Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

Lawless Hospital . . . and State Hospital

To follow on Matt Bowman’s post, I am hoping Governor Christie will assert himself on this issue of forcing nurses to perform abortions. The University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey is a state institution, created by the state legislature in 1970. And, as Matt asserts, it is a lawless hospital — and not just because coercing nurses to assist abortions against their conscientious objections is a blatant violation of state and federal law. Historically, UMDNJ is a corrupt institution.

Not long ago, UMDNJ was the target of a federal investigation involving Medicare fraud, no-bid contracts (sometimes entailing no work, either), illegal campaign contributions and lobbyist payments (a no-no for a public institution), and thoroughly politicized decision making (as opposed to judgments made on the basis of sound medicine). You can read some of the gory details here. As is common in cases involving corporate entities — where an indictment would be a death-warrant, inevitably harming innocent employees as well as the actual wrongdoers — the United States Attorney for New Jersey opted to offer UMDNJ a deferred prosecution agreement. The U.S. Attorney’s name was Chris Christie. In the now-governor’s customarily blunt style, he had this to say at the time (December 2005):

It is my policy to inform targets of a federal investigation that they are targets. Now I’m here to tell you that the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey is a target of a federal investigation. I have enough evidence to indict the university.

We no longer have any faith in your ability to fix any of the problems that have led to the conduct in the case.

But let there be no mistake about it and I want to tell each one of you face to face — if we cannot reach an agreement [on the terms of a deferred prosecution], I will do my job and prosecute this entity.

It is not my intention to be critical of Governor Christie. To the contrary, I can attest that he has been a very busy, basically sleepless guy the last several days — a real champ in riding herd over the public utilities that are over-stretched trying to deal with the aftermath of a storm that turned out to be very damaging and left hundreds of thousands of people without power. For all I know, the situation at UMDNJ has not been brought to his attention yet.

Nevertheless, this is a very serious matter, made all the more so by the fact that the hospital has a history of criminality and of currying political favor. As Matt points out, UMDNJ is heavily reliant on federal funding from what is the most militantly pro-abortion administration in history. (According to the UMDNJ website, the amount is about three times the staggering $60 million per annum that Matt posits. UMDNJ represents that in fiscal year 2010, federal agencies provided 46 percent of its whopping $372.5 million in external funding awards — apparently including two-thirds of its $195.7 million in external research funding awards.) With respect, I’d suggest that the governor must assert himself, light a public fire in his inimitable way under the right derrieres, and make sure both that these nurses’ freedom of conscience is protected and that the people who put this noxious policy in place are held accountable. 

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   9

EXPAND  

Annie G.
   11/02/11 18:33

This added information explains a lot about the arrogance of telling nurses they must assist in abortions despite the illegality. They've been flouting the law every other way and getting away with it. Disgusting.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/02/11 20:03

This another Rubicon on Christie's path to future national office as a Republican. Will he follow his pro-abortion bias and minimize/overlook the severity of UMDNJ's transgressions, as happened concerning the murderous abortion clinic in Philadelphia? Or will he demonstrate leadership and intellectual honesty to clean up the cesspool there?

In any case, the lawsuit filed by the injured nurses will certainly not benefit New Jersey's budget problems.

I agree that he has had his hands full with the fallout of global warming for the past few days, but if his staff does not notify him of this corruption and at least issue a statement in his name soon, that will also be an indication of a lack of leadership and direction.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/03/11 00:18

nurses’ freedom of conscience?

Is that really how the priorities are ranked: your declaration made under oath to get your State license places below whatever cult you're following this week?
Do you really believe that abortion is the only little personal quirk that merits protection ("I'll do this, but not that")?
Has anyone found a stipulation, waiver, exception, etc. in their nursing license, the State Board requirements, or the individual contract with the hospital that allows them to do or not do as instructed? No? Then the choice is pretty simple: do the job you signed up for, or give the money back and leave.

All that aside - this is a great idea, and the Israeli medical services should begin this practice immediately. All injured arabs should be left in the street to die since, after all, they're trying to kill their rescuers.

Isn't that what you meant?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/03/11 10:51

Didn't I read something about federal and state laws and court decisions that protected this specific right to opt out?

Yes, it's in the closing paragraphs of Matt Bowman's post of yesterday at 5:01 pm.

Glad to be of service.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Mr Conservative
   11/03/11 11:55

Oh, yeah. Sorry, we forgot. There is no fundamental difference between helping save the life of an injured Arab and killing a defenseless, unborn baby.

If the law says you have the duty to do either one, you must follow the law. (Note: I am speaking ironically.) May your conscience and your basic understanding of good and evil be damned.

Welcome to the philosophy of Ravensbruck, where "panic" is a way of life (and death). "Duty" uber alles!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Mr Conservative
   11/03/11 10:21

Many thanks are due to Andrew McCarthy for helping to bring this clear-cut violation of religious freedom and rights of conscience to the attention of Gov. Christie and the nation.

Those who love abortion and "terminating pregnancies" are undoubtedly emboldened by this administration's crusade to ensure that abortion is legal, ubiquitous, and free (i.e., paid for out of your and my hard-earned taxes).

On January 23, 2009 -- three days after taking office -- Messr. Obama reversed the Mexico City Policy which had restricted USAID from funding abortion providers overseas, including the international claw ... er, arm of Planned Parenthood. Now, Obama's Department of HHS has issued a rule that will require all Americans to pay for health insurance that includes contraceptives, including "contraceptives" that are actually abortifacients and end human lives (sorry, "terminate pregnancies").

No wonder abortion lovers at a lawless hospital such as University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey would coerce professional nurses and violate their rights of conscience and religious freedom rights. They are only following the example of America's moral leader.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/03/11 10:46

As a NJ ex-pat, I gotta love Christie's style and Andy's narrative. Pure NJ and great stuff!

Sounds like UMDNJ is trying to "fool me twice." Not a surprise.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   11/03/11 12:01

The administration has taken a hands off attitude to far more corruption in the hospital industry than you know. Nationally, hospitals are aggressively buying up doctors, trying to run independent doctors out of business, and are borrowing billions under municipal bond programs to fund lavish and costly hospital facilities. Some of this money is being directed elsewhere, but there is little interest in chasing it. Hospitals are also "farming the codes" for revenue, meaning they are hiring consultants to find the best reimbursement codes for medicare/medicaid reimbursement.

All of these things will lead to more costly and less effective care, but the Obama administration believes that getting control over 5000 hospitals in the USA...effectively even fewer, if you consider one group may own many hospitals...is worth the corruption. Mandating abortions is one thing...wait until they start mandating who gets what treatment based on the fine print in Obamacare.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Mr. Bird
   11/04/11 11:54

I think you are over-generalizing. Due to regulation, physicians are coming in from the cold. They are embracing the cover of large systems with infrastructure to handle non-clinical operations. And the only borrowing through municipal bonds would be by public hospitals. Private, not for profit hospitals are doing more with less, and are expecting that trend to continue. They are not evil as a group.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact