Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

March 5 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

Former Tiananmen Square Student Leader Urges Joe Biden to Call for an End to China’s One-Child Policy

A growing chorus is urging Joe Biden to revise and extend his remarks about China’s one-child policy.

“At best,” Joe Biden’s comments over the weekend at Sichuan University were “a statement of ambiguity that gives permission to China to continue its brutal and coercive birth planning policy,” says Chai Ling, founder of All Girls Allowed. “At worst, it is an endorsement of the exorbitant fines, severe beatings, and forced abortions and sterilizations that are performed on thousands of Chinese families every day — an ongoing Tiananmen massacre every hour,” she continues. Chai Ling, who I cite in my syndicated column on China’s one-child policy, which turns 31 this September, led students in democracy protests in Tiananmen Square in 1989.

Chai points to a woman named Wujian who was “dragged out of hiding while pregnant, had an 8-inch needle forcibly injected into her fetus, and whose 5-month-old fetus was then removed piece by piece by a doctor for China’s ruthless family planning police. Another mother, Xiao Aiying, testified on video immediately following her own forced abortion — her 8-month-old dead fetus still in her stomach.” More here. Wang Wang Jiamei’s second daughter was confiscated from her arms by family-planning officials simply because she refused to submit to tubal ligation surgery. Even the New York Times has covered the abduction of children by Chinese family-planning enforcers.

The 31st-anniversary mark provides an opportunity. “The vice president should be calling for its end,” Chai Ling urges:

The Chinese government originally promised it would last no longer than 30 years. Rather than ‘fully understanding’ the policy, the White House should heed the cry of 400 million children — the number of lives that the Chinese government boasts it has prevented. Rather than ‘fully understanding’ the policy, our administration should stand up on behalf of the 37 million Chinese girls who are missing as a result. Rather than ‘fully understanding’ the policy, American officials should consider this: If a rising China today does not have this basic respect of its own citizen’s lives, what will happen tomorrow when China becomes the world’s superpower? President Obama and Vice President Biden should act now to stop this injustice and secure a more peaceful future for America.

“If indeed it is the White House’s position to condone the one-child policy’s coercive enforcement, then our leaders are either ignorant of the cruel truth, spineless to confront the Chinese government, or cold-hearted to ignore the cries of thousands of mothers who have neither choice nor life,” she adds. “But, if the vice president’s statement was interpreted incorrectly, then we call on him and the White House to issue a statement clarifying their position and demanding an end to the one-child policy, not only on the grounds of its sustainability, but also on the grounds of its inhumane violation of basic women’s rights. May America truly be a city on a hill whose light cannot be hidden, and may she defend freedom and justice everywhere.” 

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   6

EXPAND  

DonM
   08/23/11 11:24

There is no "growing chorus," until it is said on CNN and in the NY Times. Otherwise, it falls down the memory hole with other inconvenient truths that don't fit the narrative.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   08/23/11 11:53

There is a difference between someone who is trying their best to get to utopia and a utopian who is claiming that it doesn't exist.

The student may as well have been talking to the tank.

Oh, and Biden is an idiot, and a national embarrassment.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Harpoon
   08/23/11 12:19

No wonder libs love China. Like their older siblings who went misty eyed with the USSR, the current crop has an intellectual crush on China. Technocrats/wannabes on a power trip.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Antoinette
   08/23/11 12:59

And another member of the Obama administration admires the dictators in China. I am beginning to wonder, is Jonah paying these people to prove his thesis in "Liberal Fascism"? Or is he maybe offering them a percentage of the sequel deal?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
brad2
   08/23/11 15:02

For a scary eye opener, I recommend reading the comments on the far left HuffingtonPost about Biden and the one child policy.

It's pretty frightening seeing so many out there basically saying "What's the problem? We should have a one child policy here!"

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   08/24/11 12:22

As one trenchant reviewer has commented in another separate but closely related, Chai Ling is a coward and hypocrite who enticed and allured other young demonstrators in the center of the Square only to be butchered by the communist army thugs while she herself fled to safe place prior to the suppression and massacre kicked in. Now it seems she is active in US and making a fortune with splashy and suspicious deeds. I believe her dark record of self-promotion and callousness to her claimed comrades give me ample ground to doubt her motive and her words which strike me as merely high-sounding, sanctimonious claptrap and drivel of a charlatan. From her quoted statement, the paragraph of smaller sized letters, one can't help wondering how is China with a vast populace already self-righteous, rancorous, intolerant and jingoistic enough to which a dozens of millions of newly brainwashed, aggressive and West-hating population are to be added will turn out to benefit this world and "secure a more peaceful future for America". Give me a break!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact