I’m cleaning out my browser tabs and had noted an outrage piece from Tuesday’s Times that has a solution no one seems to have proposed. Entitled “Nowhere to Go, Patients Linger in Hospitals, at a High Cost,” it features an illegal alien who’s been living free in medical facilities for the past five years:
Five years ago, Yu Kang Fu, 58, who lived in Flushing, Queens, and was a cook at a Chinese restaurant in New Jersey, was dropped off by his boss at New York Downtown Hospital, a private institution in Manhattan, complaining of a severe headache. Mr. Yu was admitted to the intensive-care unit with a stroke.
Within days, he was well enough for hospital personnel to begin planning for his release, but as an illegal immigrant (he had overstayed a work visa a decade ago), he was ineligible for health benefits. And no nursing home or rehabilitation center would take him. Neither would his son in China nor the Chinese government, although the hospital volunteered to fly him there at its expense.
This kind of thing happens a lot, and this last sentence suggests the solution. The Chinese government is one of many around the world that either flat out refuses to take back its illegal aliens from the U.S. or slow-walks the paperwork and delays as much as possible. They are, of course, free to do so. But we are free to respond, after suitable warnings, by suspending the issuance of visas to anyone from that country. Or we could even send a graduated message, by suspending student visas first, then, if there’s no progress, suspending tourist visas, and so on. It would, after all, be irresponsible to continue admitting people who, if they overstay or commit crimes, we won’t be able to send back. You’d be surprised how quickly those governments would change their tune if we did that.
But guess what? The State Department just keeps issuing visas to countries like this, apparently in the belief that keeping foreign governments happy is more important than the problems of those rubes back in America-land. As unpopular as they might be with many conservatives, I have a lot of respect for the State Department officers in the field; but this is a policy matter to be decided in Washington, and I’m afraid that the people directing our foreign policy, regardless of the administration, just don’t see the American people as their customers, the defense of whose interests is the only reason to have a foreign policy.
Actually, start with official (i.e., diplomatic) visas and follow that with high-finance-and-such visas, then student visas, then other work visas, and finally tourist visas.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseOK, that was funky. It simultaneously made it look like I had posted, yet had not posted. I apologize for the double-post.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseActually, start with official (i.e., diplomatic) visas and follow that with high-finance-and-such visas, then student visas, then other work visas, and finally tourist visas.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseUnder state law, hospitals are not allowed to discharge patients to shelters or the street.
Well there is the problem right there. This wouldn't be much of a problem in a sane world. I am surprised this scam isn't more widespread in NY. Get sick, get admitted, and have free food and healthcare for life! Just make sure you are homeless first. Gotta love perverse incentives.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseBroccoli, Romney will fix all this. I mean, no doubt this can't happen in Mass under RomneyCare, right? Right? RIGHT?
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseThis is a sad day if we're forced to choose between Obama and Obama Lite.
The patient lived somewhere before his illness and he can just go back there. It cannot be the hospital's responsibility to house patients - if as Broccoli says, it is, then we are really in trouble - oh yes, we are... I guess hospitals should start acquiring or building low income housing projects.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWhy just pick on the State Department. Linda Chavez has the same contempt for those who have the temerity to complain about situations like this. Why, according to her, identity theft is actually a boon for the person whose identity is stolen. If this immigrant's medical treatment costs a million, LC would tell you tough luck.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseHe was dropped off by his boss? Have the employer pay! Couple 7 figure medical bills later they might stop hiring undocumented workers.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseUS universities would complain about such a policy. Chinese students, unlike native-borns, generally pay full fees, which makes them valuable recruits.
External Link
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWhy doesn't the hospital transport the patient down to Foggy Bottom and leave him in the lobby. I bet he would be back in China in no time.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseI think the US should send illegal aliens back to tourist destinations in their home country. Send "tourist" Yu Kang Fu to Beijing to see the Forbidden City. Similarly, send Mexican illegal aliens to Mexican tourist resorts like Cancun.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWould we really be punishing China's government by denying Chinese people visas? Is the Chinese govt really that eager to have their top students/talent leave the country? I think you're just punishing those individuals. The problem is that Western compassion is boundless and, ultimately, probably unsustainable.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWow.
This comment by Kirkorian is a great example of how one's mind can turn to complete mush when you obsess exclusively on one issue.
We really should start a diplomatic war with China, of all countries, over something like this?
Never mind that we seek and need China's cooperation on Iran and North Korea. Never mind the growing economic ties between the United States and China. Never mind the number of economic and scientific advantages we get from issuing student visas. Never mind China's growing influence in the continent of Africa, Asia, and elsewhere. Never mind that China owns much of our national debt.
No, this single issue, which is trivial when you consider the bigger picture, should be a basis for us starting a diplomatic war that will likely greatly harm our own interests.
Wow. Just wow.
The complete lack of perspective or any sense of proportion makes you wonder what motivates someone to obsess over immigration anyway, focusing nearly exclusively on the negatives.
Someone who cannot understand both costs and benefits has no business anywhere near policy.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseWhat pray do you mean by a diplomatic "war"? China refuses to take their own freakin' citizens back, and we in turn refuse to take people from there - also their own citizens?
It's up to the Chinese to play by the rules WRT American immigration law. If China won't take its own citizens back we should deny their students, their temporary workers, their vacationers, their workers coming here to drum up business, their industrial spies, their pregnant women here to give birth to anchor babies, and all the rest.
Only in crazyland does it make since to continue to allow in people from a country that won't play by the rules.
We are going broke because of insane policies like the one Mr. Krikorian describes, and you think he's the crazy one? Oy...
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseProbably a better punishment of China would be to threaten to prevent the repatriation of their brightest students who come here with the intent to return to China. "Oh, you want Dr. so-and-so to come back so he can revolutionize your energy sector? Well...you gotta take this other guy too."
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse