Still More Gardasil Math

by Robert VerBruggen

The CDC is recommending that boys receive the HPV vaccine in addition to girls.

I previously calculated that if you vaccinated all girls at $360 a pop, you’d spend about $75,000 for every case of cervical cancer you prevented — and that’s not counting doctors’ fees (the vaccine requires three shots to be given in separate appointments, as well as, sometimes, follow-up appointments). That might be a good investment for a parent or a young woman — but considering the financial state our governments are in and the fact that HPV risk is largely a function of the sexual choices one makes, it’s probably not the best way for a government to spend that money.

Only about half as many men as women get cancer from HPV, so if you vaccinated all boys, you’d be spending about $150,000 per case before doctors’ fees — assuming that the vaccine works against head and neck cancers, which are by far the most common HPV-related cancers in men, and which the vaccine is not proven to prevent. And like cervical cancer in women, HPV-related cancers in men are usually curable. Once again, we have a vaccine that deserves to be on the market, and that parents, patients, and doctors should carefully consider, but that the government should stay away from.

The Corner

The one and only.