Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

The Horror of the Day

I’ve been trying to follow the story today while balancing some other obligations. I’ve been reading the instant-reaction on Twitter and on the web and I’ve been trying to filter out the urge to vent my rage at those who immediately shoe-horned these awful crimes into their ideological prism. There have been some truly disgusting displays of opportunism out there. I will confess to having made those kinds of mistakes in the past and I try very hard to learn from those mistakes.

If I had my druthers, the news networks would ban political commentators of all stripes for the first 24 hours after these kinds of tragedies. The rush to be wrong first is just too hard for some to resist.  If anyone cares, my column on the 2007 Virginia Tech shooting captures pretty well my feelings about the day.

Anyway, I’m going to hold off commenting until we know more. My thoughts and prayers to the families of all concerned.

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   143

EXPAND  

   01/08/11 18:23
from Florida
   01/08/11 18:26

"hold off commenting"? Probably something Sheppard Smith on Fox should do also. Repeating his journalistic mistakes a la hurricane Katrina, Smith had a state senator on Fox this PM who managed to get a Tea Party reference into her discussion of the victim.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
MT6227
   01/08/11 18:27

Exactly the type of reaction I expected as soon as I heard what had happened. Remember the rush to blame a "right winger" after the Fort Hood shooting and the attempted bombing in Times Square. How many commentators said that Obama needed an "Oklahoma City" moment in order to complete his triangulation al la Mr. Clinton. The left is trying to make this the moment. Over on Politico they are already blaming Palin's "target" map. It's par for the course, exploiting tragedy.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 18:47

"If I had my druthers, the news networks would ban political commentators of all stripes for the first 24 hours after these kinds of tragedies."

If that were to happen, then given the fact that the MSM is composed almost exclusively of left-wing political extremists AP, ABC, NBC, CBS, MSNBC, and CNN would go silent for 24 hours.

Nor is a waiting period going to help create a climate for more accurate and honest reporting, since there are no cooler heads to prevail in the MSM. On major stories like 9/11, the Cold War, the welfare state, and ObamaCare, it makes no difference to the MSM whether 24 hours or 24 years is allowed to pass. Politically-motivated disinformation is king at the MSM, and probably always will be.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
rails warner
   01/08/11 18:47

When you use terms like death panels some people might get worked up just a bit

Just going on a hunch here Jonah

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 18:50

The hits just keep on coming.

MSNBC Breaking News: "Sarah Palin, who TARGETED Rep. Giffords in 2010 election, offers condolences"

(source: Twitter)

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 Jay
   01/08/11 18:53

What's Rahm's mantra? Never let a tragedy go to waste?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 18:54

At least the president's statement, though not overly graceful, was in no way inappropriate or political. He deserves credit for that. The temptation to use this -- as we have seen already -- is obviously enormous. He may, and probably will, use it yet. But not today.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 19:05

mnmike, your posting was so infuriating, I had to look for myself. I couldn't find that tweet anywhere on MNSBC twitter feed. Perhaps it was there, and has subsequently been deleted. But, it certainly isn't there now.

http://twitter.com/#!/msnbc_breaking

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 19:09

Hyperbolic rhetoric from mainstream right wing writers/tv and radio personalities accusing Democrats of a secret plan to destroy the country and install socialism/fascism = meh.

Complaints from liberals about that hyperbolic rhetoric both before and after people are dead = unconscionable.

Do I have that math correct Jonah?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
DonAZ
   01/08/11 19:09

Jonah's expression of his "druthers" was clearly meant to be an emotional response rather than a reasoned policy statement. Of all people, Jonah would be the last to seriously advocate a mandated restriction in free speech. So c'mon folks.

I live in Tucson ... this took place about 10 miles to the northeast of where I live. It's a bit unsettling when something like this occurs so close to one's homestead.

I had occasion last year to sit next to Congresswoman Giffords on a flight from Chicago to Tucson. She is a gracious and decent person. I don't agree with her politics, but that disagreement did not prevent us from sharing a drink on that flight and enjoying a few hours of company.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 19:19

rails warner = the reason Jonah posted this. Unfreakingbelievable.

May God bless not just the souls of those killed and injured and their families, but you, too.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 19:21

The breaking news headline is still on my timeline (2hours old) from 19:21 Eastern.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 19:34

Maybe all political comments should have been withheld, but it's too late now. Time to get out and defend our people from baseless, horrific, unjust attacks by the Left. Palin, Limbaugh, Beck, FoxNews, and the TEA Party are all being blamed by Lefty luminaries like Paul Krugman, Jane Fonda, MSNBC, even one of the Dem Congressmen has jumped in.
Yes, there are people dead and people in surgery still. But that's no excuse for us to sit on our hands and hope the attacks by the Left somehow just go away.
And speaking of targets and a map, someone might want to reference the Daily Kos map that Markos tried to hide. Too bad the screeshots are getting out.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Mordy
   01/08/11 19:38

"I’ve been reading the instant-reaction on Twitter and on the web and I’ve been trying to filter out the urge to vent my rage at those who immediately shoe-horned these awful crimes into their ideological prism."

When someone decides to commit a violent act against anyone they are generally circumscribing themselves outside the normative socio-political arena. No one in the standard political discourse would ever dream of assassinating a politician, so these individuals are already outside the ideological prisms of Democrat (or liberal) and Republican (or conservative). Yet if we pretend like our normal discourses have absolutely no affect on these non-normative actors then we give up any responsibility (and agency) in the kind of community and culture we live in. Did using bullseye icons in a political map convince this man to attempt this assassination? I don't know. But I don't think the question is inappropriate. If that question is inappropriate, we might as well never ask about the influence of the things we write and discuss on the culture. And if the things we write and discuss have no effect on the culture than places like NRO are just a waste of space and time. Alternatively, these forums are worthwhile and can impact the culture both positively and negatively. And when something negative occurs, it is our duty to ask why and how we may have contributed to it (just like we might celebrate when we see a positive correlation).

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 19:45

Absolutely infuriating that anyone would try to make political hay over this. Doubly so before all the facts are in. But somehow it managed to get even worse as the day goes on.

The initial reaction of many on the left was despicable but unsurprising. They wanted to blame the right for this attack, and they couldn't even be bothered to wait for the facts. With each fact that emerged, the "right-winger" hypothesis becomes increasingly absurd. We now have evidence that this murderer was a flag-burning atheist who was "quite liberal," in the words of a high school friend. Oh, and while a Democratic Congresswoman is wounded, a Republican federal judge is dead at the hands of this guy.

You might think that the left would stop at this point and backtrack, or at least shift to "he's-a-nut-and-politics-has-nothing-to-do-with-this," but you'd be wrong. They're doubling down, still trying to pin this on the right.

This is absolutely disgusting. I haven't been this angry in months.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Harold W.
   01/08/11 19:48

The left created a mountain of dead bodies, upwards of 200 million in the last century, so I don't want to here any comments from the left on political violence. EVER.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Big T
   01/08/11 20:01

I wonder if comparing liberals to Hitler had anything to do with it. Maybe if there was a high-profile website out there whose contributors literally say that Democrats are conspiring with Jihadists to destroy America, then those clowns and cretins might offer an apology or a retraction right about now instead of pieties and off-topic mea culpas.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
avital2
   01/08/11 20:02

i am certainly concerned about Rep Giffords - but also am wondering why more isn't being said about a judge's death????

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/08/11 20:24

This will sadly be Oklahoma City all over again. Let's nonetheless hope that the democrats are more responsible this time.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Load More Comments

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact