Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

As in Wisconsin, So in Idaho

Idaho has a “superintendent of public instruction,” and his name is Tom Luna. He has proposed some measures that the teachers’ union doesn’t like, at all. And his opponents have made sure that he feels good and threatened.

Someone went to his mother’s house — his mother’s. Someone slashed his tires and spray-painted a threat onto the door. As reported in this article, Luna has said, “Family and personal property are off-limits. You don’t cross that line . . .”

Oh, yes, you do. At least some do. I will repeat what I have already said this morning: I don’t want to hear from the Left about “civility” for the rest of my life.

The public-employee unions don’t own this country. They may think they do. But we all do. Right? I hope people all across the country, even those who disagree with him, will back Tom Luna: back his right to operate unmolested.

P.S. Following events in Wisconsin and elsewhere, I think of a phrase from The Wizard of Oz: “and your little dog, too.” That’s the malevolent spirit these union jerks are expressing.

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   27

EXPAND  

   02/18/11 10:21

The starkness of this- the right being blamed for Tuscon and the *professional* left following up with widespread turmoil with little backlash- is too much. You couldn't credibly write this. One hopes the American public gets it.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/18/11 10:30

And as union activities get uglier and spread around the country, President Obama's position is that unions are being assaulted and he cautions us not to vilify our friends and neighbors, i.e., union members carrying violence-themed signs, behaving in threatening ways, creating chaos and vandalizing personal property.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/18/11 10:36

In his 1998 book Inside Terrorism, Bruce Hoffman defined terrorism as "the deliberate creation and exploitation of fear through violence or the threat of violence in pursuit of political change" (page 43).

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
1776
   02/18/11 10:38

If only we could melt the leftist "witches" by pouring water on them...

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
TRO
   02/18/11 10:39

Jay,

I'm a federal employee and I absolutely HATE public employee unions. In fact, I'm not fond of any union after having almost violent confrontations with them when I worked in the private sector many years ago (I was lower management and had to cross that picket line - they knew it and yet still pounded and spit on my car and yelled plenty of stuff I can't type here).

I personally know other public employees (including two teachers) who hate them as well, but are afraid of what will happen to them if they voice their opinions.

Public employee unions need to be outlawed in general, but doing away with collective bargaining rights is a good start.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Flambeaux
   02/18/11 10:43

The American public won't "get it". A goodly portion of them are these thugs. The rest are too apathetic to notice.

Thus do all republics and democracies descend into civil disorder and chaos, necessitating the emergence of a strong dictator to restore order. Sadly, the few Americans who do care are also enamored with the myth of American "exceptionalism" and live in denial that even this republic is doomed to this fate.

It's been a good run but even the Founders couldn't change human nature. And, thus, the experiment was doomed from the beginning.

We made it about as long as the Roman Republic did. Decadence has set in the same way. And it will come to its necessary conclusion over the next century or so in the same way.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/18/11 10:48

I want to thank and praise Jay Nordlinger for writing with passion and clarity on this situation with the government empowered unions, particularly the one in charge of "education." This is serious business, a prelude to our future, and while the American public probably won't get it -- does it ever? -- I like to fantasize that a few people here and there are catching on: that our enemies on the left mean business and civility as the chosen response will prove inadequate.

Allow me to be blunt: the goal of our resistance is not to have lunch with socialist* Obama and his minions, but to render these wretched people impotent over our lives. Like our enemies abroad, our enemies at home are now free to strike whenever and wherever they please with the full encouragement of the media (which remains a powerful political force.) As Stanley Kurtz has explained, we are now fulfilling (the amazing, moderate, reaching across the aisle, triangulating) Obama's plan.

And just wait until he brings in the artillery of race. Not good. Not good at all.
_______________________

*What kind of socialist? I think this version:
External Link 

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 Huey
   02/18/11 10:51

I don't think this will help Wisconsin, but the folks in Idaho haven't surrendered the God given right of self-defense.

I would recommend exercise of 2nd Amendment privileges.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 Huey
   02/18/11 10:53

Excuse me...I mean 'privilege' in the sense of God, not the State, conferring it to us at birth.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
theduchessofkitty
   02/18/11 11:12

These acts of violence would make union thugs no different from the Ku Klux Klan...

"In his 1998 book Inside Terrorism, Bruce Hoffman defined terrorism as "the deliberate creation and exploitation of fear through violence or the threat of violence in pursuit of political change" (page 43)."

Hmmm... Didn't the Klan commit acts of terrorism in its heyday?

Again... Hmmm...

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/18/11 11:22

It looks like the Left is trying to make the debate emotional, as if they know they can't win a reasoned argument. They're ginning up a shouting match so voters can't distinguish between the alternatives.

If the Wisconsin government can come through this looking businesslike and determined, that's a huge blow to the lefty meme of angry conservatives.

Don't expect the electorate will get angry at this. It's not like the Republicans haven't done their share making the problems. And most people don't pay enough attention to this stuff to see the tactics with enough clarity to get angry. Maybe they should, and it's still more irritating that these childish tactics don't carry a higher price.

But the winning ground is in the policy. Which is why the Left is so eager to move to more chaotic ground.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Pete Oliver
   02/18/11 11:34

Jay
Keep 'em coming. You're on fire.
Thanks
Pete

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/18/11 11:43

Fear and intimidation is all that these losers have.

Public employees are decently paid. They are not the abused workers at the beginning of the last century, when unions were needed to prevent abuse by employers.

I know, I am a former civil servant in California.

Naturally, I'm sympathetic, but these tactics make me repudiate them. Let's hope they lose the goodwill of everyone.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
TxCard
   02/18/11 11:48

Somebody link to that obnoxious and completely unsupported rant by Bill Maher (I know, that's an oxymoron) on Leno's show after Tucson about how all the violent rhetoric eminates from the right. Add this Idaho stuff to SEIU beatings of opponents in St. Louis, the protests in Madison, and multitudes of ACTUAL EVIDENCE that Bill Maher doesn't know what he's talking about (as if we needed more proof)!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/18/11 14:26

And the head editorial hack in the local rag, opined that just because Luna's mother was approached by someone and his car spray painted didn't necessarily mean that these were teacher's unionites or their fellow travelers - why it could have been a juvenile delinquent that did it. I mean the timing could have been purely coincidental! And the guy that went to his mom's house? It could have been anyone. We just don't know and we shouldn't leap to conclusions.

(The Statesman is a McClatchy paper - enough said I think)

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Lanette
   02/18/11 14:34

I began asking for support for folks to come together and go to Wisconsin with an offer to teach these kids until the Wisconsin nonsense is over. A couple of people on Twitter "Retweeted," but no takers.
If groups of 4 in every city came together and went to Wisconsin for help, it would show our seriousness behind kids first, not unions.
Liberals win these fights because Conservatives love to arm chair quarterback.
The liberal nightmare will never end unless Conservatives start disrupting their comfortable lives. Problems don't arise on a schedule. You can't open your planner and see that Wisconsin will shut down the third Tuesday in May.
Yes, the belief in the individual is an incredibly important, keystone belief for Conservatives but, watching the rights of the individual evaporate because the liberal groups mobilize on a dime and conservative mobilize on a schedule is pathetic.
I don't want to hear another word from another Conservative. Words are great but actions are results.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/18/11 14:59

Hey, Lanette--

Can't make your fun-filled trip to WI. Gotta work to pay my (soon to be rising) taxes.

A Conservative

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
WPMCCC
   02/18/11 15:01

How can we judge the actions of thousands by the thuggery of a few? We ask others not to judge us by teh buffooner of John Birchers and their ilk. Let's try and be adults. Let the liberals be the name callers.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/18/11 15:13

The spoiled brats demonstrating in Wisconsin are not MY friends. If I knew them, I would tell them not to expect a Christmas card from me ever again. I don't live there, so they are not my neighbors. If they were, I would shun them. I would not want them teaching my children if I had any, and I think their appalling example teaches all the children something really awful: you can get what you want if you just throw a tantrum big enough and loud enough. Definitely not a lesson that should be propagated. Are the test scores of WI children worth mentioning?

I hope they all get fired, and the governor hires minimum wage babysitters to come in and keep the kids in an orderly environment for the length of a school day, until computer learning tutors (not teachers) can be hired to show kids how to do self-paced learning. The best classes I ever had were self-paced, and the promise of free time made me work harder to get done faster. I had wonderful teachers in most of my public school classes, but I also wanted to learn as much as possible. At this point, I think computers have made most teaching positions obsolete.

Now if the WI legislature will also pass a law making it illegal to offer benefits to employees, so we all work for wages alone, that will close off one avenue of improvidence. I'm sure there are downsides to that, but are they worse than the state government defaulting on its fiscal responsibilities?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/18/11 17:11

Many years ago I could have replaced a teacher who was on strike in a private school but chose not to do so. Believe me, I really needed the job. Now, I am kicking myself! There are a lot of ungrateful people out there.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Load More Comments

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact