Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

GOP Reactions to Birth Certificate Release

Mitt Romney:

What President Obama should really be releasing is a jobs plan

Sarah Palin:

Media: admit it, Trump forced the issue. Now, don’t let the WH distract you w/the birth crt from what Bernanke says today. Stay focused, eh?

House speaker John Boehner’s spokesman Kevin Smith:

This has long been a settled issue. The Speaker’s focus is on cutting spending, lowering gas prices, and creating American jobs.

RNC chair Reince Priebus:

As I’ve repeatedly stated, this issue is a distraction. Our economy is strained from out of control deficits, debt, and unsustainable entitlements. The President ought to spend his time getting serious about repairing our economy, working with Republicans and focusing on the long term sustainability of Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security. Unfortunately his campaign politics and talk about birth certificates is distracting him from our number one priority – our economy.

UPDATE: Newt Gingrich to Talking Points Memo:

All I would say is, why did it take so long? The whole thing is strange.

House majority leader Eric Cantor to Fox News:

I have criticized members of my own party for making this some kind of an issue and so I am really surprised that the White House is actually doing the same. … If the White House press secretary says that this is a sideshow, why aren’t we treating it as such and dealing with the bigger issues? … This is an issue that does not belong in the debate. There are much more important issues for us to be dealing with.

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   21

EXPAND  

   04/27/11 10:46

Obama and his media brigade have been using the questions about his birth certificate to paint his political opponents as nutcases. They used this as a distraction from some of the more important issues.

So why would they release it now? The timing is curious to me. Why not hold out until October 2012 to gain the most political advantage? I'm no political strategist, but if I was trying to gain the biggest advantage from this issue (or non-issue, depending on one's point of view), I would hold out so I have a broad brush with which to paint all my opponents.

But it's out there, so I assume Obama and his media brigade will focus on the real issues, like the deficit, jobs, economy, etc.

Or, he could just go to more fundraisers and play more golf. In other words, the more important things on Obama's agenda.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 10:52

This is obviously legit...it is certified by a PhD.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 10:53

My guess as to why Obama released the certificate now is that recent polls were showing that solid majorities of Americans were starting to wonder why he wouldn't release his certificate, and if that meant the questions being asked might be legitimate.

In other words, the other side was no longer considered nut cases by most Americans.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 10:55

HighLife...they released it now to get Trump off the hook...so he could move beyond it and have a robust life as a distraction to the GOP and ultimately as a 3rd pty candidate.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 10:55

We can always expect the politically correct response from the establishment GOP, which is why Palin's response is somewhat different from the other Republicans. Shouldn't the GOP be asking, like many Americans are, why the President of the United States allowed this "distraction" to continue on for more than two years while the country burned?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 11:02

It all makes sense to me now. His mom's name is Stanley.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 11:02

I was thinking...now that we have this lull in burning issues, what if Trump calls in his dogs from Hawaii and they join up with "the Factor's investigative team"...we could have a really awesome pack of conservative sleuths to trap leftie malefactors.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 11:02

Wait. Weren't we told for years that Obama "already released his birth certificate", and "already released everything he has" and "there is no long form birth certificate"?
Heck, in a recent comment on this site a week or three ago, I was told I don't know what I'm talking about when I asked "where's the long form?"
And, will anyone (on MSNBC or CNN or other "progressive" outlets) be called to task for spreading the LIE that Obama "already released his birth certificate"? Short answer: No.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Pennsylvania Yankee
   04/27/11 11:03

A characteristically petty response from the various GOP torchbearers. Their crazy base focuses on this issue, and then when Obama finally lowers himself to discuss it, they claim it was his fault (and even his plan) all along.

Republican politicians currently fall into two classes: lunatics who are genuinely on the side of the crazies (Palin) and those who are so cowed by the Tea Party that they have to say ignorant things they don't believe (Romney). Every candidate who announced that they'd "take the president at his word" about the birth certificate was simply winking at the Tea Party, and owes Obama an apology. But he won't get one, because the GOP currently views any act of class as a sign of weakness.

No one thought the Palins, Bachmanns, and Trumps in the GOP were ever going to show any perspective on this issue. Maybe I was wrong to expect more from Romney. The one joy is that the same ignorance and knee-jerk suspicion of anyone different that feeds the birthers also feeds suspicion of Mormon candidates. Romney will get the primary voters he deserves soon enough.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 11:05

As Donald Trump would say, "I am hearing that Obama is hiding other things."

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 11:07

The proper response from any Republican should be:

"Who cares?"

or:

"So what?"

or:

"Now that this important matter of national concern has been properly addressed and put to rest, I can, finally and thankfully, sleep tonight."

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Kevin Moriarty
   04/27/11 11:25

MarkW: A lie or hysterical theory repeated enough so that it takes on momentum with the public is not per se a legitimate issue. The fact that a large majority were duped by birther promoters indicates a lack of independent thought and a predisposition to believe anything negative about someone they don't like (or hate).

Nothing more to say about the post yesterday on the USA Today poll by Ms. Trinko, where she omitted an inconvenient poll number for the Ryan plan?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 11:36

In defense of birthers....we have a shadowy, anti-American character who spent his young childhood in Indonesia, had a Kenyan, communist father, who is very dodgy and evasive about the details of his life as president of the United States. It seems normal to me that people might demand some assurance that such a person did at least narrowly meet the strictly legal and constitutional requirements for eligibility for his office.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 11:44

Reince Priebus.

So, THAT'S who's running the GOP.

One would never even know that the GOP even had a chairman with all the ducking and covering this non-entity has been doing.

What a loser.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
foont
   04/27/11 13:00

The thing that strikes me about these "issues" is the near identical rhetoric and ripostes that both sides employ. These kinds of nonsense issues - Obama's birth certificate, Bush's National Guard service, Clinton and the death of Vince Foster, etc., etc. - are just that: nonsense. But they stimulate rage, calumny and a thirst for retribution among partisans of both sides that can never be settled because it is the nature of the "issues" that they never CAN be settled.

These "issues" are about 95% elaborately developed conspiracies resting on just enough fact to give them the semblance of a foundation. Their inventors and those who grab hold of them employ perfect logic - and it is quite good logic - in support of their claims. The problem is not in the logic but in the almost entirely nonexistant reality that such logic is generated to support. Of course anyone who dares challenge the foundation of the great controversy is simply dismissed out of hand as an agent of the enemy or as stupid or hopelessly ignorant.

But even worse than the fantasists who invent these "issues" are those who make use of these to traduce and slander anyone and everyone even remotely associated with them as birds of a feather. This is done by people who understand quite well the nature of the "issues" and decide to use them as a vehicle to further the view that ALL their political opponents are evil or sub-human. These people use logic too. These use it to create an attack on their perceived enemies and to widen the net that encompasses the tiny number of true believers to include everyone with whom they have a political disagreement. These people are worse than the true believers who hold to the nonsense "issues" as if they are gospel. These people are far more rational than that but they make use of he irrationality of the few and claim it is the true condition of the many knowing this is not, in fact, true. This is slander and libel used deliberately to inflame the basest passions and instincts. In its worst form this leads to murder. So far, in this country, it is limited to vile rhetoric and heated arguments.

These nonsense "issues" should be ignored by all rational men and women of good will and honest intent. They shouldn't be addressed at all except to perfunctorily be dismissed as the twaddle they are and then move on to matters of far greater importance. Given the general level of poltical discourse now extant and the general level of morality that prevails among so many I do not expect this to happen.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
SteveW
   04/27/11 13:20

I'm not suprised given the Gallup poll that only 38% thought Obama was 'definitely' born in the USA. That is an amazing statistic, and shows the damage Trump had done to Obama.

Sorry - 62% of the people are not right-wing nutcases.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 13:36

I agree with bwarsch. He reveals the long-withheld "long form" when for two years they've been telling us there is nothing to reveal.

Could they not appear more shallow, deceptive and deceitful?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 13:40

bwarsch states: Wait. "Weren't we told for years that Obama 'already released his birth certificate'"

Yes. And He did. BOTH Are COLB. One remains at the Dept. of Vital Stats. All others are used for official purposes. Duh. We get it Why don't birthers understand that simple principle.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 14:35

MsStevie, you need to read Andrew McCarthy's well-researched article, "Suborned in the USA" which exlains the long form/short form facts and what was intentionally withheld.
Here: External Link 

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   04/27/11 14:36

Ms Stevie - The "certificate" previously released was the computer print out of data taken off the original hard copy and stored in the state's computer system (when they converted to paperless storage). In the old days, you received a photocopy of the original hard copy of the certificate. Today, the authorities simple print out the data and certify the authenticity of the information. Again, you no longer routinely get, and Obama never previously released, a xerox of the original signed hard copy (or print out of the pdf, as the case may be). In fact, we were variously told that the original of the hard copy produced today was destroyed and / or lost after the data contained therein was input into the state's new paperless computer records system. (Remember?)
You can "Duh" all you want, and mock my inability to "understand" a "simple principle" (dang, Obama defenders are just so much better and smarter than the rest of us!), but the paper released today was never before released, although we were told for going on 3 years that it had been. Frankly, if I were a loyal Obama fan repeating the "he already released everything he has" line for the past 3 years, I'd feel pretty abused, used and misled. But, then again, I'm just too simple for yer high falutin' higher level critical thinkin'. I'm so dumb, I debate and disagree with people without insulting them.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Load More Comments

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact