Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

March 5 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

Malaysian PM: Muslim Brotherhood Must Renounce Violence or Be Left Out

Since the beginning of the uprising in Egypt and the expected power shift in favor of the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamic world has rallied around the Brotherhood and demanded that the West engage with them. But a crack in that unity appeared today when Malaysian prime minister Najib Razak said that the Muslim Brotherhood “shouldn’t be part of the process as long as they don’t reject violence and extremism.”

“Anyone who wants to be part of the political process should adopt values that are compatible with democracy,” Najib said in an interview in Istanbul, where he is speaking at a conference on moderation. “It’s not just about having a vote and choosing your leaders; it’s also part of imparting the right values for democracy to work, because there are failed democracies as well.”

Najib said he has “some concerns, deep concerns” about Yusuf al-Qaradawi, the Muslim Brotherhood’s spiritual leader. Those concerns center on Qaradawi’s support and justification for terrorism, which carries a great deal of weight given Qaradawi’s credibility as an Islamic scholar. It is exactly that type of Muslim leader that has led the Middle East astray, according to Najib. “We have lost a lot of ground to the extremists in the Middle East.”

He offered his own country as a model to emerging Islamic governments in the Middle East, saying that Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has described Malaysia as “modern, progressive, and moderate.”

“We shouldn’t want to impose on people, but people are welcome to study our experience and how we’ve done things in Malaysia. Perhaps it could be useful in their country,” he said.

Too many leaders, Najib said, misunderstand moderation. “I think they’re not paying enough attention to the values associated with being a moderate,” he said. “Moderate doesn’t mean that you’re a wimp — far from it. It means that you’ve chosen a path because you believe that’s the only way for global harmony and peace.”

— Seth Mandel is a fellow in the Foundation for Defense of Democracies National Security Fellowship Program.

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   30

EXPAND  

   02/23/11 15:34

Malaysian prime minister Najib Razak moderate?

Only if "moderate" means "doesn't wish to be reminded of his anti-Semitic comments".

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
disgusted
   02/25/11 06:27

This malaysian PM is a hypocrite and dim-witted

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
spiky
   02/25/11 08:11

Well, isnt this the statement of the year!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Hashim Yaacob
   02/25/11 09:47

Hypocrite Prime Minister of Malaysia.If you know his background you will laugh till your stomach ache. Funny talking to the peoples of Turkey. Tried to prove himself good. He is more a lest than Mubarak.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
shakir taha
   02/25/11 12:27

You know Najib? You will laugh like.......kah,kah,kah,.The best actor of the year.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/25/11 12:49

This article is written in the context of

A) $20 million contract between APCO worldwide and the Malaysian government that has been widely reported and is documented in FARA records. Part of that campaign is to promote the Malaysian government in the US and rehabilitate the Malaysian prime Minister's image which is badly tarnished by a number of scandals including the alleged involvement in the murder of a Mongolian woman in 2006. The other part of the APCO effort is to undermine the support that Malaysian opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim carries in Washington DC among policy makers and the media.

B) Anwar Ibrahim as a well regarded Muslim democrat has been calling for broader engagement with all political parties in the Muslim world so long as they renounce violence but has urged the US and EU to discard age old prejudices and side with reformers on all sides of the political divide. This is of course vehemently opposed by neoconservatives as well as the pro-Israeli lobby which stands to benefit more from America's continued overt support of dictators in the Middle East. Although he has been criticized for his belief that engagement with groups like the Brotherhood is essential, these statements have in no way undermined his relationships with Republican or Democratic parties in the US.

APCO has used his alignment as an Islamist to try and smear Anwar Ibrahim's name in DC and drive a wedge between him and his friends on Right and the Left. It looks like certain writers like Rachel Motte, Josh Trevino and Seth Mandel have all of a sudden taken a deep interest in Malaysian affairs such that they would endorse Najib's leadership without any critical look at the clear abuses of power taking place under his watch. There has been no end to their attacks on Anwar although it does not appear to have had much impact. Anwar is still able to secure high level meetings with the administration including as recently as February with officials from the State Department, White House and National Security Council.

Therefore, Najib's statement, which is not really based on fact but on the mythology of Muslim Brotherhood violence, is almost certainly being made to further this effort to differentiate himself from Anwar. To Washington DC, which Najib needs the support of in order to successfully convict and jail Anwar on sodomy charges this year, Najib wants to be the moderate reformer. and Najib/Apco want Anwar to be the radical Islamic fundamentalist.

This comment by Najib will likely backfire in his own party. UMNO is not known for its moderate views and to the extent that UMNO leaders are critical of US policy in the middle East, Najib looks weaker. Mahathir, who is the albatross on Najib's back, will probably criticize Najib as well for taking a position that is seen to be subservient to US views. And the Ikhwan itself will generally lose respect for Najib around the Muslim world which impacts his ability to have any kind of influence or positive reputation.

As for Malaysia being a model example - that will also be hard to prove. Malaysia banned non Muslim use of the word Allah, banned yoga, canes people regularly for adultery and drinking beer, declared Islam superior to other religions, arrests and detains without trial political dissidents, allows hundreds if not thousands of people to be killed while in detention, facilitates human trafficking, etc etc. I dont think there is much to be gained right now from the Malaysian example.

Furthermore, that Najib has ignored and not supported the clear clamor for freedom and justice taking place throughout the Middle East shows how insecure he is about the domestic situation. In Malaysia the demographics are not too different from the Middle East. Large numbers of unemployed voters under the age of 30 who are tech saavy, get their information from blogs and facebook and are well aware of what is happening in the rest of the world.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
HopingFORaCHANGE
   02/25/11 19:49

Malaysian prime minister always talk nonsense. Nonsense talk from nonsense people.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
kal
   02/25/11 21:03

We need the change, change for better, as soon as possible.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
fooart
   02/25/11 21:04

Go and fly kite Najib!!!!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
A Concerned Malaysian
   02/26/11 00:15

Najib is the biggest hypocrite of all. In Malaysia, they use all kind of underhand tactics to restrict freedom of information, media, right to assemble peacefully and practice widespread policy of divide n rule policy to rule over various races in the country. He was also never investigated thoroughly for his alleged involvement in the cold blood murder of Mongolian lady Altantuya who acted as a French interpreter in the useless purchase of Scorpene submarine from French company though his two personal bodyguards were convicted for the murder. In Malaysian parliament, they acknowledged a commission of USD 133 million was paid to a company owned by a close associate of Najib but it was claimed to be for services rendered n not bribe. The prosecutor, the judge, the investigating agencies r all controlled by the executives headed by najib n so none can touch him. This is true Malaysia n yet he want Malaysia to be the model for whole Muslim world. Shame on u Najib

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
akak pink
   02/26/11 02:05

Thank you Najib for showing the world your true colors... So the rest of the Islamic world can easily understands the struggle of the Muslims in Malaysia..

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
badul
   02/26/11 10:40

The truth colour of Malaysian Prime Misstress

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Muhd hisham
   02/26/11 11:19

Im malaysian and very sad have prime minister like him! Im prefer Mahathir...

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
jUSTICE
   02/26/11 14:58

Please think back Najib regarding your disagreement for a group of Muslims who willing sacrifice their life just for the sake to get rid of the corrupted leader like Mubarak.leader who took people taxes for himself,leader who strongly supported America and it's tight allied Israel,leaders who keep his citizen voice shut.

How many years they have to kept silence and patient to be oppressed. What are the other method besides rally so that their voice being heard??.A manipulated election?..

Is that You call terrorism? and American invasion of small country you call Jihad?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Connun Drum
   02/26/11 17:22

Shucks you guys ... PM Najib is innocent. UMNO the blessed party is innocent. All the rest are guilty, ungrateful and baloney!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
al-Barq
   02/26/11 22:08

hmph... out of 15 comments, only one is pro-Najib.... the others are anti... I guess it is clear what most Malaysian feel about their prime minister.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
truthseeker
   02/26/11 22:53

I am a Malaysian. I was at the function attended by the malaysian PM, and the Malaysian PM did not criticise Yusof Qadrawi.
Anwar ibrahim is the greatest liar in the world. he is good in twisting facts.
We in Malaysian know Anwar very well, we have watched him lie through his teeth.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Ishak bin Said
   02/26/11 23:16

Disgusted and ashamed what a hypocrite PM we Malaysian have!!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
achmad abdollah
   02/27/11 00:11

Connun Drum...

You are so naive... you don't know who najib is? a lot of unanswerable issue is circle during his administration... like submarine commision, altantuya killing, bilion withdrawal from Malaysia to oversea (not FDI) and etc. he should resign from PM post a long ago.. Think again connun...

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
zarul zaabah
   02/27/11 03:05

you guys should be ashamed of yourself. you disgraced your own leader for the whole world to read. you all brings nothing but bad image to the country. is this the behavior of muslims? trying to give bad review about someone? if u are malaysia's PM, would u do a better job at running the country? think again la people. its not like najib is the most perfect human being ever in malaysia. there are non. and yet u guys assume like he's perfect. shame on you guys. just keep on insulting among yourself and see malaysia crumbles from the inside. people with mindset like you guys are one of the reason a country may fall. try to look back at how Malacca fell in 1511. its because of betrayal among the citizens of malacca itself. you want your country to fall like melacca did? think again la..

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Load More Comments

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact