Tonight may indeed may be a “seminal moment,” as McCain said. This was to be the appropriators’ last hurrah. In the end, they couldn’t see it through, and it’s not going to get any better for them next year.
Why did it go down? You had Jim DeMint rallying outside opposition, and pushing Reid’s back against the wall procedurally with the threat to have the whole monstrosity read on the floor; that was time Reid presumably couldn’t afford to waste given everything else he wants to jam through.
Then, you had Mitch McConnell on the phone all day with Republican appropriators–Reid’s base of support on the bill–twisting their arms to come out against it. My understanding is that by the end he had all the appropriators committed against it, with the exception of two who were undecided. McConnell told the appropriators that passing this bill, and passing it this way, would represent a rejection of everything the mid-term election was about, and ultimately he prevailed. Again and again over the last two years, McConnell has done what a minority leader needs to do–keep his troops united.
And, finally, there was McCain. He was out there, too. On “Hannity” last night, he sounded like a tea-partier, urging people to use social media and to flood the phone lines in opposition. It must have been particularly sweet for him, after all these years battling appropriators, doing a victory jig all over the bill on the senate floor a little while ago.
Altogether, a heartening night…
Finally, a demonstration of resolve that gives hope to Conservatives. It will take much more courage to undo the damage inflicted on America by Obama and the Democrats, so let us hope this indeed represents a seminal moment.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI never know what to believe about McConnell. Was he not an earmarker in this omnibus bill?
Bravo sir. Bravo.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseMcConneell and McCain come through with flying colors. A good sign for the Conservative Ascendancy.
External Link
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse"Because the Only Good Progressive is a Failed Progressive"
Thank you, Senators DeMint, McConnell, and McCain - very, very much.
That gigantic bag of goodies which many hoped to trumpet as gifts under the tree was, in fact, one monstrously huge piece of coal in our childrens' stockings.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWhen McCain is on the side of right, I love him.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse"In the end, they couldn’t see it through, and it’s not going to get any better for them next year...
... Altogether, a heartening night…"
As Han Solo said to Luke Skywalker after he shot down his first Empire fighter, "Great, kid - don't get cocky!"
This is FAR from over. The tough work - eliminating entire departments and agencies - HUD, Education, Agriculture, Energy, EPA - still lies ahead. And if you think the sweet, moral progressives and their enablers in the media have been harsh on you up to now, calling you every filthy name in the book (other than communist, which they don't consider filthy), you have no idea.
Remember, these are people who admire Fidel Castro because he's outlasted ten U.S. presidents, who think killing unborn babies eight months after conception is just fine, who... well, you get the picture. They will not lose gracefully or graciously. They will adopt Alan Grayson as their role model. Be prepared - here it comes.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI know some people are down on McCain, but how lucky are we to have this guy still in the Senate? I really think this is going to be a great year for McCain, as the party is really moving towards his longstanding positions on fiscal responsibility.
Here's to you, Senator!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseIt's just not possible to overstate how much McConnell has accomplished. Lots of folks don't think he's done enough, but they seem to miss how well he has played a long string of bad hands.
Put it this way - would you rather play poker against Reid or McConnell?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseRepublican hypocrites. They loaded up this bill with earmarks too. They're the ones buckling to pressure from the Tea partiers.
Reid was smart to pull the bill and remove a huge target for Republican attack.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWell done. Now go make sure DREAM doesn't pass.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWashington now requires constant vigilance. Plenty of Republicans would love to continue the spending, if not for the great unwashed paying attention. Take a break for a few minutes and they'd be right back at spending. They fact that they still, even after the elections, require arm twisting to reject such an awful pile of spending is proof enough.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWhen I saw the earmarks for just Senator Murkowski of Alaska, I realized what a monstrosity this bill was. So much political payback and pork - stunning when you consider the recent election and how many big spenders lost because of bills like this. I am so glad it has been pulled and I applaud every single NO vote. Thanks to all the GOP leaders who fought this and won!!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseMcConnell had 38 earmarks in it for $85M, the bill had 6,714 for $8.4B. The average $ per senator is $84M and 67 each. I believe these have been in the works since the spring. McConnell's two biggest were both MILCON type projects totaling $21M.
Earmarks as a process stink, but many programs that get in as earmarks are worthwhile, really wanted by the agency, and are proper spending. But we have also created way too many "National Frisby Museums" with this process also. The formal review process needs to be revised to evaluate better the earmarks.
I'm really liking McConnell, doesn't look like he would hurt a fly, isn't partisan, but has held caucus unity when one defection loses the battle. If the caucus had often caved over the last two years, where would we be - far deeper in debt and under the ruler's thumb.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWell done McCain. This is the a fight he's been fighting for over a decade. I'm glad he finally has some allies. I wish the tea partiers had supported him in his primary ten years ago. But this has to be just the beginning. There is a long battle ahead.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThe commentary is that a lot of this spending was proposed months ago, well before the Republicans in the Senate agreed to the moratorium on earmarks. Some took time to pull theirs others, claiming to believe that there was no chance of it ever reaching the Senate floor, did not. I do not know the truth. I do not support ear marks and feel that most local spending is not the province of the federal government. There are a lot of possibilities here. Perhaps the democrats believed that by including all the republican earmarks, the republicans would quietly go along fearing to oppose the bill when they have earmarks in it as well.
I was troubled to see that my Senator had a small number of earmarks in the bill. I was expecting that he would have none. I went to Tom Colburn's web site and looked at the list. Most appeared to be government funding of development projects for the DoD. Most were also solicited by the Dems in my state. We are changing the way that the government is going to be doing business. Perhaps many of the earmarks requested by my Senator were appropriate federal spending on basic research for defense programs. Hard to say. If so they can be addressed next year in a separate defense bill, for now we're better off killing this mess and starting fresh, Like I said, we are going to force a change in the mechanics of how the government spends our tax dollars.
In some sense it doesn't matter. What matters, with regard to this bill, is that McConnell, and other republicans, pulled the party appropriators back into line and this bill is DEAD.
Thanks to all who made this happen , in the Senate and the pressure appliers outside the Senate.
However, to the incoming Republicans in the 112th Congress, hear my words clearly. The regular people of this nation have awakened and are NOT going back to sleep. We will not make the mistake we made in 1994. We are watching you. We are following your votes and statements in committee and on the floor of your respective bodies. Business as you have conducted it for more than my life time (and I am an old man) is OVER.
Over the last two years spending is up 20%, If you can't cut 10% in a 3 trillion dollar budget in the first 90 days you aren't trying. For those of you who are math challenged, that's $300 billion. By the end of 2011 you should TRIPLE that number. Not cut growth, cut outlays.
Getting spending 5% under 2007 would be a good goal for 2011.
Still today you have done well. You have done your jobs. Thank you again.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseRich, someone at NR ought to be sketching out an outline for a feature "behind-the-scenes" piece on how the GOP's leading legislators in both chambers have mostly managed to avoid circular firing squads and purity purges in the run-up to these victories. Surely this can be a teachable moment?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseTo CT NRO Man et al:
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseMcConnell and the other establishment Republicans are far preferable to Stalinist democrats - however, trust but verify...
Fire them if they cave on conservative principle - replace them with Tea Party patriots - take over the Republican party and make it the Conservative party.
There is NO compromise with Stalinists - defeat them - period. There is no more maneuvering room - we are on the brink of tyranny and socialism.
hi bill, good thought--we're trying to get a piece w/ more of the behind-the-scenes story of this omni victory
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseMcCain will join forces with Graham to resume "reaching across the aisle" even before his arm -- currently out-of-socket from his patting himself self-congratulatorily on the back -- rights itself. Kudos to this centrist equivocator just for fighting a bill whose mere debut should have had Tea Partiers rioting in the streets? Forgive me for holding my plaudits in reserve. If so many in his party deem him worthy of basking in adulation just for his opposition to this bill, then it's a small wonder indeed that his party nominated such a weak and hopeless candidate in 2008, and it likewise bodes ill for 2012. Yea verily, the northeast GOP senators wink at overriding DADT, and simply retaining the Bush tax cuts comes at the profound cost of another 11/12 digits in dollars piled atop the debt, but let's not fret: It's time to party for John McCain!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseIf only they'd had the guts to follow through on the threat of reading the health care bill aloud in its entirety...
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse