The Corner

The one and only.

Kmiec On Obama


I have a lot of respect for Doug Kmiec, but with respect to his latest missives on Catholics and Obama, he is, respectfully, off his rocker.   Whatever can be said of John McCain, I fail to see how his perceived imperfection would lead faithful Catholics to support a candidate who has a zero rating on life issues from the National Right to Life Committee, who voted against a state ban on partial-birth abortion, who has supported expanded stem-cell research, who emphatically supports Roe v. Wade, and who opposes even reasonable restrictions like parental notification or even a state version of the Born Alive Infants Protection Act (which passed the federal Senate 98-0).   Faithful Catholics would seem to have an obligation to consider Sen. Obama’s positions on the sanctity of life, and Professor Kmiec’s recent response to Ramesh, while acknowledging Obama’s general pro-abortion positions, fails to offer any hope that this particular “vineyard” would yield any fruit.  There is no indication in Obama’s record that he has anything but a reflexive pro-abortion bias or that he would not further ingrain the “culture of death” into our political and legal institutions.  I appreciate Professor Kmiec’s enthusiasm for “change,” but think this is an area where Obama would be as status quo as any Democrat.


Subscribe to National Review

Sign up for free NRO e-mails today: