Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

White House Messaging Undergoes Structural Change

Bye-bye, hope and change. Hello, denial and defeatism.

Today’s jobs numbers have taken the wind out of the administration’s blustering economic sails. As high school and college grads poured into the job market in June, employers managed to add only 18,000 jobs — the lowest number in nine months. Unemployment rose to 9.2 percent, and the underemployment rate soared to 16.2 percent — the highest since December.

In a fleeting Rose Garden appearance today, the president urged patience and advocated a less-than-inspirational economic agenda of Patent Office reform, a new bureaucracy (an “infrastructure bank), and extension of December’s payroll tax cut. (Why not? Look how well the temporary cut has sparked the economy so far!) He then retreated swiftly to the White House, refusing to take a single question.

The evidence that Obamanomics has failed — long-term unemployment is higher now than at any time in more than 60 years — is overwhelming. Even the White House senses its “stimulus” mantra won’t wash any more. After publicly chuckling that the much-vaunted “shovel-ready jobs weren’t so shovel ready,” [ha-ha!] the president can’t very well maintain that prosperity is just around the corner if only we keep spending ourselves deeper into debt.

Thus, we see two new messages emerging. First, the 1970s-esque acknowledgement that, yes, the economy stinks, but there’s nothing the president or anyone else can do about it. Why? Because there has been a “structural change” in the economy. The moral of this argument: “Get used to 10 percent unemployment, 15 percent underemployment, and bid a fond adieu to the American dream.”

It’s a message of resignation. Yes, it says, we’re doomed for economic decline no matter what, but trust us to manage it more gracefully than anyone else.

But Americans will likely stand athwart such defeatism and say “Stop!” There is no need, they will say, to tolerate European levels of unemployment. It’s an increasingly easy sell: Jettison the President’s European-style economic policies, and you jettison European-style unemployment.

The second new message emanating from the White House is strictly political. Unemployment numbers are no big whoop, says senior presidential advisor David Plouffe, because the president can win reelection even if the economy is in the tank. While doubtless reassuring to the 454 White House aides earning more than $37 million this year, that news provides little comfort to the 14.1 million Americans currently looking for a job.

Plouffe, Obama’s 2008 campaign manager, sprang this message yesterday at a Bloomberg breakfast:

The average American does not view the economy through the prism of GDP or unemployment rates or even monthly jobs numbers. People won’t vote based on the unemployment rate, they’re going to vote based on: “How do I feel about my own situation? Do I believe the president makes decisions based on me and my family?”

One is tempted to ask Mr. Plouffe: “Just what part of ‘It’s the economy, stupid’ don’t you understand?” But perhaps history is wrong and Mr. Plouffe is right in saying that feelings outweigh employment in matters electoral. Yet, even if that is the case, Plouffe shouldn’t count his electoral chickens just yet. The fact is, most Americans don’t feel that great about their situation. A recent McClatchy-Marist Poll found that 77 percent of registered voters (and 72 percent of Democrats) “think the U.S. economy is currently in a recession.”Last month, a Bloomberg National Poll found that Americans feel — by a 44 percent to 34 percent margin — that they are worse off than when Obama took office. Even more ominously, 55 percent feel their children are now destined to have a lower standard of living than they do.

White House messaging has definitely undergone major “structural change” since 2008. “Hope and change” has given way to “Hey, this job’s tough. Lower your expectations, America.”

— Michael Franc is vice president of government studies at the Heritage Foundation.

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   12

EXPAND  

   07/08/11 18:07

You forgot #3, blame Bush. Although that's not a new message but rather a golden oldie.

And Plouffe and the other parade of lying horribles that surround the head clown? They are spinning madly in the hope that something sticks in the average person's mind that takes the onus off Obama. Although Debbie Wasserman Shultz, aka Mrs Roboto, has said that the dems take responsibility for the economy. Run that in an ad.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
D.C. al Fine
   07/08/11 18:20

Note how socialist Plouffe, speaking for socialist Obama, expects people to buy a line about caring for ask our celr citizens when the topic is raising taxes vs. cutting spending, but to ignore the unemployed if we are not unemployed and to think only of ourselves when it comes time to te-elect Obama.

The emperor has no clothes.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/08/11 18:29

Notice how socialist Plouffe, speaking for socialist Obama, want each of us to think about the fate of our neighbors when it comes to convincing us to prefer higher taxes over lower spending. But when it comes to deciding our vote to re-elect Obama and his party or not amidst his failed economic policies, suddenly scoundrel Plouffe emerges urging us to think only of ourselves.

The emperor has no clothes.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Obsolete Dudes
   07/08/11 18:43

So, obsolete dudes, what is your prescription? Tax breaks for those who already have money? More H1-B visa immigration for those companies whose top brass are already among the richest in the world? More immigrants for farmers who inherited their stolen lands? Concealed carry laws? Guns in every home? More death penalties? More foreign intervention? WHAT? WHAT? WHAT?

Has it ever occurred to you that the reason voters elect ridiculous leftists is because you are even more ridiculous?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/09/11 11:11

I am trying and failing not to enjoy these signs of liberal angst as it dawns on them their great champion has miserably failed and has lied to them throughout the process.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 JEM
   07/09/11 16:30

You are funny and desperate. Businesses aren't hiring because they do not trust your chosen One, who is a fraud and easily the single most incompetent president ever in the history of this country. This is what Europe looks like, 10% structural unemployment, less and more expensive goods for sale, and the political elite forever looking for more ways to separate themselves from having to experience any of it, with taxpayer padded expense accounts and resort located "summits" where they do nothing but eat and drink and make pronouncements that mean nothing except give me more money.

It is time to stop this.

Obsolete, if that's all you got, I am very hopeful for our future, because only about 20% of population doesn't think that is just utter silliness. I refuse to believe you are that dense except that you are clinging to your religion while being forced to realize it is a fraud.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/08/11 18:54

(How does CAPTCHA know how to do this? "technicolor yawn")

Ah, the Carter "malaise" speech . . . "my fellow Americans, you make me sick." Eerie all the parallels.

There are those of us who remember the defeatism of the late '70s, and fortunately we do have in living memory an example of how it can be turned around.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Annie G.
   07/08/11 19:22

OK, so we don't think about the GDP or the unemployment numbers, but we sure notice the price of gas, and the fact that there are houses sitting vacant in our neighborhood, and the value of our own house is down, and we have friends out of work, and our teenage kids couldn't find a summer job....I could go on but that should suffice to make my point.

How out of it must David Plouffe be not to realize that we notice every single day, in ways large and small, that the economy of this country is stagnating?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/08/11 20:55

Captain Despair.

A sane country wouldn't re-elect him, but a sane country would have found Casey Anthony guilty, too.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
sixrings09
   07/08/11 20:57

Sorry, could not help but read Mr Plouffe as Pouffle which sounds about as sturdy as Obama's policies.

WFB is rolling in his grave as I mangle the English Language. I apologize in advance.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/09/11 13:48

If Obamanomics has failed, did Bushonomics succeed?
Just asking, so don't bite my head off.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Richard L.A. Schaefer
   07/09/11 22:58

Before the stimulus package had been finalized, Robert Rubin rejected "shovel ready" projects on the Lehnrer News Hour. His reason: they turn out never to be shovel ready.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact