Get FREE NRO Newsletters

 

June 11 Issue  |  Subscribe  |  Renew

Close

New on NRO . . .

The Corner

The one and only.

Print   |  Text
 

Scientific Anniversaries

A couple of notable scientific anniversaries this year:

The Michelson-Morley experiment, the decisive one, was conducted in the spring and summer of 1887, just 125 years ago this year. By any reckoning one of the most important scientific results ever (and replicated many times since), Michelson-Morley established that the speed of light in vacuo is the same in any direction regardless of one’s motion through space, and therefore that there is no such stuff as space. As one of my own professors explained the new understanding to us very helpfully: “Space is what stops everything from being in the same place.”

Alan Turing’s centenary falls on June 23. I shall have much, much more to say about that in a review of George Dyson’s new book in an upcoming issue of National Review.

New on The Corner. . .


COMMENTS   15

EXPAND  

History Buff
   02/23/12 12:27

I believe children should be exposed to the alternative theory of "etheric space"...so that modern, secular so-called "physics" isn't rammed down their throats by a bunch of atheist quantum mechanicists.

Besides, everybody knows that Michelson and Morley were high-paid stooges of the socialist environmentalists.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Hah Bumbug
   02/23/12 12:29

Cool factoid: The captcha for this comment is "math test."

The Michelson-Morley experiment was a form of null result, in that it showed that the Earth's movement through space did not affect the relative speed of light. That was unexpected. But it would have been the expected result, if the Earth were immobile whilst the rest of the universe moved around it, as thought by many through the Middle Ages.

I cannot recall the name of the experiment, but it is possible to demonstrate that Earth rotates using physical principles: Put water with some suspended particles (whose motion can be detected by reflected light) in a toroidal, transparent, sealed container. Orient it parallel to Earth's equator. Let it sit for awhile. Then, abruptly turn it over (flip the toroid). It will be seen that the water is rotating. This is because in prior equilibrium it rotated along with the Earth, but suddenly its direction of rotation is opposite to the Earth.

Now, imagine that the Michelson-Morley experiment had been performed FIRST. At the time, it would have been interpreted as proof that the Earth does NOT move through space, and that something such as Ptolemaic theory was correct!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/23/12 12:34

BREAKING NEWS: Error Undoes Faster-Than-Light Neutrino Results:

External Link 

Thanks God !

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Hah Bumbug
   02/23/12 16:17

The related headline, for one of the online news services, was that the error could just as well mean that the neutrinos went even faster than originally reported!

Speaking of cable connection errors: In one recent production of Goetterdaemmerung (such as in San Francisco last year), the Norns manipulate cables in what appears to be an electronic switching facility. There is a cable problem.

Thank Wotan!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/23/12 12:41

We don't take too kindly to that scientifical talk 'round these here parts, savvy?

Well, that's what I was told by the Left, anyway.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/23/12 12:45

“No such ‘stuff’ as space”?

No such “stuff” as ether, when I went to school.

Wasn't the landmark importance of Michelson-Morley the discovery that light (and other “electromagnetic waves”) needed no medium for their propagation?

In other words, empty space is, indeed, empty — not filled with the theorized but never-observed “ether,” whose putative existence was definitively disproved by this experiment.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
wpa38
   02/23/12 12:53

The Italian neutrino experiment should have learned something from Michaelson-Morley. When you set up an experiment involving two locations 70 miles apart, traversing two different paths between those locations, with lots of unknown stuff standing between the locations on those two paths, and using RADIO WAVES BOUNCING OUT INTO SPACE as part of your timing mechanism..... Someone should have stopped this mess before it even started. There was no possible way to calibrate such a mess within a few milliseconds, let alone the picoseconds required.

MM showed the right way to do such an experiment. Lay out the whole thing on one compact solid 'table', able to rotate in all directions, with complete visibility and supervision of all paths.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/23/12 13:00

In a related bit of history, 2012 is the 40th anniversary of the first "ethernet" device. The name ethernet was derived from the "luminiferous ether" (the "stuff" from Derb's post) which Michelson-Morley disproved the existence of in their famous experiment. The Xerox employees used "ether"net to describe the physical medium (cables) that transported digital signals...as scientists once thought the luminiferous ether transported E-M waves.

This feels like an Episode of "Connections", that great BBC show created/hosted by James Burke. "And that is how Aristotle made the internet possible." (Aristotle first proposed the "ether".)

My college roomie and I used a variation of the M-M experiment to show that interferometry could be used to identify low-frequency vibrations in objects. We had to do a lot of dampening because (as we often joked) if somebody dropped a Tic-Tac on the 3rd floor, we knew about it in our basement lab. Such was the sensitivity of the device we built. We identified a beat frequency from the addition and cancelation of interference patterns which we demonstrated was mathematically linked to the frequency of the vibrating object we positioned on one leg of our M-M device. Our original plan was to use fluid scattering and build a probe-free mini wind tunnel. But the proof of concept was good enough to get us published in the Undergrad Journal of Research in Physics ('94).

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/23/12 13:25

Your college experience sounds like an episode of The Big Bang Theory. Are you more Sheldon or Leonard?

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/23/12 13:01

Alas, all knowledge of the Michelson-Morley experiment is slowly disappearing into the aether.

(Sorry - couldn't resist that one.)

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
Solano
   02/23/12 13:05

Turing was driven to suicide by homophobia.
The 50s are still remembered as a time when values still had meaning.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/23/12 15:42

Ah, Alan Turing. He was one of the key people in winning World War II. He was thanked for his heroics...and for his science that changed all our lives...with torture at the hands of his government, with a government-mandated chemical castration because he was homosexual.

But I am sure Derb thinks that was just fine treatment. Ironic that he would mention dear Alan, who finally committed suicide when he could no longer bear the torment he was enduring from society, since earlier today Derb was mocking the very idea of condemning someone for tormenting a gay man until he offs himself.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/24/12 09:57

I love the way gay activists;
1) Have to drag their obsession into every single discussion.
2) Can't be bothered with accurately describing the position of those who oppose them.

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/23/12 17:57

Ah, the old Michelson-Morley experiment...I learned about it in the Army!

In 1966, I was at Fort Dix, New Jersey undergoing a stimulating and scary -- but intellectually rather light -- course of study called, "AIT Infantry."

To amuse myself, I had a nifty papebpack book that taught all you could want to know about electronics in a mere three or four hundred pages. (I had the recurring fantasy in my early life that electronics was something you could study by reading. Imagine my surprise when I later learned that there was math involved, too!)

It was a good book, but I didn't really learn much electronics from it. The thing that I really remember, though, was the Michelson-Morley experiment. Those were the days...when guys were guys and gals were gals and profound physics experiments were understandable and fired the imaginations of average guys. (A popular song on the barracks radio that summer was Frank Sinatra's "Strangers in the Night," which was particularly poignant for guys who were not likely to have any exciting romantic encounters in the night -- at least they hoped they wouldn't.)

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse
   02/24/12 08:50

Glad to see Alan Turing getting some recognition in NRO. A docudrama about him was broadcast in the UK in November and will soon be released in the States. More details here: External Link 

Hopefully many more people will soon come to recognize his contributions!

Reply to this commentLinkReport Abuse

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.


The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


* Designates a required field.
© National Review Online 2012
All Rights Reserved.
Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital

Gift Subscriptions
NR / Print
NR / Digital
NR Apps
iPhone/iPad
Android

NRO Apps
iPhone
Support Us
Donate
Media Kit
Contact