The Corner

The one and only.

Sincerely Yours


This coming Sunday’s New York Times Book Review features a review of Why I Turned Right: Leading Baby Boom Conservatives Chronicle Their Political Journeys, by Stephen Metcalf of Slate. You won’t find anything thoughtful in it, just the usual hack-job tactic of assembling isolated quotes and casting them in the worst possible light. Still, the review is worth a look. Metcalf’s default assumption that anyone at a “corporate backed think tank” must be cynically attacking liberalism, strictly for the money, was evidently shaken by the book. Metcalf’s one concession is a surprised admission that public conservatives are actually “sincere.” This sincerity, Metcalf concludes, allows public conservatives to bond with the “culturally dispossessed” (i.e. ignorant yahoos like you).

Metcalf’s review had a kind of mirror-image effect on me. I find it hard to believe that any serious liberal could think that conservative writers don’t believe their own ideas, but simply do it for “corporate money,” although I know liberals say this all the time. I’ve also wondered whether conservative put downs of liberals as “elitists” who despise the masses are quite fair. I must admit, however, after reading Metcalf, that liberals can be completely sincere in such beliefs.

Why I Turned Right does seem to bend folks out of shape, as in the fellow who attacked the book for being well written. But thoughtful reflection on the well-springs of political conviction is not exactly the sign of our era. These days, just believing the other side means what it says is an achievement.


Sign up for free NRO e-mails today:

Subscribe to National Review