It would be pointless to rank television’s top fathers by parenting style, since we all know what good fathers look like (Mike Brady) and what bad fathers look like (Homer Simpson) in the television universe. Instead, in honor of Father’s Day, let’s look at ten iconic TV dads chronologically. (You can see the slide-show version on the homepage.) It’s instructive because we can see the transformation of fatherhood on television reflecting the left-wing bias against traditional family roles. Here we go:
Ward Cleaver (Leave It To Beaver, 1957-1963)
The archetypal TV dad, Ward finished nearly episode by giving good, solid moral advice to his sons. He also had a great marriage with prototypical 1950s mom June.
Mike Brady (The Brady Bunch, 1969-1974)
We’re already moving into the era of alternative family structures, though the Brady clan was obviously in coincidence with traditional moral values. Mike is still the moral authority in the household, though he’s a very soft authority figure.
Archie Bunker (All in the Family, 1971-1979)
Archie is a good dad but a horrible person. Here’s where television begins to change from the respectful view of fathers to the flower-power view of fathers as racist, bigoted, old men you can mooch off of for years on end.
Steven Keaton (Family Ties, 1982-1989)
Steven is in one way a reversal, in another way, a step forward for liberals. Where liberals were militantly anti-father with regard to conservative dads, they’re all of a sudden in favor of traditional father roles when dad uses his authority to promote hippy liberalism. Steven always gets the last word, even if we love Alex.
Cliff Huxtable (The Cosby Show, 1984-1992)
The last gasp of the conservative father on television came not from a retrenchment of conservatism but from liberals who wanted to assure blacks that not every television show about blacks had to take place in a junkyard or the streets. The result was one of the great conservative characters of all time: a traditional father who is successful in his career and authoritative at home.
Al Bundy (Married … With Children, 1987-1997)
A horrible father, a vulgar personality, and a cynical jackass. The Left’s newfangled view of traditional fatherhood takes Archie Bunker a step further, now stating that middle-American conservative dads aren’t good dads or good people.
Homer Simpson (The Simpsons, 1989-current)
The cartoon Al Bundy is even worse than Al — he openly abuses his children (strangling Bart), he gets drunk at the local bar every night, and he is stupid, slothful, and bigoted. A far cry from Ward Cleaver. Peter Griffin (Family Guy) is Homer Simpson with hair and glasses.
Ross Gellar (Friends, 1994-2004)
What is Ross doing on this list? He’s here because he represents the left’s next step: the absentee father who simply doesn’t matter to his son’s life. Ross impregnates his lesbian wife, has a kid, and then takes care of the kid once every blue moon between his affairs and antics. His son, Ben, never feels any ill effects. Welcome to the liberal paradise, where dads are completely superfluous.
Tony Soprano (The Sopranos, 1999-2007)
Tony is a lot like Archie, except violent and sexually promiscuous. He’s a terrible person, but he’s loyal to his family. Tony actually represents a soft retreat for the left — at least they’re now engaging the notion that fathers are necessary.
Cameron Tucker and Mitchell Pritchett (Modern Family, 2009-present)
They’re virtually ideal dads, except that they make silly mistakes like locking a baby in a car. But they can be ideal dads because they’re gay, which means that as the series progresses, look for them to become even more sainted. The Left has finally come to terms with fatherhood — anyone at all can be a dad, and there’s no need for mom.
Don't forget Ben Cartright!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWhy would we "love" Alex Keaton? He was a caricature of conservatives -- openly, vociferously sexist and obsessed with money, as well as squarish, prudish, and a know-it-all whom you'd despise in real life.
(Though "Leland College" appeared to be an analogue of my undergrad -- but I'm sure grads of plenty of the many small liberal arts schools in Ohio would think so, too.)
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI should add, though, that Alex was never racist.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseYou missed Hank Hill from "King of the Hill". Probably one of the best TV fathers (other than Bill Cosby) of all time.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseYou're evaluating these shows like they were produced by a world wide conspiracy to promote values you disagree with. They existed to entertain and make money and were produced by individual people, not a political collective.
I'm pretty sure Ross was an "absentee father" because the show was about six single adults and that premise was working very well. Turning it into a completely different show with a toddler character in every episode would have lost millions of viewers and dollars. Ross's son was a storyline, not a neglected kid.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse"You're evaluating these shows like they were produced by a world wide conspiracy to promote values you disagree with."
Gosh, you'd think he hadn't written a book on that very topic, in which many TV producers go on record as saying that they do exactly that.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseFox (the Simpsons, Married with Children) is in business to make money. So are the other networks. Finding that most TV writers and producers are liberals is not the same thing as a conspiracy; where are you claiming the producers of these shows take orders from?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseSounds like you need to read the book. I get it from the mouths of the producers themselves.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseBusted! I have not read every book.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseAndy Griffith!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseAnother vote for Hank Hill of "King of the Hill". Probably the best depiction of a husband and father in modern television history. I tell you what!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI wondered if someone would mention Hank Hill. His qualities as a father are magnified because he is an eagle surrounded by turkeys. He is the only responsible, mature person in the lives of almost everyone around him, including his boss and his own father.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse"The Left’s newfangled view of traditional fatherhood" was on Rupert Murdoch's new network.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseSo?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThe author is claiming Married with Children is the product of "the Left." I don't know the politics of everyone involved in the show but I know it was on a network owned by Rupert Murdoch, not the Democratic party.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI say again . . . so? You seem to think that simply invoking "Rupert Murdoch" means something here.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseIf there is a conspiracy to promote leftist values via sitcoms, I don't think Rupert Murdoch is a part of it.
The two Fox shows here are the first 2 hit Fox shows. We know them because they were on so long. Their purpose was (and is) to make money, not to promote leftist values. All of the shows on the list are famous because they were very popular and long running - people liked them. It's not a conspiracy.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse*You're* the only saying Rupert Murdoch has anything to do with anything here.
(Your problem is that you assume the conclusion within your premise, as has been tried to point out to you.)
But dude . . . read the book.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseYes, and in order for the creative talent -- writers and producers -- to be social liberals and even radicals, a network would have to be owned by the Democratic party; Murdoch's ownership is proof enough against the theory, because we all know (somehow) that he's so splendidly partisan that he wouldn't ever allow other voices on his networks.
What hogwash.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseIt's because the left is so committed to their own bulls -- "hogwash" -- about Murdoch and the loathed "Faux News" that they assume it's incandescent, self-evident truth, and that simply saying "Rupert Murdoch!" is an argument-ender.
One need only look at the history of the Fox Network to see what, er "hogwash" it is, with all those notoriously right-wing shows like Family Guy, American Dad, the Simpsons, Married . . . With Children, That '70s Show (hey, where's Red Forman on this list???), That '80s Show (where every joke was a Reagan joke), and on and on . . .
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse