Is Egypt about to erupt in a full-blown revolution that could lead to the fall of President Hosni Mubarak’s regime? Might Jordan’s government be next?
One thing’s for certain: No one predicted the demonstrations in Egypt would grow so big so fast. Momentum for the protests is growing. A Facebook page promoting the democracy protests grew from 20,000 members on Wednesday to 80,000 on Thursday. The government then reportedly shut down Facebook, and disrupted Internet service in parts of the country. Twitter has been blocked. Police are beating protesters. As of Friday, more than 1,000 Egyptians have been arrested for demonstrating. Now an overnight curfew has been imposed and the Egyptian army has been deployed to urban centers.
One key factor fueling events: economics. Egyptians have been suffering double-digit inflation — averaging between 10 percent and 14 percent — and soaring food prices in recent years. Reports Reuters: “The Food and Agriculture Organization, a body of the United Nations, said on January 5 that food prices hit a ‘record high’ in December 2010, topping 2008 levels when riots shook Egypt as well as other countries.”
Most Egyptians are already dirt poor. Skyrocketing food prices are causing them to fear they may not be able to feed their families. This is creating a “perfect storm” of anger against the Mubarak regime — it’s corrupt, authoritarian, anti–human rights, and resistant to all positive economic and political reform. It’s been bad for the 30 years Mubarak has been in power, since the assassination of Pres. Anwar Sadat, the bold reformer. But now Egyptians are being pushed over the brink.
Calls for Mubarak to step down are growing. “Mohamed ElBaradei, the former head of the U.N. nuclear watchdog turned Egyptian reform campaigner, said he expected big demonstrations across Egypt on Friday, and that it was time for President Hosni Mubarak to go,” reported Reuters. “ElBaradei, 68, left Vienna, where he lives, for Cairo on Thursday to join a growing wave of protests against Mubarak inspired by Tunisia’s overthrow of their authoritarian president. He told Reuters he would not lead the street rallies, but that his role was ‘to manage the change politically.’” On Friday, however, ElBaradei was placed under house arrest in Egypt.
In my 2009 non-fiction book Inside The Revolution, I described Mubarak as a “classic Resister.” While nominally a Sunni Muslim, he’s not an Islamic radical. He’s not a revolutionary of any kind. To the contrary, he doesn’t want real change of any kind. He just wants to retain power, keep things stable, keep wealth and power for himself, and pass the keys to the kingdom on to his son Gamal. But such resistance to positive change is inflaming the “rank-and-file,” everyday Egyptians who feel increasingly desperate and see others in the region (Tunisians, Iraqis, and the people of southern Sudan) changing their governments and having more of a say in affairs of state. Egyptians are yearning for something better, and now they’ve taken to the streets in hopes of getting it.
Meanwhile, protests have mounted in recent days in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. There, too, economics is playing a critical role. Reports the AP: “The economy saw a record deficit of $2 billion this year, inflation rising … to 6.1 percent just last month and rampant unemployment and poverty — estimated at 12 and 25 percent respectively. ‘The government buys cars and spends lavishly on its parties and travel, while many Jordanians are jobless or can barely put food on their tables to feed their hungry children,’ said civil servant Mahmoud Thiabat, 31, a father of three who earns $395 a month.”
In Egypt, I don’t see the protests being driven initially or primarily by the Muslim Brotherhood (which started in Egypt in the 1920s) or by other radical Muslim groups, though the Islamists are certainly trying to take advantage. This would be a nightmare scenario we must pray never happens. We don’t want this to be another Iranian Revolution where an Islamic-radical madman takes over. If Mubarak falls, we want to see a group of pro-democracy, pro-free market, serious reformers come to power.
In Jordan, there is a very high risk that Islamic radicals would take over the regime. As I write in Inside The Revolution, “It is precisely because the Jordanians have made such progress [with positive political and economic reforms in the past two decades] that I am worried by the Radicals’ determination to launch a jihad there, seize the capital, and create a new anti-Israel, anti-Western base for Iran and al Qaeda. Therefore, I often pray for Jordan’s peace, prosperity and continued progress. I pray for King Abdullah’s health and safety, and I pray that the Lord would grant him the wisdom to know how best to move forward in such challenging times.”
On top of all this, the Iranian-backed Hezbollah terror movement has just toppled the government in Lebanon. Iran’s leaders are convinced their so-called messiah known as the Twelfth Imam is coming to earth at any moment, and feverishly trying to build nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles to help usher in a new messianic age and an Islamic caliphate.
Unfortunately, the Obama administration doesn’t get it. “Our assessment is that the Egyptian government is stable and is looking for ways to respond to the legitimate needs and interests of the Egyptian people,” said Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. Is she kidding? The Mubarak regime is not stable. It is an authoritarian, corrupt, anti–human rights, anti–free speech regime. The Egyptian people deserve better. They deserve freedom and democracy and free markets. Perhaps the greatest democracy in the world should be backing them.
— Joel C. Rosenberg is the New York Times bestselling author of seven novels and non-fiction books on Israel and Islam. His newest book is The Twelfth Imam.
This is a useful and thought-provoking post, thank you Mr. Rosenberg.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseDo the chickens continue to come home to roost, born of the Bush-Obama policy of military occupation of Islamic countries? Is it just a coincidence that the Muslim nations with whom the U.S. is the friendliest -- Egypt and Jordan -- are currently the most threatened? It is not. Is Pakistan next? It's time to get out of Afghanistan entirely, to adhere to the Iraqi Status of Forces Agreement to the letter, and to be out of that miserable sandbox entirely by the end of the year.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThis comment is disturbing: "Unfortunately, the Obama administration doesn’t get it. “Our assessment is that the Egyptian government is stable...." Jimmy Carter with his concern for “human rights” facilitated the downfall of the Shah of Iran and helped turn it into the terrorist state it is today. Now it appears the absolute naiveté (or downright stupidity and incompetence) of Obama and H. Clinton may well bring about the takeover of Lebanon, Egypt and perhaps Jordan by radical Islam! By not taking a firm stand against radical Islam, Obama has emboldened the Mullahs and Imams to take over Mid east societies. Obama promised change but this certainly isn’t the kind of change that is helpful to the world! I thought Obama’s incompetence might have some limitation, but apparently I was mistaken.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse---"I am worried by the Radicals’ determination to launch a jihad there, seize the capital, and create a new anti-Israel, anti-Western base for Iran and al Qaeda. "---
Note also, that if Jordan went full Islamist, you have Jordan + Syria + Iran bracketing Iraq.
---"“Our assessment is that the Egyptian government is stable and is looking for ways to respond to the legitimate needs and interests of the Egyptian people,” said Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. Is she kidding?"----
Someone would expect something different from her, the CIA, the State Dept., the Obama Administration?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseObama is pulling a Carter - abandoning an ally to Muslim revolutionary fanaticism. America should launch airstrikes against the protesters immediately. We cannot allow another Iran to menace Israel.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse"The Mubarak regime is not stable. It is an authoritarian, corrupt, anti–human rights, anti–free speech regime. The Egyptian people deserve better. They deserve freedom and democracy and free markets. Perhaps the greatest democracy in the world should be backing them."
Yeah, but he's OUR son of a b***h, right?. All this fatuous cluck clucking on NRO about the Obama administration not standing up for "democracy" in Egypt is a load of nonsense.
Is the Obama administration not continuing a central plank of US foreign policy since the administration of Saint Ronald Reagan (peace be upon him)? Has not the Egyptian government not received tens of billions of dollars in US aid over the course of the last 4 administrations (3 of which were of course Republican)? Would you not say that supporting the only Arab state with a peace treaty with Israel for all of the 1980s and part of the 1990s, a state that also contributed thousands of troops, along with legitimacy to Desert Storm, AND that has consistently supported US policy in the Middle East, was the WRONG choice for the last 30 years? In fact it seems like a pretty rational one, and probably the only choice Reagan, Bush, Clinton, Bush, and Obama could possibly make.
Mubabrak is appalling, no doubt, but don't go pretending that US support for him began on January 20, 2009, or that there were not (and ARE not) good strategic reasons for preferring the devil you know to the one you don't...
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseMy fear is Egypt goes the way of the Cedar Revolution in Lebanon. 6 years later we have Hezbollah Running the Country.
While we can advocate Democracy (like we did in Iraq), the problem is that this administration, will certainly sit on the side-lines (a point made by the posting) and thus, allow the more radical elements to take over.
Democracy at its core can become oppressive just like Fascism and Communism. The Founders in the United States Understood this, and thus created a Constitutional Republic driven by Democratic Elections. If Egypt is to have "Democratic election" the demand this is step two. Instead people should be protesting in order to secure natural and basic political rights, Democracy should be a vehicle, but one that cannot trump natural rights.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse@ 180 Out -- SF CA
What's going on in Egypt has nothing to do with the U.S. in Iraq and Afghanistan. I'd like to say that if you actually read the news lately you wouldn't post things like that, but I have a feeling it matters not one whit if you read the news.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse"If Mubarak falls, we want to see a group of pro-democracy, pro-free market, serious reformers come to power." Yes, ideally. But I can't imagine anything replacing the Egyptian and jordanian regimes that will be friendlier to Israel (and thus the US). I think this is all unsettling for friends of israel.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWhoever may be in the streets now, in a closed muslim society like this, the movement is bound to be taken over by the most blood thirsty group -- here, the muslim brotherhood and their ilk.
Social media is clearly the biggest threat to tyrrany. The pattern now is that when revolutions spark the tyrant pulls the plug on the web.
I understand opposition groups find some ways around the tech blackout but I wonder if there's technologies that free governments can use or develop to further support an opposition staying connected. This seems like a very worthwhile project (that is, if our govt and its allies were truly intersted in supporting the cause of freedom).
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseMr. Rosenberg - I think this will end badly for the US and Israel. As I've indicated before, the number of democratic Arab states can be counted on the fingers of no hands, and so all these riots will not end up with democracy; it will end up with anti-American, anti-Israel Islamists in control.
SF CA - Why would US assistance (which you call, occupation) to Iraq and Afghanistan affect Egypt and Jordan? What you are saying is a non sequitur.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseMy husband and I recently viewed the documentary on Gerda Weissmann--a Jewish teen enslaved by the Nazis during WW2. It sparked a conversation between my husband (CT) and me regarding the the US economy. CT is a financial planner and advisor, thus he keeps abreast of economic trends (as best anyone can these days). As I understand the problems before WW2, hyper-inflation was the main issue. Much of the hatred toward the Jews was fueled by fear and desperation. After all, the Germans felt the need to blame someone for the hyper-inflationary economy. We know the outcome of that senerio. Now we ask, could this happen again? In the U.S. of A.? I think so, but this time it will be not only the Jew that suffers, but all Christians. Scripture reminds us to pray for our leaders. We have work to do. The world is not only hungry for food, but for truth. Jesus said, "I am the way, the truth, and the life." Let us be busy bringing saving grace to the hungry souls around us.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseMr Rosenberg, good work. Is Hilary Cinton kidding? Unfortunately NO. In the title of your piece you ask,
"Revolution in Egypt?" Yes, the issue is what kind...
"Is Jordan Next?" Jordan? Jordan?(ask the question like Jim Mora's "playoffs" rant)...
WE'RE NEXT!!!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI am in total agreement with "linearheights" (above) as well as most of Mr. Rosenberg's piece. The turmoil in the Mideast has escalated over the past 20 years and seems to continue to do so--in the case of Egypt, for valid reasons. Benign dictators (Mubarak; the Hussein monarchy in Jordan) are still dictators as far as their people are concerned and it is they who bear the burden of far more than the price of a gallon of gas.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI think John Mcternan has it right. This is now the time Islam will go crazy and attack Israel on literary every side. God is no longer going to allow this false faker religion to prosper when they rise to finish off Israel. In fact He will use Israel to destroy the nations that come against her. See Psalm 83, the book of Obadiah, and Zach. The false god Allah is going to be shown up as a fake without power when Israel destroys the nations around her as they attack from all sides. It is going to be a rough time for Israel and many will die there also. We are seeing the end of the age rapidly advancing to its final culmanation.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseJoel, These revolutons in nontheocratic Islamic states are setting the table for the acceptance of the "Twelfth Imam." Oil will be their weapon against western indusrialized nations. They will use it to neutralize non Islamic world powers while they focus on the destruction of Israel. To get a picture of how his all works out, read what the prophet Ezekiel writes in chapters 36 thru 39. Wow! What a fascinating time to be alive.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseJoel, many talk about USA is not a good friend, they abanden Shah Iran, trying to leave Israel as well, many think as I do that our Lord is coming soon and we have to be prepare and preach the Gospel to all nations, and pray for peace and stability. for me( A Converted Muslim) I like Mubarik compare to muslim brotherhood, he is calm and like peace. my prayers are with Mubarik and egyptian people, May God be merciful to this nation and draw them to see the salvation.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI'm a jordanian , and i dont think what you said will happen in jordan ,because revolutions is not in contact with religous things ! and by the way there is a number of christians in jordan you know ,, and i beleive that you need to pray that king abdulla and all the arab kings and presidents should go away and leave ; because they are the one's who are stealing and doing all the wrong things believe me !
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse