Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

Perry on Romney’s Tail

Mitt Romney remains the frontrunner in two new polls, but Rick Perry is a close second in both polls.

Results from the Fox News poll of GOP primary voters: Romney (17 percent), Perry (14 percent), Michele Bachmann (10 percent), Rudy Giuliani (9 percent), Sarah Palin (9 percent), Ron Paul (9 percent), Herman Cain (5 percent), Newt Gingrich (4 percent), Tim Pawlenty (2 percent), and Rick Santorum (2 percent).

Romney has lost six percentage points since an early June Fox poll, while Bachmann has gained six points. Perry did not appear on the early June poll.

If options are limited to declared candidates (which excludes Perry and Palin), the top three are Romney (26 percent), Bachmann (15 percent), and Paul (10 percent).

Results from the CNN/ORC International poll of Republicans and Republican leaning independents: Romney (16 percent), Perry (14 percent), Palin (13 percent), Giuliani (13 percent), Bachmann (12 percent), Paul (8 percent), Cain (6 percent), Gingrich (4 percent), Pawlenty (3 percent), Santorum (2 percent), and Jon Huntsman (1 percent).

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   41

EXPAND  

   07/22/11 08:40

Having watched how mistaken Fox polls have been over the years - who does their polling again? It is hard to take them seriously. They bizarrely had Huckabee leading in polls just a little while ago, when the rest of the poll centers revealed Romney was heavily favored.

It is more amusingn, especially when the other more reliable mains, like the WSJ report Romney up at 30% Nationally. (Rasmussen had Romney at 33%). Even the questionable Fox offering did not really put Romney's numbers in the RCP average down much - which is quite telling.

External Link 

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 09:17

Even more questionable are Fox poll results on Palin. Both newest CNN and Wapo polls have palin at 13 and 16 respectively and Fox has her at 9?

Interesting. If skewing polls is designed to keep her in Fox stable of talking heads, is suppressing her popularity the right way to go?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 09:41

I think Fox News recently changed their pollster. Seem to remember that I read something about that

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
la stu
   07/22/11 14:12

They sure did. Their new D-side pollster spun off her firm from their old pollster, Opinion Dynamics.

Her firm is teamed with the Bush family's personal pollster from UT-Austin to represent the R side.

Their methodology is bogus, however. They make headlines here with a sample of just over 300 respondents for the GOP primary preferences. They also only plug you in to their poll at question #24, with no idea what came beforehand.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 09:05

The better known Perry becomes, the higher his poll numbers will go. The better known Romney's positions are known, the lower his numbers will go.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 10:20

Republican votes know Romney and he has been a consistent frontrunner. Unless Rick Perry gets in and starts knocking people's socks off the nomination is Romney's to lose.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 10:35

If you read the Fox internals, Giuliani's inclusion in the polling hurts Romney's performance heavily. Most of Rudy's supporters list Mitt as their #2 choice.

Palin's support would go to Romney, Paul, and Perry.

Perry's would go to Bachmann and Romney.

Romney is still unquestionably thr leader, especially in a Rudy-free world. But the long-term trend is toward Perry. Bad for Romney is that Perry takes votes directly from him, he's not just taking votes from Bachmann and Palin and scooping up undecideds. Unlike other candidates such as Cain and Bachmann who rose without directly hurting Romney, every point Perry gains also takes a measurable share of a point away from Mitt.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 10:57

Only thing is, Perry was the only governor to have endorsed Giuliani in 2008 (which gives rise to one of my misgivings about Perry, actually). Also, Giuliani's law firm was the product of a deal with an old Texas firm looking to expand into New York and beyond. Giuliani and Perry seem as if they might be buddies. So Giuliani could actually endorse Perry, when Giuliani inevitably drops out (or decides not to run).

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 10:43

Governor Perry look like Governor Rommey's older, wiser, tougher, maybe meaner, big brother.
It might be "Dutch Rub" time.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 10:57

Handicapping political races is remarkably like handicapping horse races. The best horse racing handicappers in the world are seldom pick 3 out of 5 races correctly. I'm guessing political handicappers in during primary season aren't much better, but here it goes...

While it's impossible to predict with any certainty how any individual political campaign will go, I find it difficult to imagine a scenario where Perry doesn't eventually sew this thing up. But, that comes with the presumption that he won't fall all over himself between now and the first primary, which I suppose is possible.

However, Perry is a three-term governor of a gigantic state, so he must be a competent campaigner, right? Romney, who is Perry's only real competition, is - IMHO - too flawed and saddled with too much baggage to capture the nomination outright. It's impossible for him - perhaps even without Perry in the race - to gain the requisite number of delegates, especially when you consider the challenges Romney faces in our Southern states. Perry, OTOH, is likely to do reasonably well almost everywhere - save for perhaps the extreme Northeast.

Nope, the horses aren't even in the gate yet. But in the post parade, Perry looks fit & eager, Romney looks tired & wet and the rest of entrants look like this is the next stop before the glue factory. I would be surprised if Perry doesn't win, going away.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 11:06

I agree with all you say, Scott Wilson, unless there is a new surprise entry to the field or unless Perry does something to blow it. The only way Romney gets the nomination is by attrition, i.e., McCain's method (which will be just as ineffectual in the end, so let's hope *that* doesn't happen).

I would only add that, in my view, Bachmann remains a dark horse. Even if she hangs in there, though, I see her as Perry's VP choice.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
hmasteryclinder
   07/22/11 21:41

Me too. And it would be a very smart move. Never underestimate the "Sisterhood", especially with conservative women, who have been denied for too long. Most of the gains that conservatives have made since slick Willy are probably due to women wising up to the democrat sleaze.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
glenn Korbel
   07/22/11 11:47

Anybody remember these blurbs from polls taken in late June of 2007:

"Senator Fred Thompson, preparing to formally announce his candidacy, leads the pack in the latest Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey with 27% support. That gives him a four-point advantage over former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani who is currently preferred by 23% of Likely Primary Voters. A week ago, it was Thompson 28% and Giuliani 27%. Two weeks ago, they were tied at 24%. Prior to that time, Giuliani had been on top in every weekly Rasmussen Reports poll for five months

Thompson leads Giuliani by 13 percentage points among conservative primary voters while Giuliani leads among moderates."

(That was CNN. USA Today, Newsweek, and CNN had Guiliani up by 9%-11% 17 months out. McCain didn't even have a pulse.)

And from Politico:

"A Los Angeles Times/Bloomberg national poll released this week showed Giuliani with 27 percent of the GOP vote, Thompson with 21, McCain 12 and Romney 10. A Quinnipiac poll at the same time found Giuliani at 27, Thompson and McCain at 15, and Romney at 10. An NBC/Wall Street Journal poll has Giuliani at 29 and Thompson at 20, with Romney and McCain at 14."

Finally this from A University of Iowa study aboput McCain's problems:

"Former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney appears to have taken a commanding lead in Iowa among registered Republican voters and Republican caucus goers, according to a new University of Iowa poll released today, Wednesday, Aug. 8. Poll results also indicate that former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani has lost support, and support for Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., has collapsed well into the third tier of candidates.

Republicans appear to be punishing both Giuliani and McCain for their unwillingness to compete in the Aug. 11 Straw Poll, while Romney's campaign has hit its stride... ."

The more things change; the more they stay the same: In 2007 Romney looked like he had all the "mo" going into Iowa and Fred Thompson was the rising star.

This year Romney is stil top dog but now Bachman and Rick Perry are the
wise guy's good thing.

How can anybody seriously consider a psudoscience like polling which if it has any predictive validity only does so a week or two before an election--and even then they blowup with embarrassing regularity?

urvey, with support from 27% of the Republicans and independents who said they planned to vote in the party's 2008 primaries.

But Thompson, an actor who plays a prosecutor on NBC's "Law and Order," polled 21%. Indications are he will join the race within the next month.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 12:28

"How can anybody seriously consider a psudoscience like polling..."

First, it's not pseudoscience, it's quite correctly called political science. Opinion polling employs well-tested and well-proven methods of statistical modeling. Is it perfect? Absolutely not, which is why every legitimate poll cites a "margin of error". There are PLENTY of other plainly scientific methods that also have margins of error.

Polling does not attempt to predict the future, although perhaps some people incorrectly try to apply polling that way. Polling does however, (reasonably) accurately measure the current political climate; In other words, "what is the public thinking right now". This tells the candidates, and the public, whose message is winning, today.

With respect to the polls that you have cited from 2008, you're citing those polls as if they happened in a vacuum or static environment. They didn't. They happened in a dynamic political environment. In that kind of an environment, things change - candidates make mistake, their records are scrutinized and/or they just fail to connect with voters. That doesn't mean that the polls were inaccurate or without merit.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Jay B. Born
   07/22/11 11:55

Don't know much about Perry. The few times I've heard him speak, I wasn't duly impressed. He seems too conservative to carry the big diverse voting crowd that will come out in Nov. 2012. Not like last Nov. when mostly older, conservatives turned out. That's why we're seeing so much of Boehner and McConnell now.I'm independent leaning conservative but see no GOP candidate to get excited about.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Jay B. Born
   07/22/11 11:56

Don't know much about Perry. The few times I've heard him speak, I wasn't duly impressed. He seems too conservative to carry the big diverse voting crowd that will come out in Nov. 2012. Not like last Nov. when mostly older, conservatives turned out. That's why we're seeing so much of Boehner and McConnell now.I'm independent leaning conservative but see no GOP candidate to get excited about.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 11:57

Assuming Perry gets in:

Race between Romney and Perry, as Bachman loses supporters to Perry. If Perry bombs and gets out early, Bachman picks up the majority of Perry's former supporters with Pawlenty hanging on and hoping that one of the two top contenders implodes. Pawlenty's best chance is for Romney to do poorly in Iowa, not win NH and lose in SC., while Perry bombs and gets out early and Bachman implodes under pressure (and the MSM/DNC will do anything to derail Bachman). If that scenario holds, Pawlenty becomes the 'conservative' candidate in comparison to Romney. Thus, T-Paw is looking at long odds right now. However, 'right now' can look a lot different in a few months.

Best chance to beat Obama? Probably Romney, unfortunately. However, if Perry can somehow avoid being seen as Bush II by independents, he will have a very good chance of beating Obama. In fact, Perry should even pick up some disaffected liberals (as in 'unemployed' liberals) who appreciate his libertarian/10th amendment views regarding choices being made by citizens rather than politicians (and in this case, decisions not being made by conservative politicians at the national level).

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 12:34

You know, NRO has truly "arrived." An entire thread 90% of which is Dem trolls arguing with themselves over their party line on Perry. That tells you also that Perry scares the cranberries out of them.

Basic facts: Anyone who even slightly takes Pawlenty, Huntsman, or any of the truly second-tier candidates seriously at this stage is muddying the water or out of touch. Anyone who believes that the 3-times-elected Governor of the ONE state of 50 (not 57, Mr. President) that is growing jobs and the economy, even with no income taxes and a legislature that meets only every other year, even after absorbing a flood of Katrina victims from Louisiana and a flood of Federally-ignored illegals, drugs, and criminals from Mexico, and even with the same challenges that all the other states are enduring under the Obama kleptocracy...will have his political fate decided by an endorsement of Giuliani once upon a time is...well, naive is a nice way of putting it. And ANYone who believes that the massive wave of conservative and conservative-leaning-independent voters who swept the House into office last time will suddenly vaporize in a flood of "youth" and "minority" and other classic Dem fracture-coalition voters this time is...well, just plain wrong.

This will be an exciting, interesting primary season full of the usual ups, downs, and sidewayses, and polls will run the gamut, too. But at the end of the day when the Convention is over and the Obamanauts and their proxies have shot all their defamatory wads on every candidate--from headaches to halitosis and depleting their cash and credibility in the process--a serious, professional, economic conservative with solid roots in the electorate and powerful credentials to fix the only-gonna-get-worse Obama economy will emerge and be rallied around by everyone but a few Paul fringies and all seven people who think The Donald's hair looks good.

It is easy to see, hard to foresee, but from this moment in time, it is very, very likely that person will be Rick Perry. It is also clear that he can and will handily dismiss the inept, petulant, incompetent child currently giving Jimmy Carter a good name in the White House.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   07/22/11 12:39

P.S. Romney is a good man, a decent man, a great fundraiser, and also yesterday's horse. I believe he will, at some point, do the very right thing and admit that to himself and his supporters who will all realize that the GOP's days of picking "the next guy in line" have to be over if the party is to continue without being replaced by something else.

If we insist that Republicans in Congress not cave and compromise about the debt, how can we suggest that Republicans in the electorate cave and compromise on Romney? This is not the time for compromise on candidates or policy. With any luck and a bit of spine, it never, ever will be again.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
No4More
   07/24/11 18:18
Load More Comments

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact