There’s a really fascinating piece on Margaret Thatcher and her relationship to Jews in Tablet. Here’s the open:
When asked about her most meaningful accomplishment, Margaret Thatcher, now embodied by Meryl Streep in the biopic Iron Lady, did not typically mention serving in the British government, defeating the Argentine invasion of the Falklands, taming runaway inflation, or toppling the Soviet Union. The woman who reshaped British politics and served as prime minister from 1979 to 1990 often said that her greatest accomplishment was helping save a young Austrian girl from the Nazis.
In 1938, Edith Muhlbauer, a 17-year-old Jewish girl, wrote to Muriel Roberts, Edith’s pen pal and the future prime minister’s older sister, asking if the Roberts family might help her escape Hitler’s Austria. The Nazis had begun rounding up the first of Vienna’s Jews after the Anschluss, and Edith and her family worried she might be next. Alfred Roberts, Margaret and Muriel’s father, was a small-town grocer; the family had neither the time nor the money to take Edith in. So Margaret, then 12, and Muriel, 17, set about raising funds and persuading the local Rotary club to help.
Edith stayed with more than a dozen Rotary families, including the Robertses, for the next two years, until she could move to join relatives in South America. Edith bunked in Margaret’s room, and she left an impression. “She was 17, tall, beautiful, evidently from a well-to-do family,” Thatcher later wrote in her memoir. But most important, “[s]he told us what it was like to live as a Jew under an anti-Semitic regime. One thing Edith reported particularly stuck in my mind: The Jews, she said, were being made to scrub the streets.” For Thatcher, who believed in meaningful work, this was as much a waste as it was an outrage. Had the Roberts family not intervened, Edith recalled years later, “I would have stayed in Vienna and they would have killed me.” Thatcher never forgot the lesson: “Never hesitate to do whatever you can, for you may save a life,” she told audiences in 1995 after Edith had been located, alive and well, in Brazil.
In the past two or three years, I have made many public comments that have gone a little out of their way to talk about Jews in contemporary politics in the same indelicate style that I talk about any other cohort of the population. Frankly, I have found it increasingly difficult to have a general feeling of warmth toward a group that, on the average, lines up so reliably on the side of the socialist Democrats who are trying to destroy this country. (Of course, the 25 percent of the Jews who are not part of our national problem are way disproportionately represented among my favorite people.) I don't think that it is particularly respectful of Jews to pretend not to notice them when talking about the Christian Right, Working-class Catholics, Southerners, Soccer Moms, gays and straights, etc., etc.
All of that bluntness aside, the Holocaust more than any other event in modern history has informed and shaped the moral sensibilities of us all. I am troubled that the vividness of these events may be fading for younger generations. I hate it when people smugly say that any reference to Nazis is a thread-ender as though we should somehow set-aside what is, and always should be, the central moral lesson and cautionary tale for all of us. I am thrilled to hear this story about Mrs. Thatcher. She is pitch-perfect in her sense of what is most profoundly important.
(Just happened to have watched The Pianist this week...a few years late on that one.)
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseIt's a shame Thatcher didn't feel the same empathy for Catholics.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseYes, I remember many stories about Thatcher's pogroms against the Catholics. Moron.
Reply to this commentLinkReport AbuseMoron? Clearly you need to look in a mirror. And study your history. Thatcher's disdain for Catholics contributed to her mishandling of the Irish troubles. This tragic flaw in her character resulted in the loss of many, many lives. She didn't institute the anti-Catholic pogram (your choice of word,) but she clearly exacerbated conflicts that stretched back over centuries.
Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse