An amusing press release from the National Alliance on Mental Illness just crossed the old NR transom:
Did NPR ‘Psychiatrist’ Remark about Juan Williams Violate the Americans with Disabilities Act?
NAMI Asks NPR to Take Action to Protect Against Hostile Work Environment
ARLINGTON, Va., Oct. 28 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ — The National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) has warned National Public Radio (NPR) that a remark made by NPR’s CEO in the firing of senior correspondent Juan Williams may violate the letter or spirit of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
In this week’s NAMI Blog, NAMI Executive Director Michael Fitzpatrick shares the text of a letter sent to NPR president and CEO Vivian Schiller, calling on NPR to adopt a plan no later than its board meeting scheduled in November to “educate and reassure” managers and employees about ADA protections in the workplace for people with mental health concerns.
After firing Williams for talking about Muslims during a Fox TV News program, Schiller told news media that Williams’ personal feelings should have been kept between himself and his “psychiatrist or publicist — take your pick.” Williams responded that he did not have a psychiatrist.
Schiller later apologized for the “thoughtless remark,” but NAMI called it an “outrageous” statement.
“NAMI remains greatly concerned about the cruel signal the incident has sent to millions of Americans — and its chilling effect both on people seeking help for mental health concerns and their expectation of privacy and support in employment relationships,” said Fitzpatrick.
NAMI warned Schiller the remark “may violate the letter and/or spirit of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) — risking creation of a hostile work environment, flowing from the top down through NPR and its affiliates for any employee who lives with mental illness.”
In the NAMI Blog, Fitzpatrick further noted: “Once again, someone has played ‘the stigma card,’ suggesting mental illness to discredit a person rather than debating issues on their merits.”
Fitzpatrick told Schiller the remark was “sadly inconsistent with NPR’s own stellar record of reporting fairly, accurately and compassionately on issues related to mental illness.”
The NAMI letter to Schiller was copied to NPR’s Vice-President for Legal Affairs and General Counsel, Joyce Slocum.
I'm wondering if a letter should be sent to NAMI from the ACLU with a warning that chastising someone (Schiller) for exercising their free speech rights could potentially lead to litigation.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseGawd but this has a sweet taste to it. I realize its a drop in the ocean, but even an instance of "them" being held to the same standard that "they" use to beat the rest of us over the head with is very satisfying. A taste of their own holier-than-thou PC medicine. I think I need a cigarette after that.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI honestly laughed out loud at that headline.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseShould the matter go to court, will Ms. Schiller still be a Good, Enlightened, Right-Thinking Person if as her defense she pleads insanity?
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse