Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

NYS Takes Control of Nassau County Finances

The New York Times reports:

A state oversight board has seized control of Nassau County’s finances, saying the wealthy and heavily taxed county had nonetheless failed to balance its $2.6 billion budget despite months of increasingly ominous warnings.

The 6-0 vote here on Wednesday afternoon by the Nassau County Interim Finance Authority gives it veto power over the county’s budget, labor contracts, borrowings and other major financial commitments.

The board cited a deficit that reached nearly $350 million at one point last year but that was not fully closed, it said, despite assurances to the contrary by the county executive, Edward P. Mangano, a Republican.

It was only the second time a county had been taken over by New York State… 

The move effectively puts the finance authority board, a six-man panel of state-appointed financial experts and other professionals, at the bargaining table opposite Nassau’s civil servants, police officers and other labor unions.

The board also could unilaterally impose a freeze in wages, a strong club for Nassau, which has been sapped by lucrative salaries, benefits and costly work rules for its police and other workers. But the board chose to stop short of that for now, saying it would try to work with the county first.

Nassau Couny is practically iconic for its high public-sector employee pay. Pensions are so generous that openings in the police department are known to induce, in the words of the New York Times, a “stampede” of out-of-county, and even out-of-state cops. In 2007, more than 28,000 police officers signed up to take the Nassau County police exam. 

Because of that, despite the second highest property taxes in the country,and a six-figure median family income (Nassau is the third-wealthiest county in the U.S.), the Long Island suburb has endured severe budget shortfalls in the last decade. And now, according to E. J. McMahon, a New York state and local policy expert with the Empire Center, it is facing a crisis from “the projected cost of scheduled wage increase in a county that already pays its employee handsomely (county cops, for example, make an average of $126,000, and few employees contribute anything to their health coverage).”  Nassau has long been something of “an outlier” thanks to “to the free-spending traditions of the Republican machine that controlled the place for decades.” In McMahon’s words, “it takes work to be both wealthy and broke.” The Nassau County Interim Finance Authority (NIFA — the board that is seizing control of  Nassau’s finances), in fact, was established in response to a similar crisis in 1999.

I spoke with County Executive Ed Mangano a couple of weeks ago about Nassau’s budget crisis. At that time, he had three intended courses of action: Plan A was to get the unions to voluntarily renegotiate their contracts, in accordance with the normal procedure — but union leaders announced their refusal. Plan B was to pass legislation called the “Taxpayer Relief Act,” which would authorize Mangano to unilaterally reopen county labor contracts  to order givebacks. And if that was prevented by a legal challenge, Plan C was to start firing public employees in 2012 (that power was contracted away for 2011). 

Evidently NIFA found these inadequate, possibly because the 2011 budget was, according to the Times reporter, cooked: 

Mr. Mangano inherited a growing deficit when he took over in January, but his first action worsened it: he eliminated a tax on home heating fuel that would have reaped $40 million in revenue. His 2011 budget also counted on $60 million in phantom concessions from labor unions, more than $20 million in state aid that has not materialized, and $100 million in new borrowing for operating expenses.

Keep your eye on this as it unfolds. Other local governments in New York and elsewhere are approaching similar crises. Nassau’s resolution could set the pattern.

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   9

EXPAND  

thibaud
   01/26/11 15:46

Nassau has long been something of “an outlier” thanks to “to the free-spending traditions of the Republican machine that controlled the place for decades.”

Not an outlier at all. Both parties across the nation have been paying off powerful public sector unions for many years. Both parties are determined to pander to the latino voting bloc with an utterly insane, open-borders low-end immigration policy that would be unthinkable in any other advanced democracy.

Tweedledum and Tweedledee. Working families be damned.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/26/11 15:48

Hopefully this can help convince my sister and brother-in-law to vote for Repub...

-- thanks to “to the free-spending traditions of the Republican machine that controlled the place for decades.” --

...oh.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
JD522
   01/26/11 15:52

How screwed up do your finances have to be for NY *State* to come in and try to fix them? That's like having Charlie Sheen tell you you might want to go easy on the booze and blow.

Later,

Joe

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 Bugg
   01/26/11 16:27

Besides county police, many of the small towns within Nassau County have their own equally well-paid police forces. Not onlya re they well-paid, but redundant.At the same time you have state troopers responsible for the various roadways. There are some areas like Roosevelt and Hempstead that have high crime, but the level of policing is mostly beyond absurd. And that's mostly because many of the towns expanded and incorporated due to "white flight" from New York City after the 1950s, the new residents wanted massive but mostly unnecessary police protection. Remarkably almost every Nassau police officer started his or her career with NYPD. This is also true of neighboring Suffolk County. Arguably their police academies are a waste as well. The top salary of NYPD is nowhere near that of the suburban police departments.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/26/11 16:34

Say hello to the Quebec Islanders!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Karen
   01/26/11 17:01

Nassau County went democrat over a decade ago. I grew up in Uniondale and watched Margiotti run things, and then get in trouble, and the democrats came in and the cronyism kicked in. Nassau County has some of the highest crime towns in the country. Hempstead is like a third world country. It is one of the most segregated areas of the country according to the census. Each town has its own school district, and it is either great or horrible.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/26/11 18:58

Who was that guy yesterday on the Comments claiming that all these lower-level NYS agencies and governments were not going to be absorbed by the state?

If NYS considers a county to be under the State, then the PBC's are definitely state-run...and their debt is the state's debt.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Eman
   01/26/11 21:56

When I served in a grand jury a couple of summers ago, it struck me that a very high percentage of the cops who testified were former New York City police. I knew then that Nassau County was paying too much!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   01/27/11 14:22

hokkoda - nobody questions the fact that legally speaking the authorities and agencies are creatures of the state.

And in every state counties are "under" the state. Counties only exist because the state creates them. Counties are not like states are in the federal system. The counties didn't "come together" to form the state government. The state government created them as administrative units and delegated certain power and authority to county governments in order to better provide services (i.e. - schooling, police forces, etc.) If the state wanted to abolish every county in the state, it could do so and it could then provide all of those services directly. It can also, at any time, change the power and authority that the county governments have to make decisions - as New York has in the case of Nassau County.

But being "under" the state doesn't make everything the county does a state action and put the state on the hook. If Nassau goes bankrupt, its bondholders still have no claim on state revenues to pay them off. They will have to take a haircut unless the state voluntarily decides to provide such funds to the county to cover its debt. As a practical matter that is liable to happen - the state does not want to ruin the municipal bond market and make it harder for every other county in the state to obtain financing in the market. But as a legal matter it is not a foregone conclusion.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact