The Corner

The one and only.

Brookings on Immigration


Jason Richwine of AEI writes about a new report from the Brookings-Duke Immigration Policy Roundtable. As he notes, the roundtable came out for getting rid of the “diversity lottery,” abolishing extended-family reunification, and increasing skilled immigration levels. These steps, taken together, would in my view be a vast improvement over current policy. So would some other steps the roundtable urges, such as giving skilled immigrants more freedom to switch employers.

But the question of whether to provide a path to citizenship remains as acrimonious as ever. The report advocates a series of linked steps toward both improved enforcement and legalization. Stephan Thernstrom and Peter Skerry, while praising the report in general, dissented from its recommendation on a path to citizenship. Skerry endorsed an idea I hadn’t heard before: allowing illegal immigrants to attain legal status while forever barring them from citizenship. “Such a program would address the human predicament we face, but also impose the clear and uncomplicated penalty on illegal immigrants that the American public has been demanding,” he writes.


Subscribe to National Review

Sign up for free NRO e-mails today: