No question, the biggest Capitol Hill story of the pre-Christmas week was the Senate’s ratification of the New START treaty. But let’s not overlook the remarkable achievement of Oklahoma senator Tom Coburn.
Amid high-profile lame-duck debates over New START, gays in the military, an omnibus spending package, and the Bush tax cuts, the 9/11 Health and Compensation Act had garnered relatively little attention — until Comedy Central funnyman Jon Stewart launched a one-man crusade to secure its passage. GOP critics of the measure were castigated as insensitive at best and immoral (perhaps even unpatriotic) at worst. No Republican caught more flak than Senator Coburn, who demanded significant changes to the bill and threatened to delay its approval until 2011.
The idea of boosting medical and financial aid to heroic Ground Zero workers was never controversial. But the proposed legislation needed serious fixes. Indeed, various aspects of the 9/11 bill — the cost, the duration, the lack of adequate oversight mechanisms, the loopholes for trial lawyers — were deeply problematic. Unfortunately, Republicans who suggested as much were pilloried for their “callousness” and “cowardice.”
Well, guess what? On Wednesday afternoon a compromise version of the 9/11 bill passed by unanimous consent. Had Coburn simply folded? Quite the opposite. He had succeeded in obtaining major revisions that greatly improved the final product.
Originally, the ten-year cost of the legislation would have been either $7.4 billion (House-passed version) or $6.2 billion (amended Senate version). The ten-year cost of the compromise will be only $4.2 billion. Originally, the bill would have cost billions more beyond the ten-year window. Those added costs were jettisoned entirely from the compromise. Originally, the re-opened 9/11 Victim Compensation Fund (VCF) — which closed in 2003 — would have stayed in operation through 2031. Now the VCF will be shuttered — permanently — in 2016. Originally, legislative loopholes would have permitted certain attorneys to gobble up a massive chunk of 9/11-related settlements. The compromise imposes a rigid ceiling on trial-lawyer fees, limiting them to 10 percent of the total amount awarded and giving the VCF “special master” authority to slash fees that he considers disproportionate. Originally, the bill suffered from a dearth of accountability controls. The compromise includes muscular safeguards against waste and abuse.
In short, Coburn’s thankless efforts resulted in a much better 9/11 bill — a bill that won approval without even a formal vote. I’m not sure there are any profound “lessons” to be drawn here — the 9/11 measure was a unique piece of legislation, and its chief Senate sponsors (New York Democrats Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand) were desperate to see it enacted during the lame-duck session — but the junior senator from Oklahoma deserves hearty praise for weathering a storm of vitriol and forcing the necessary improvements.
Yay for Coburn, except... "Originally, the re-opened 9/11 Victim Compensation Fund (VCF) — which closed in 2003 — would have stayed in operation through 2031. Now the VCF will be shuttered — permanently — in 2016."
Nothing is shuttered permanently in DC. All that needs to happen is to have another Congress decide to extend the program.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseOnly $4.2 billion! Well, that's like chicken feed.
I'm sorry, but this victim fund for first responders is nothing more than a payout to the fire and police unions. These guys get gold plated health insurance benefits and retirement/disability payments on the job and when they retire so giving them more assistance is disgusting, even more so when compared with how our veterans and servicemen are treated.
The drug addict this legislation is named for got great settlements. He was also on disability and I'm sure his health insurance was paid for. He OD'd. How is that related to what was in the air on 9-11?
Everyone's a victim. Everyone's a rent-seeker. So in like minded spirit, where's my Katrina money?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThis is pretty much how the system works, day-in, day-out. The democrats say, "let's jump off a 100-foot cliff!" The sober and civil republicans say, "not so fast. Let's make that a 50-ft cliff." The democans and republicrats get together and agree that jumping off a 75-ft cliff will suffice for this year.
NR sends their congratulations. Another triumph for conservative thinking.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseOf course the bill deserved to be defeated. Of course $4.2B is still a colossally corrupt amount, almost as bad as the DOA's massive payoffs to any racial minority member clever enough to claim a past desire to be a "farmer." Of course the system that allows such crimes to bankrupt us in broad daylight needs to be challenged. Principled conservatives are correct to scream and holler about it all...
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseEVEN SO, Senator Coburn deserves our highest praise, for actually doing something to limit the damage, AND for doing it in such a clear, simple and obvious fashion that it exposes the bill's sponsors, including Jon Stewart, as the Pharisees of the left.
I just wish Stewart had the cojones to invite Coburn on the first Daily Show after the holidays.