Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

Vandal, as a Proper and a Common Noun

Speaking of VDH, you should read his powerful piece from the homepage yesterday, “A Vandalized Valley,” where he reflects on the unraveling of order in our largest state:

I am starting to feel as if I am living in a Vandal state, perhaps on the frontier near Carthage around a.d. 530, or in a beleaguered Rome in 455. Here are some updates from the rural area surrounding my farm, taken from about a 30-mile radius. In this take, I am not so much interested in chronicling the flotsam and jetsam as in fathoming whether there is some ideology that drives it. …

A couple now in their early 90s lives about three miles away from me on their small farm. I have known them for 50 years; he went to high school with my mother, and she was my Cub Scout leader. They now live alone and have recently been robbed nine, yes, nine, times. He told me he is thinking of putting a sign out at the entrance to his driveway: “Go away! Nothing left! You’ve already taken everything we have.” Would their robbers appreciate someone else doing that to their own grandparents? Do the vandals have locks on their own doors against other vandals?

There is indeed something of the Dark Ages about all this. In the vast rural expanse between the Sierras and the Coast Ranges, and from Sacramento to Bakersfield, our rural homes are like stray sheep outside the herd, without whatever protection is offered by the density of a town. When we leave for a trip or just go into town, the predators swarm. …

There is, of course, a vague code of silence about who is doing the stealing, although occasionally the most flagrant offenders are caught either by sheriffs or on tape; or, in my typical case, run off only to return successfully at night. In the vast majority of cases, rural central California is being vandalized by gangs of young Mexican nationals or Mexican-Americans — in the latter case, a criminal subset of an otherwise largely successful and increasingly integrated and assimilated near majority of the state’s population. Everyone knows it; everyone keeps quiet about it — even though increasingly the victims are the established local Mexican-American middle class that now runs the city councils of most rural towns and must deal with the costs. …

The influx of over 11 million illegal aliens has had a sort of ripple effect that is rarely calibrated. Sixty percent of Hispanic males in California are not graduating from high school. Unemployment in rural California runs about 20 percent. There is less fear now of arrest and incarceration, given the bankruptcy of the state, which, of course, is rarely officially connected even in small part to illegal immigration. Perhaps because illegal immigration poses so many mind-boggling challenges (e.g., probably over $20 billion lost to the state in remittances, the undermining of federal law, the prejudice shown against legal immigration applicants, ethnic favoritism as the engine of amnesty, subterfuge on the part of Mexico, vast costs in entitlements and subsidies), talking about it is futile. So most don’t, in fear of accusations of “racism.”

I’ve just started the sequel of sorts to A Canticle for Leibowitz, set in a post-apocalypse Southwest just beginning to emerge from the new Dark Age. But Walter Miller had it all wrong. We’re not going to blow ourselves up; we’re just going to lie back and let vandalism overtake us.

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   13

EXPAND  

 cab
   12/22/11 12:34

Hanson's essay is apt, brilliant, and terrible in its truth. I recommend it to everyone: if you live in California, you need to come to grips with this situation.

If you don't live in California, this state of affairs is headed your way fast.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Larry Brown
   12/22/11 17:46

"What, Me Worry?" As long as we imbecilic Californians enable a leftist governor, legislature, and culture, things will continue to get worse. "Open Borders now and forever" is what they want. The Los Angeles Times editorial board never met a tax they didn't want to raise, or an illegal alien they didn't want to pander to.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   12/22/11 12:52

For those who may think that VDH is a Republican, and therefore attack him, unless he recently changed his registration, he is a Democrat, though a fairly conservative one.

BTW, CA appears to be making some effort to get a handle on metal theft by lowering the requirement to consider stealing copper a "Grand Theft" to $250, via the passage of AB 316, which was signed by the Governor in Sept, 2011.

External Link 

I'm so glad I left the Bay Area for NV a few years ago.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   12/22/11 13:03

I don't know if "there is some ideology that drives [vandalism]." Desperate people do desperate things. But there is an ideology that enables it. By creating desperate people in the first place, and tolerating their behavior in the second. This ideology resides in the White House today.

d(^_^)b
External Link 
“Because the Only Good Progressive is a Failed Progressive”

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
 cab
   12/22/11 16:50

I wouldn't assume that vandalism is caused by desperation. A hefty portion is likely selfishness and criminality.

If the bands of metal thieves wandering the Central Valley of California were desperate, they could, along with millions of other illegals, *get a job*, since nobody cares (officially) if they are entitled to work here or not.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
C. P. Pela
   12/22/11 13:08

A simple measure of this decline which I have applied across the country is the increasing incidence of litter. In the last 10 years we have gone from a fairly litter free country to a landscape of empty bottles, fast food wrappers, and just plain trash. I put this off to the same vandalization--not quite as traumatic, but certainly a canary in the coal mine.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
nobookcontract
   12/22/11 13:13

>A couple now in their early 90s lives about three miles away from me on their small farm. I have known them for 50 years; he went to high school with my mother, and she was my Cub Scout leader. They now live alone and have recently been robbed nine, yes, nine, times. He told me he is thinking of putting a sign out at the entrance to his driveway: “Go away! Nothing left! You’ve already taken everything we have.”

These are the people nobody cares about. Like the Americans hiding in their homes along the southern border (Steyn has written on their plight), they can listen fearfully to the vandals passing through the night but can do nothing. Certainly their government does not care. Perhaps these people might yet get something out of this, some kind of education re-imbursement or whatever, since it is not their fault. But now, they can scarcely even be mentioned in passing. Without Steyn, VDH, or Krikorian we would not hear of these people -- even in NR. They just don't count, their lives are of no significance. I hope I didn't offend any independents by writing that.

Over to you Kevin. Kevin? Kevin D. Williamson . . . ? Okay, over to you, Christian. Christian? Christian Schneider . . . ?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
MarkJ
   12/22/11 15:39

The rate things are going, I suspect we'll be seeing a lot of more vigilantism in Mr. Hanson's corner of the world. Why spend time hassling with the police and courts when one can quickly and simply make a metal thief conveniently "disappear"?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
dsawy
   12/22/11 16:05

VDH speaks the truth. The Southwest is being overrun with these wonderful illegal immigrants who are celebrated by the likes of GW Bush and his political tool Rove.

Perhaps the editors and pundits at the WSJ and NYT would sing a different tune if this sort of situation were dumped upon their posh habitats in NYC and on Long Island...

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
elim
   12/22/11 17:11

LInda Chavez says VDH is a liar. All Mexicans are hard working non-criminals looking with high moral values. VDH's story is impossible to accept as true. In fact, these are just the voters who will accept Republican small government values. Did I miss any of the tripe she peddles?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Mr. Sandmich
   12/23/11 12:39

That, sir, is an insult to tripe. Of course more appropriate words would be...unacceptable,

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Anonymouser
   12/22/11 17:20

Hanson's bemoaning about crime in California is nice and all, but not supported by, you know, actual facts. Crime is down in the state and down dramatically since the early 90s.
External Link 

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   12/22/11 21:44

There was a period somewhat like today in recent American history: The mid-1960s through the early 70s. People (especially the segregationist south and later the campus young) began taking the law into their own hands. Back then it was about civil rights and later the war; today it is more about the economy. But the political climate was ugly then, and it is ugly now.

The civil rights struggle was successful, but at great cost. Coarseness, lawlessness, and violent, nearly-nonstop attacks on traditional American values (nonviolent protest and law-and-order, to name two) became widespread. Both the segregationist right, and (later) the left tried to use extra-legal means to bully their way into accomplishing their goals.

We sometimes forget that there was a strong counter-reaction by ordinary Americans to these excesses on both extremes. Racism on the right was crushed, and today is truly vanishingly small (at least on the right). The lawless excesses of the left, however (and, admittedly, residual racism) led to a close three-way Presidential race as late as mid-October, 1968. But not everyone who voted for Wallace was a racist. At the last minute, George Wallace's support faded, and Hubert Humphrey nearly caught Richard Nixon. But it was a much closer thing than those who did not live through it realize.

Today, the economy and differing views about big government (not race) are the major issues, and the worst of mob violence has diminished. But if the ruling establishment believes that there is no seething discontent just beneath the traditional political surface; well, their outlook for the 2012 political landscape is very different from mine. I think we had better all pray for an continually-improving economy, and yet hope at the same time that Americans are intelligent enough not to re-elect a far-left President.

That looks like a tough needle to thread. I am not particularly optimistic that collegiality and rationality will prevail. Individual liberties are once again at risk.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact