Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

The Persecution of Egypt’s Coptic Christians Continues

The Arab Spring has not been kind to Egypt’s Christian minority. Over the weekend, Muslims apparently incited by Islamist hardliners again terrorized Coptic Christians, in what is now a pattern of attacks against them and their churches. Possibly the Islamists are jockeying for political power in this transitional period, or even trying to immediately effect a religious cleansing similar to the one that has happened in Iraq.

Copts, numbering about 10 million, constitute the largest Christian group and the largest religious minority in the Middle East. Their size will likely prevent an escalating persecution of them from going unnoticed for long in the West.

Coptic Christians in the Imbaba district of Cairo report that on Saturday night they were assaulted by Muslims who looted and burned St. Mina’s Church and the Church of the Virgin Mary and attempted to burn St. Mary and St. Abanob Church. The press has reported that, according to the Copts, twelve people were killed. According to the Egyptian interior ministry, which habitually downplays or ignores attacks against Christians, possibly six victims were Christian and six were Muslim. More than a hundred people were injured, as Copts fought back with sticks and stones.

The latest attacks follow others earlier this year. In March, a Coptic church was torched in Soul, and on New Year’s Day a church in Alexandria was targeted with explosives.

On Sunday and Monday, the Copts held large protests in Tahrir Square and outside the main Egyptian television station, demanding an investigation. Typically, these kinds of incidents result in a “reconciliation” session held by the state or its courts, in which the Christians are pressed to forgive their Muslim attackers, who then go free. The Assyrian International News Agency reported that “the Bishop of Giza, Anba Theodosius, said ‘These things are planned. We have no law or security, we are in a jungle. We are in a state of chaos. One rumor burns the whole area. Everyday we have a catastrophe.’ Addressing the Salafis he said ‘We will never leave our country.’”

The Copts believe that fundamentalist Salafi (also known as Wahhabi) Muslims were behind the attacks, which were apparently triggered by rumors that a Copt had abducted a woman who had allegedly converted to Islam. These rumors were in turn triggered by the airing of a broadcast from another woman, Camilia Shehata, the wife of a Coptic priest, who had also been rumored to have converted to Islam and then been abducted by Copts. In the broadcast, Shehata said that she remained a Christian and had never converted to Islam.

In this week’s issue of The Weekly Standard, my colleague Paul Marshall describes recent Salafi violence against Copts in Egypt, noting that the size, influence, goals, and activities of this extremist faction have drawn scant media attention. Like the Muslim Brotherhood, the Salafis want to see Egypt ruled under Islamic law, and some are using violence to bring that about. According to the English-language Egyptian newspaper Al Masry Al Youm, 50,000 Salafis and Muslim Brotherhood supporters held a joint rally in Giza over the weekend at which protesters chanted slogans of unity and support for Islamic law. At the rally, prominent Salafi preacher Safwat Hegazy proclaimed, “The United Arab States and the United Islamic States are inevitably coming. . . . And soon we will have one caliph to rule us all.” Violence against the Copts was denounced by some rally speakers. The recent attacks were also condemned by the Saudi monarchy, the sheikh of al-Azhar University, and the Muslim Brotherhood on its English-language site. Egypt’s government officials vowed quick justice for the perpetrators, though trials for massacres of Copts over the past ten years continue to languish or have ended inconclusively.

It has been observed that the American mainstream media does not get religion. Regarding the weekend atrocities in Egypt, the most egregious blindspot was probably displayed by the New York Times, which uncritically reported the Egyptian interior ministry’s press releases, appearing to blame equally the victimized Coptic minority and their attackers. Quoting unnamed people on the street, it advanced the economic-determinist theory that unemployment rather than ideology was the trigger: Times correspondent David D. Kirkpatrick wrote that “people on both sides said the fighting pitted one group of frustrated and underemployed young men from the neighborhood against another, along battle lines that had more to do with tribal allegiances than any religious or political ideas.”

Largely because of mounting violence against the Copts, and against other, smaller minorities, the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom recommended on April 28 that the State Department list Egypt as a “country of particular concern” under the International Religious Freedom Act and adopt foreign policies to defend religious freedom there. 

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   11

EXPAND  

   05/10/11 09:13

FTA: "Copts, numbering about 10 million... Their size will likely prevent an escalating persecution of them from going unnoticed for long in the West."

I see. So the author is attempting to set a boundary on the western instinct to appease Islam. I am not as confident as the author.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
sombreros divertidos
   05/10/11 10:29

And the earth continues to orbit the sun.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/10/11 10:58

I wonder which Islamic strongman is going to be the caliph. Surely they would all want the job and fight to get it. I can't imagine Qadaffi stepping aside for Ahmadinajad, and surely the Saudis have a candidate they like. Since the Middle East is so tribal, perhaps the tribal conflicts they are prone to will inhibit the actual selection of a caliph (or the proliferation of people claiming they are the caliph?).

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/10/11 11:27

"And soon we will have one caliph to rule us all.”

...and in the darkness bind them.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/10/11 11:29

This past weekend I saw CNN's Fredrika Whitfield be extremely dismissive about the attacks on Christians in Egypt when she was reporting the church that was burned down and the killing of 12 people. She acted like, 'Those darn religious people fighting amongst themselves again.'

As Nina Shea has accurately pointed out, THAT is NOT the story of what is happening in Egypt against Christians.

The U.S. News Media fails the public again - and I wonder why it is that Christian lives are so cheap in the eyes of U.S. news people.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/10/11 11:58

NRO should do a cover story on this situation. If you don't speak up for this persecuted minority, who will? Obama?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   05/10/11 12:41

Christians are also being murdered en masse elsewhere and it barely makes a ripple in the MSM.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Moki
   05/10/11 18:34

It is not only in Egypt that the MSM misreports on the overwhelmingly Muslim violence against Christians, who once in a while try to defend themselves, as being tribal dispute, or even some form of class and economic warfare, in which both sides are equally guilty. That kind of misrepresentation in news reporting also comes out of Nigeria.

I think it is caused by an extension of Leftist thinking and propaganda, and the "blame the West," "blame the U.S." thinking that permeates the media and academia in the West.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Alejandro LB
   05/23/11 06:43

Not only in Egypt. Christian minorities have a bad day everywhere. Even in Israel and the occupied territories, the land where Jesus was born, they have to face the restrictions imposed by the Israeli occupation and the increasing persecution by radical Islamists.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
bob samuel
   05/23/11 17:43

to Mrs Donna, because christianty in the states isn't protected, as long as this president in the WH. only when american people wake up and vote for the right president which is somthing i am not optimistic about it, american people don't know how to choose well

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Don Turnblade
   12/13/11 11:11

With the economic interests of the west flowing through the Middle East, Europe in cultural shock concerning Muslims, attacks by Muslims on supposedly Christian countries in violation of the armistice of the Crusades, I am finding it harder to see a difference between the foundations of the historical Crusades and the logic now brewing.

Thus, I stand to speak out against what I can only call "The Crusades Book 2, the nuclear tipped edition." Folks, we have to care about distressed Christians. We have to play a role in the Middle East, but to anyone who has read the charter of the UN and the Crusade Armistice documents, my concern is not far fetched and the international law is not unreasonable. We can be in for a first class mess if secular business interests such the Church into another mess.

That sad, murdering one's neighbor is not a sign of righteousness for Islam and not a sign of righteousness for Christianity. As it stands, Christianity already has the legal right to enter a Muslim land and blow up a building with 3000 people in it for no other reasons that because it is an Islamic land, just as the armistice of the Crusades swears we have a right to do. The Muslim world actually is very intent on watching the Pope's words, because it is hard for them not to imagine that the Pope does not truly think they way their leaders do.
They read their history. But, have we. If we do not read it, then how shall we avoid repeating it?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact