, I haven’t yet been able to find the Beinart piece, so it’s tough to comment at this stage. I would note, however, that Beinart’s parallel effort to push the Democrats toward the center on national defense issues hasn’t worked out very well. If anything, Beinart-style hawks are in a more precarious position among Democrats than the doves Beinart once thought he could purge. Given all that, why should we assume that Beinart’s plans for the Democrats on immigration will be any more successful than his plans for the Democrats on national defense? You seem awfully (and uncharacteristically) optimistic to believe that, just because a few Democrats are tacking right on this issue, the rest of the Dems are bound to follow. I would also have to worry about the reliability of Dems on this issue, given their late conversion and the pressures that will surely be put on them to shift when the chips are down. The House Republicans held fast when few (including me) thought they would. Would johnny-come-lately Democratic converts do the same? Certainly I agree with Kathryn that there are a host of other reasons for getting out to vote Republican. In any case, so far I’m not remotely convinced that a conservative stance on immigration is not best served by a Republican congress.


Sign up for free NRO e-mails today:

Subscribe to National Review