On the day Joe Knilans stood to address his Republican colleagues in a closed-door meeting, he was celebrating his sixty-day anniversary as a Wisconsin assemblyman. It was March 10, the day the assembly was set to take its final vote on Gov. Scott Walker’s controversial bill to limit collective bargaining for public employees in Wisconsin.
But as the words fell out of Knilans’ mouth, it was clear he was not up for celebrating.
“I just want to say that taking this vote today will probably cost me my job,” he began. “But that’s why I came to Madison — to take votes like this. I never wanted to be a career politician — it’s about doing the right thing.”
Knilans, 46, is an old union hand who used to assemble cars at the recently mothballed General Motors plant in Janesville. In November, he won a shocking victory over the sitting speaker of the assembly, Mike Sheridan, who had been caught having an affair with a registered lobbyist. It was the first time since 1938 a sitting Wisconsin assembly speaker had lost. After such a historic election, “how can I not vote with the people who voted for me?” Knilans told me.
When Knilans finished speaking, his colleagues gave him a standing ovation. Many that watched him speak remember feeling a jolt of electricity pass through the room. They were numb from the passion Knilans exuded in his speech. Soon, more vulnerable representatives stood and expressed their resolve in voting for the collective-bargaining bill.
Rep. Scott Krug was the next to stand, echoing Knilans’s sentiments about the bill being the right thing for Wisconsin. (In November, Krug beat the longest-serving assemblyman in state history, cantankerous Democrat Marlin Schneider.) Rep. Kathleen Bernier, who had served in local government in Chippewa Falls, cried as she told tales of how the bill had affected her friendships and family relationships.
Sixty-nine-year-old Rep. Ed Brooks talked about how he had been alive for World War II and the Kennedy assassination, and said he would always remember the vote they were going to take that day. One representative stood to explain why he couldn’t vote for the bill, but his opinions were treated respectfully.
At the end of the caucus meeting, they all held hands and prayed.
On election night in November, Assembly Speaker-to-be Jeff Fitzgerald confided to friends that the Republican electoral wave had been so tremendous, he didn’t even know the names of some of the people that would be joining his new majority caucus. Knilans had to be one of the names Fitzgerald never could have imagined would be joining him in Madison. In switching from Democratic to Republican control, the assembly had picked up 25 new GOP members. Forty-four percent of Fitzgerald’s members were now first-termers with no legislative experience. Call them the “Obamacare Babies.”
It was these freshman legislators who stood on the assembly floor following Knilans’ speech that day, while their orange-T-shirt-clad Democratic colleagues shouted “SHAME! SHAME! SHAME!” in their faces. They could feel the ambient rumble of the thousands of pro-union protesters that stood mere feet outside the assembly chamber. Newly elected representative Michelle Litjens had earlier been the target of a threat from a Democratic assemblyman, who pointed at her and said, “You’re f***ing dead.”
Knilans himself felt the intimidation. In his capitol office one day, he heard a group outside his door say, “We know where you live.” Picketers showed up at his house. He said he didn’t personally feel threatened, but he was anxious about the safety of his wife and two small children at home. One day, his five-year-old son asked him, “Do they hate you, Dad?”
Yet they stood together, endured the insults, and passed the bill on to Walker, who signed it the next day.
Voters always say they want politicians who vote without their reelection in mind; they favor elected officials whose conscience is their guide. Yet the GOP assembly freshman class of 2010 has been rewarded for the leadership with verbal abuse, death threats, demonstrations at their homes, and promises they will be yanked out of office via recall. Certainly, some of them know they will not keep their jobs in 2012 as a result of their vote last week.
But on Thursday, March 10, amid attempts to intimidate them, they held hands, closed their eyes, and made the leap together. Some will not survive.
— Christian Schneider is a senior fellow at the Wisconsin Policy Research Institute.
And as a Wisconsinite, I owe them more than they know. My kids, who will now get a better education, thank them.
Some of them will certainly lose, but I bet that number is less than people think it is right now. If the budget is balanced, Wisconsin is growing, and people see that teachers are still just fine, I bet some perceptions will change. Sure, some will still lose, but I really do bet it's less than you think. In two years, we'll have had more Obama misery, and that will almost certainly be the focus on the top of all minds.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI think a lot more will "survive" than you think. Look at what happened to Mitch Daniels in Indiana after they passed government union reform. And don't forget PATCO and the Gipper or Maggie and the coal miners. Buck up. When the world doesn't end and government workers still make a good living with nice benefits, voters will notice.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThose people are heroes.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse“Do they hate you, Dad?”
Yes, but they hate themselves far more.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseKudos. If every politician had this same attitude, we might not be in the fix we're in now. If your well-being is so tied up in being an elected official, then maybe you just don't need to be there. So many of our pol's seem to be tied up with being popular rather than doing the right thing. It's as if most of them are back in high school and afraid if they don't say the right thing, they might not get invited to the prom. This is how you cowboy up. If you do the right thing, it doesn't matter what anyone else thinks of you.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseIf it was such a shock they won last November, some would be goners with or without this vote. I concur, I think on the competitive turf instead of areas of a fluke GOP win, this whole recall effort will pretty much flop.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseAs a former state representative, I admire everyone of these folks for voting for this bill. I understand the pressure they are going thru...I have been there...and it is not pleasant. If even one of these individuals loses their seat over this, it will be a loss for the citizens of Wisconsin. The Democrats and their connections to the Unions have created a mess in states all over this country and after watching these idiots in Wisconsin, it is doubtful we will ever be able to correct it. So many companies have gone down from union demands....so many people have lost their jobs...and they still don't get it. It's all about ME! ME! ME!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseHow many decades has it been since a group of legislators exhibited the kind of courage shown by the Wisconsin republicans?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseCongratulations and GOD Bless the people we voted for to do the job they are doing. Stand your ground and know that you ARE supported for doing the right thing. The UNION demonstrators are certainly teaching our children how to be a bully and stomp your feet and throw a fit if you don't get your way. IS THIS what we want our children to learn in school and in life. Threaten people - shout obsenities and destroy property all in the name of "my freedom of speech." YES, more and more will see that the world will continue spinning in a positive way as budgets are balanced and Wisconsin becomes a thriving economic state to work in and live in. THANK YOU for doing a great job!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseA truly thankless job...but one that is appreciated by all Wisconsinites. Even their enemies will know in a few years how heroic were their deeds.
If only the freshmen in Washington had as much gumption.
Thank you Obamacare Babies and your families! You are truly fighting the good fight!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseIt is nice to know there are politicians that deserve to be honored and make one proud. My sympathy and prayers are with the entire Republican caucus in Wisconsin.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThat man is exactly what the founding fathers wanted. A principalled man doing a job in a FINITE timeframe. Service not a career. He has guts !
Being threatened by teacher's union thugs. Criminal.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseIs it too much to call them heros?
In any case, well done. All of them. I certainly hope that the NRC gets some programs set up to publicize this and accept donations from the wider nation.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseIt is a shame and a wonder to me that a rightfully elected public official has to sacrifice his or her career for having not only done what the constituency asked, but for having done the right thing for his or her state. This is the story that should be on every news report.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseTruly inspirational. In these dark days we citizens of these United States are in desperate need of statesmen instead of politicians. Thank God some still exist. Bless you, Republicans of Wisconsin. Your actions will live in history as one of the first battles won in this (so far) non-violent civil war our country is fighting.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseYou're right, Joe Knilans. Don't whine now! Your voting "lock step" because higher up GOP masters told you to and your betrayal of the State of Wisconsin and it's people WILL cost you your position where you have dishonored - with a complete lack of integrity - from the day you took your oath of office without even being a resident of the district you were to (not) represent. Shame..shame...shame!!!!!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThis is to Proud Wisconsin Resident: the only dishonor is to you and your union thug cronies and the union bully tactics. The real world that requires you to live in realty outside the protection of "Public" union protection. Step out in the real world... shame, shame, shame to you!!!!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseJoe Rey - FYI: Neither I nor any one in my family have been in a union. So I guess you may call me a "grandmother thug" if you'd like. I know if you have an 8-hour work day, a minimum wage, a weekend, your children go to school instead of a factory, etc...you can be grateful to unions. Maybe you can call me a "legislative cronie" for I once worked in the Wisconsin Legislature. I know the rules, protocol, decorum, and behavior of commendable legislators who abide by the State Constitution. Sadly, behavior we have seen in recent weeks from the GOP is devoid of civility and legal behavior. The GOP-WI proposals go FAR beyond union busting. Best advise - READ THE BILLS and then we can talk. Apparently, Walker learned well before he was expelled from Marquette .... External Link
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThroughout the Wisconsin debate, the rhetoric from the left has been so disconcerting and troubling to me. Just a few weeks ago we witnessed a tragic event in Tucson against one of our public officials in addition to the innocent bystanders. Some where quick to point fingers and blame o conservative pundits, even conservative politicians for rhetoric and terms such as "targets" that led to the shootings. And here we are just a short time after this horrible event threatening law makers again. The worst part is we have civil leaders promoting dangerous rhetoric. Since when have death threats ever been an acceptable form of protest? Did we learn nothing from the Tucson Tragedy? Why do the rules so quickly change? I am proud of the Wisconsin Lawmakers. If only our country had more people of integrity and personal conviction leading the way.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseTo Proud Wisconsin Resident. I am proud of the republicans for sticking up for the taxpayers of WI. What the dems did was disgusting and an assault on democracy. How many times did the republicans hold their noses and voted on Doyle bills which lead to the condition we are in today. Remember republicans are representing taxpayers, Union and nonunion. The dems are only supporting the unions.
People of WI time to wake up and stop being held hostage by public sector unions.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse