Last night, Egypt’s U.S.-supported armed forces ruthlessly crushed a protest against religious repression. The mayhem that erupted in the Maspero section of Cairo on Sunday was horrifying both in terms of its carnage and for what it signals about the Egyptian state’s intolerance of the country’s Christian Coptic community.
So far, between 25 and 35 people have been documented killed and hundreds wounded in violence that broke out when the Egyptian army brutally dispersed a crowd of Coptic Christians, gathered in front of the state broadcasting building to protest against a church burning in Aswan on September 30. The protest was a reflection of the Coptic community’s growing despondence after a rash of mob attacks directed toward the country’s Christian minority since the January 25 revolution — and their frustration with the military caretaker government that has been largely indifferent to their complaints.
With last night’s violence, that earlier indifference has turned to complicity and direct hostility. The army appears to have suppressed this protest with unrestrained violence — one amateur video from the scene includes footage of a military vehicle careening through the crowd — and early reports suggest that they were joined by armed local thugs who were either out to teach a lesson to the Christians (who had the audacity to demand equality as Egyptian citizens), or were paid to do so. Security personnel were among the casualties, and as of this writing it is unclear who assailed them or how, since there is no evidence that the Coptic protestors were armed.
Regardless, by Monday morning, Egypt awoke to the aftermath of violence that has now left more Copts dead than the New Year’s church bombing in Alexandria.
The caretaker government’s public reaction to the Maspero violence may precipitate worse things to come. Prime Minister Essam Sharaf blamed the events of Sunday night on “invisible hands” — which he did not care to further define — seeking to divide the country. This may appear to be an impromptu deflection of responsibility, but it is in fact a carryover practice from the Mubarak era, in which any Muslim–Christian tensions (on those rare occasions they were even acknowledged) were blamed on “foreign elements.”
This stance has allowed the increasingly toxic sectarian atmosphere in Egypt to fester and intensify, and at this crucial and tense moment, the Prime Minister’s indifference may indeed turn into incitement. It is almost certain that rumor-driven anti-Christian mobs, such as the one that led the church burning in Aswan on Sept. 30, will take his ominous words of “invisible hands” as license to terrorize the Copts. The Copts, who comprise ten percent of Egypt’s population of 80 million, now find themselves crushed between Salafi and other ultra-conservative forces seeking to “put them in their place” from below, and a ruling military demonstrating from above that its patience for public demonstrations does not extend to non-Muslims demanding equal treatment in their own nation
The Egyptian Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) must move quickly to prevent this overnight violence from spreading and to cut off possible reprisals against Coptic Christians throughout the country. It must prosecute the drivers of the military vehicle who ran over the protesting Copts and other members of the security forces who used abusive force against the protestors. At the highest levels, U.S. officials must be firm in informing Egypt’s military that the American people will not allow its foreign aid be used for religious cleansing of the nation’s long-beleaguered Coptic minority.
— Kurt J. Werthmuller is a research fellow at the Hudson Institute’s Center for Religious Freedom.
NPR was reporting this morning that the Christians apparently took weapons from the soldiers at the site and began firing, or something similar to that. That sounds unlikely to me, but that's what was being reported.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseHere's hoping our President speaks out on this (even if only out of Machiavellian self-interest).
Thanks, NRO, for reporting. Keep it up!
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI second Will's comment. Good to see NRO following this.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThe last two presidents have been an absolute catastrophe for Near Eastern Christians.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThese are just the wages of Islam.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseSo much for "The Arab Spring." Who would have expected it?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI have sympathy for any minority religion stuck in a muslim country BUT
Some of the footage I saw on the 'peaceful' protest included rock throwing, cars on fire, etc. Just because they are Christians and are in a horrible situation doesn't make me impulsively side with them when their actions may not have been supportable.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThis is what always happens to anyone who isn't muslim, or even isn't the right kind of muslim, in a muslim country.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThere was good reason not to be bullish on Mubarak. But look what's happened in the wake of his leaving? Maybe we ought to restore benign neglect as one of the arrows in the quiver of US foreign policy?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI can just but only pray and hope that the Christian in that country would begins to work in Gods wisdom to overcome the contention of the enemy
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseJust what did the idiots (McCain are you listening) and Obione expect? For Egypt, the saving grace is that they have a stable military but probably do not want to expend political capitol on saving the minorities. After all, they let their C in C hang out to dry.
Now lets extrapolate all of this to the Liybian case....one truly screwed up mess and which is only going to go from bad to worse. The ONLY place for minorities is Israel and we are working on destroying the one and only democratic safe haven in the region.
No doubt all to plan as a result of that stupid 'call to arms' speech from Obione in Cairo....what else would one expect from someone who bows to the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseToo bad about the Christians, but that's what happens when you run out of Jews to kill. Looks like being good Egyptian patriots wasn't enough. Cheer up - when they're done with you, they'll kill each other over which end of the egg to open.
What to do?
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse1. We make Egypt a puppet state (like Iraq and Afghanistan) and give them even more money... to be stolen (how is Mrs. Arafat doing lately?).
2. Well, certainly the Christian Arabs will help them, like Lebanon? Hello?
3. We pay for all of them to come here and live in my neighborhood. Not to be rude, but that's not going to happen no matter what the State Department says. If they need to re-settle any more "refugees" they can live in the Pentagon.
Excuse me, but do you have any background understanding of the position of Christians in the Middle East? You're comments are smug and uninformed.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse